15 Peacock Original Movies That Are So Good You Need to Watch Them Again
Peacock has carved out a unique space in the streaming world with its original movies that hook you from the start. From laugh-out-loud comedies to chilling thrillers, these films pack a punch and keep you coming back for more.
Each movie on this list is a Peacock original, meaning it was produced directly by them, not just licensed from another studio. We’re diving into 15 released films that deserve a second watch, each with its own flavor and story to pull you in.
Psych 2: Lassie Come Home (2020)
This comedy brings back the beloved duo Shawn and Gus from the ‘Psych’ series for a wild ride. When Santa Barbara’s police chief Carlton Lassiter gets ambushed, the pair dives into a case blending humor, heart, and a touch of the supernatural.
The mix of sharp wit and goofy charm makes this a comfort watch we can’t get enough of. It’s perfect for a night when you want laughs and a light mystery to unravel.
Psych 3: This Is Gus (2021)
Shawn and Gus return in this hilarious follow-up, tackling a new adventure before Gus’s big wedding. They’re on a mission to find Selene’s missing husband while Lassiter wrestles with his career’s future.
The chemistry between the leads and the over-the-top ‘groomzilla’ moments keep this film endlessly rewatchable. It’s a fun, chaotic romp that delivers every time.
Five Nights at Freddy’s (2023)
This horror flick dives into the creepy world of a haunted pizzeria where animatronics come alive. A security guard’s night shift turns into a fight for survival against these eerie machines.
The jump scares and tense atmosphere make it a thrill worth revisiting. It captures the game’s spooky vibe perfectly, pulling you back to face the frights again.
The Killer (2024)
John Woo’s action-packed remake follows an assassin facing a moral crisis in a gritty underworld. Zee, played with intensity, navigates betrayal and redemption in a high-stakes game.
The sleek fight scenes and emotional depth keep you glued to the screen. It’s a movie that rewards rewatching for its layered story and stunning visuals.
They/Them (2022)
Set at an LGBTQ+ conversion camp, this horror blends social commentary with slasher chills. Teens face unsettling psychological tactics and a masked killer stalking the grounds.
The mix of real-world issues and genre thrills makes it gripping on repeat viewings. It’s a bold, eerie ride that sticks with you long after the credits roll.
Sick (2022)
This pandemic-era horror follows two friends quarantining at a lake house, only to discover they’re not alone. A masked intruder turns their isolation into a deadly game.
The tight pacing and relatable fears hit hard, making it a great rewatch for horror fans. Each viewing reveals new details in its tense, compact story.
Meet Cute (2022)
In this romantic comedy, Sheila uses a time machine to relive a perfect date with Gary, tweaking it to fix his flaws. But her meddling unravels deeper truths about love and choice.
The quirky premise and heartfelt moments make it a gem to revisit. It’s a fresh spin on rom-coms that feels new every time.
The Silent Twins (2022)
This drama tells the true story of twin sisters June and Jennifer Gibbons, who retreat into their own world, communicating only with each other. Their bond leads to a complex, tragic path.
The haunting performances and emotional weight make it a film you’ll want to revisit. It’s a deep dive into a unique story that lingers.
Honk for Jesus. Save Your Soul. (2022)
This satirical comedy follows a Southern Baptist megachurch couple rebuilding their congregation after a scandal. Their over-the-top efforts to save face are both hilarious and biting.
The sharp humor and standout performances make it a joy to rewatch. It’s a clever take on faith and ambition that keeps you laughing.
The Independent (2022)
A young journalist uncovers a conspiracy that could sway a historic presidential election. This political thriller keeps you guessing with its twists and high stakes.
Its fast-paced plot and timely themes make it worth revisiting. Each watch reveals new layers in its smart, suspenseful story.
The Sit-In: Harry Belafonte Hosts The Tonight Show (2020)
This documentary captures a historic week in 1968 when Harry Belafonte hosted ‘The Tonight Show.’ It highlights his interviews with civil rights leaders and cultural icons.
The blend of history and entertainment makes it endlessly compelling. Rewatching uncovers new insights into a pivotal moment in TV.
Shooting Stars (2023)
This sports drama chronicles LeBron James’s high school basketball days with his childhood friends. It’s a story of friendship, grit, and chasing dreams against the odds.
The inspiring performances and underdog vibe make it a great rewatch. It’s a feel-good film that hits every time.
Praise This (2023)
A rebellious teen joins a competitive gospel choir in this musical comedy. Her journey from outsider to team player is filled with catchy songs and heartfelt moments.
The vibrant energy and uplifting story make it perfect for repeat viewings. It’s a joyful celebration of music and redemption.
Genie (2023)
In this festive comedy, a workaholic dad gets help from a magical genie to save his family’s Christmas. The chaos and heartwarming moments create a holiday classic.
Its charm and humor shine brighter with each watch. It’s a cozy pick for any time you need a dose of holiday cheer.
Drop (2025)
This intense thriller follows Violet, whose date takes a dark turn when mysterious threats force her into a life-or-death choice. The stakes climb fast in this nerve-wracking ride.
The relentless suspense and clever twists make it a must-rewatch. It’s a gripping story that keeps you on edge every time.
Which of these Peacock originals is your go-to for a rewatch, or is there another gem we missed? Drop your thoughts in the comments!
