‘The Body’: Are Anya and Elise Gay, and Are Kristina Bogic and Sara Boustany Queer in Real Life?
Netflix’s supernatural teen thriller ‘The Body‘ premiered on November 11, 2026, pulling viewers into a moody 2004 world of Catholic guilt, high school hierarchy, and dance-team devotion. Set at St. Mark’s Catholic High School, the story follows Lions co-captains Anya Butler and Elise Zakaria as a Halloween initiation spirals into townwide panic. Amid the mystery, audiences have wondered whether Anya and Elise are gay and whether stars Kristina Bogic and Sara Boustany are gay or bisexual in real life.
Created by ‘Under the Bridge’ filmmaker Quinn Shephard alongside co-showrunner Gina Gammell and executive producer Riley Keough, the eight-episode drama quickly climbed into Netflix’s global Top 10 charts. Ahead of production in Ontario, Canada, Deadline reported that 11 recurring cast members, including Ashley Madekwe, Motell Foster, and Cale Ambrozic, joined series leads Bogic, Boustany, Geena Meszaros, and Sofia Wylie. Critics praised the series, earning it an 85% score on Rotten Tomatoes.
Are Anya and Elise Gay in ‘The Body’?
Inside ‘The Body’, Anya and Elise share a sapphic romance that turns intimate in the premiere episode, though neither character adopts a strict label like gay or bisexual during the first season. Shephard, who told Netflix’s Tudum she began writing the script the year she came out, designed the show around “some of the trauma of growing up queer and repressed and the confusion around that”. Even though both teens initially mock lesbians to protect their popularity, their private moments reveal genuine longing.
For Anya, confronting her attraction collides with deep Catholic guilt and compulsory heterosexuality. She stays with her devoted boyfriend, Steven Maxwell, despite feeling unfulfilled, and pushes Elise away whenever things turn serious. Speaking to Elite Daily, Bogic explained that she researched “comphet” for the role and noted, “I genuinely don’t think Anya would ever say she’s a lesbian, which is why she’s so repressed and feels so much guilt”.

Elise is far more comfortable with her attraction to women and seeks an open romantic relationship with Anya. As Boustany explained in an interview with Teen Vogue, “Elise has a better sense of self,” adding, “That’s why Anya makes so many mistakes; she’s too caught up in what other people think”. Boustany also confirmed to MovieWeb that Elise previously had feelings for classmate Grace Franklin.
Reflecting on that dynamic for Tudum, Boustany said, “I think Elise’s character and arc are for the people who’ve experienced an unrequited love with someone who isn’t ready to take on a journey of self acceptance and discovery, which is sadly common in queer relationships”. By the finale, Anya’s cover-up of Grace’s overdose shatters their trust, and Elise walks away.
Are Kristina Bogic and Sara Boustany Gay or Bisexual in Real Life?
Off-screen, neither Kristina Bogic nor Sara Boustany has publicly identified as gay, lesbian, or bisexual. Both actresses keep their personal dating lives and sexual orientations private, separating their off-screen privacy from their candid discussions of queer storytelling. Still, both performers have spoken enthusiastically about bringing Anya and Elise’s relationship to life.
For 19-year-old Australian actress Bogic, whose earlier credits include ‘Playing Gracie Darling’ and the queer coming-of-age short film ‘Howl’, ‘The Body’ marks a breakthrough American role. Addressing their intimate scenes with Teen Vogue, Bogic said, “You’d think those scenes with Sara would be daunting, but we actually had a great time,” adding, “We trusted each other so much, and it was really nice having a set that was mostly women, especially on the creative team”.
Boustany, a Lebanese-American actress known for ‘PEN15’, ‘Dolly Parton’s Heartstrings’, and ‘Hello Beautiful’, originally auditioned for Anya before casting director Jennifer Venditti pivoted her toward Elise. Once paired over Zoom, Boustany told Teen Vogue that reading with Bogic felt “electric”. That trust carried onto set, where both actors pitched their own floor blocking for Anya and Elise’s first intimate moment.
While Netflix has not yet renewed ‘The Body’ for a second season, both stars remain eager to revisit their characters’ bond. Speaking in an Interview Magazine conversation, Bogic remarked, “You see their dynamic as friends, but I would love to see Anya and Elise have more best friend moments,” while Boustany playfully joked, “Everyone, start kissing now”.
Tell us in the comments whether you hope Anya and Elise get a second chance in a potential second season of ‘The Body’, and share your favorite moment from Bogic and Boustany’s performances.
