‘Obsession’ Star Inde Navarrette Names the Other ‘X-Men’ Role She Would Have Been Excited to Play Alongside Rogue
Few actors have had a year like Inde Navarrette‘s. After a breakout turn as Nikki in Curry Barker’s horror hit ‘Obsession’, she went from familiar face to one of the most talked-about names in Hollywood. Now she is preparing to step into one of Marvel’s most beloved mutant roles as Rogue.
The announcement came at D23, where Kevin Feige revealed the main cast of the ‘X-Men’ reboot. Navarrette joins Sadie Sink as Jean Grey, Kit Connor as Cyclops, Samara Weaving as Emma Frost, Maya Boyd as Storm and Christopher Abbott as Professor X. Adam Driver rounds out the lineup as Mister Sinister.
Even with the role locked in, Navarrette has been asked which other X-Men character she would have been excited to play. According to a new ELLE interview, her answer was Professor X, and she explained it with a joke about the appeal of a character who gets to sit down all day. She then half-apologized for saying it out loud.
It is a funny pick on the surface, but there is a real connection between the two characters. In the comics, Rogue was raised by Mystique and recruited into the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants. She initially fought the X-Men as an antagonist before seeking Professor X’s help.
That history matters, because Xavier is the person Rogue turns to when she needs to control her powers. Her ability lets her temporarily absorb the powers and memories of anyone she touches, which makes that guidance essential. If the reboot leans on the same dynamic, Abbott’s Xavier and Navarrette’s Rogue could become one of its key relationships.
Abbott himself brings a very different résumé to the part. Forbes notes his credits include ‘The Crowded Room’, ‘James White’, ‘It Comes at Night’ and ‘Possessor’, and argues his casting points to a more complex Xavier than the gravitas of Patrick Stewart or James McAvoy. That could make his scenes with a young Rogue feel less like a lecture and more like a negotiation.
Inde Navarrette on which X-Men character she would have been excited to play beside Rogue: “Professor X. I wanna sit down all day. Is that bad to say? I don’t think so. I’m so sorry if that is.” (via @ELLEmagazine) https://t.co/rhDgUm56cp
— Cosmic Marvel (@cosmic_marvel) November 17, 2026
Navarrette’s Xavier answer is the latest in a string of memorable comments about the franchise. Before D23, she told Variety that she had met with director Jake Schreier and named Mystique as a dream role. In hindsight, that looked like a misdirect, because Rogue turned out to be the character she was playing.
She later told Collider that the Mystique answer wasn’t a lie. According to her, she was dropping hints, since Mystique’s shapeshifting mirrors Rogue’s ability to take powers through contact. Nobody picked up on it at the time.
Navarrette has been open about how seriously she is taking the part. At the Governors Awards on November 15, she told E! News that she is working on Rogue’s Southern accent and wants to visit Mississippi as part of her prep. She even slipped into the drawl with a playful “sugah.”
She has also spoken about looking forward to stunt training and about the character’s legacy. Anna Paquin played Rogue in the earlier X-Men films, and Navarrette said she feels a connection to Paquin that goes back to her childhood, though the two haven’t spoken. She has described the opportunity as an honor.
Not everyone was thrilled when the casting was revealed. The choice divided some fans after she had publicly set her sights on another mutant, and others debated whether her fame from ‘Obsession’ was enough to carry a franchise role. Still, plenty of commentators see her as a strong pick for the part.
Reports claim Navarrette passed on at least 2 other major projects, including Michael Mann’s ‘Heat 2’, to take on Rogue. The reboot is set to hit theaters on May 5, 2028, after the Multiverse Saga finale. Before that, the earlier X-Men cast will make a final appearance in ‘Avengers: Doomsday’ on December 18, including Patrick Stewart as Professor X.
Which X-Men character would you have been most excited to see Inde Navarrette play?
Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!
