Why Disney Executives Panicked Over Johnny Depp’s Jack Sparrow Before ‘Pirates of the Caribbean’ Hit Screens
Few movie characters are as inseparable from their actor as Johnny Depp’s Jack Sparrow. The slurring, swaggering pirate headlined the 5 ‘Pirates of the Caribbean‘ films released from 2003 to 2017, and the franchise has collectively grossed $4.5 billion at the worldwide box office.
It is easy to forget that the performance was once a very big gamble. Depp was not exactly an obvious fit for a studio like Disney, since by late 2000 he was not known for starring in big-budget, family-friendly movies.
Now a new look behind the curtain shows just how nervous the Disney brass were when they first saw what Depp had in mind. The Hollywood Reporter has published an exclusive excerpt from a new biography titled ‘The Many Faces of Johnny Depp’, in which the producers of ‘Pirates of the Caribbean’ recall their shock at his unusual vision for the character.
The excerpt centers on Dick Cook, who had risen from a ride operator at Disneyland to become head of the studio over the course of 30 years. Cook was a company man, and Depp was anything but. His agent Tracey Jacobs and her boss, UTA chairman Jim Berkus, wanted to set up a meeting between the actor and Cook.
Cook revealed only the title of the project, ‘Pirates of the Caribbean’, and confirmed it was based on the ride. Afterward, Depp told Jacobs the studio was going to make a movie about the ride and that he had said he wanted to be in it.
Depp kept quiet about his plans for Sparrow as the project moved forward. He eventually found himself back on the Disney lot in Burbank for a hair and makeup test on Stage 2.
Then came the moment of truth, when Depp finally presented his vision for the character to a gathering of Disney executives. According to the excerpt, the reaction was alarm, with executives wondering aloud whether Sparrow was supposed to be drunk and what exactly the character was meant to be. Depp’s answer was simple, and as recalled in The Hollywood Reporter‘s excerpt, he told them, “You just got to trust me.”
The panic is not entirely new, since Depp has spoken about the studio’s nerves in the past. Depp has described how former Disney chief Michael Eisner said the actor was ruining the film, and he has also said he made an effort to be a punk rock actor since he started doing films.
Producer Jerry Bruckheimer has also described the tension. In an interview with Deadline, Bruckheimer reportedly said the studio had expected a classic swashbuckler in the mold of Burt Lancaster or Errol Flynn, and that Depp’s gold teeth and rock-inspired mannerisms left executives confused. The team assembled a short clip from his early footage, and after seeing it, executives began to understand what he was doing.
That compromise reportedly involved removing a few of the gold teeth while keeping the heart of the character intact. Depp modeled his performance on Keith Richards, a choice that did not appeal to some executives at the time.
The timing of the excerpt is notable. Depp’s new film ‘Ebenezer’ is his first major movie role in 8 years, following ‘Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald’ in 2018, and he has another film lined up with Lionsgate, the action thriller ‘Day Drinker’, co-starring Penélope Cruz.
Meanwhile, Disney has been contemplating another ‘Pirates of the Caribbean’ movie. Depp has said he is open to returning as the chaotic captain, while Bruckheimer has confirmed he has spoken with the actor about a new ‘Pirates’ movie.
For a studio that once worried it had a problem on its hands, the irony is hard to miss. The same performance that reportedly set off alarm bells became the face of a billion-dollar franchise.
Were Disney executives right to be concerned about Johnny Depp’s Jack Sparrow performance?
Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!
