James Gunn Snaps Back at ‘Lanterns’ Critics, and His Hal Jordan Death Tease Just Blew up the Internet

‘Lanterns‘ has spent the past several weeks becoming one of HBO’s most talked-about series of the year, mixing prestige crime drama with cosmic superhero mythology in a way few adaptations have attempted before. That mix of tones has made for gripping television, but it’s also opened the door to plenty of criticism from longtime comic book readers.

Much of that criticism has centered on how the show has handled Hal Jordan, the character many fans consider the definitive Green Lantern. Between the show’s willingness to bend from decades of comic canon and its shocking decision to reveal Hal already dead in the present-day timeline, some viewers have felt the character deserved better treatment.

That frustration boiled over recently when a fan directly confronted DC Studios co-CEO James Gunn online, arguing the show should “try and at least respect the characters that made the comics popular” and calling the decision to seemingly kill Hal off “the worst thing” the series could have done after fans waited years to see him back on screen. Gunn, never one to shy away from engaging with fans, responded with a lengthy and pointed defense of the show’s approach.

Gunn pushed back hard on the idea that Hal has been shortchanged, noting that the character has already appeared in every episode of the series so far. He argued that Kyle Chandler’s Hal has received more live-action screen time in ‘Lanterns’ alone than the character has accumulated across his entire history on screen combined.

“We more than respect him. We love him, despite his imperfections. Us knowing the time of his death, if that’s exactly what that is, is absolutely not the same thing as killing him off right away,” Gunn wrote, closing the reply by noting that Hal remains a major reason the show has connected with both fans and newcomers alike.

That phrase, “if that’s exactly what that is,” has quickly become the focal point of the exchange. It’s a small but pointed piece of wording that suggests Gunn may be leaving the door open for more nuance in Hal’s arc than the show’s grim premiere initially implied.

‘Lanterns’ kicked off with a gut punch of an opening, revealing Hal Jordan dead in the present-day timeline, apparently from a gunshot wound, with his Green Lantern ring conspicuously missing from the scene. That missing ring has since become one of the show’s central mysteries, fueling ongoing fan speculation about how the story will ultimately resolve his fate.

Gunn didn’t stop at defending Hal’s screen time and treatment. He also addressed the broader complaint that ‘Lanterns’ isn’t a faithful adaptation of the source material, arguing that television doesn’t need to treat the comics as untouchable scripture.

He compared the show’s creative liberties to the way both DC and Marvel have repeatedly rebooted and reimagined their most iconic characters over the decades. It’s an argument Gunn has leaned on before when defending the DCU’s approach to long-established comic book lore.

Reaction to Gunn stepping directly into the discourse has been mixed, to put it mildly. Some viewers have applauded him for engaging seriously with criticism instead of ignoring it, appreciating the transparency about the creative reasoning behind Hal’s arc.

Others have pushed back on the exchange itself, arguing that a studio executive publicly sparring with critics sets an uncomfortable precedent, regardless of how thoughtful the actual response is. It’s added yet another layer to a ‘Lanterns’ controversy that already touches on the show’s tone, its mature content, and its broader deviations from Green Lantern’s comic book roots.

The trailer for 'LANTERNS' Episode 7 has arrived!

Premieres September 27 on HBO Max. pic.twitter.com/29VKRBR8Gd

— DC Film News (@DCFilmNews) September 21, 2026

Whether Hal Jordan’s death proves to be as final as it initially appeared remains to be seen, but Gunn’s wording has already sent fans into overdrive theorizing about what comes next. With John Stewart still searching for answers and that missing ring still unaccounted for, ‘Lanterns’ shows no signs of slowing down the mystery anytime soon.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments.