Kevin Feige Explains Why He Brought Robert Downey Jr. and Chris Evans Back to the MCU for ‘Avengers: Doomsday’

Marvel Studios / Depositphotos
Share:

When ‘Avengers: Endgame’ ended, it looked like the book had closed on the two actors who built the MCU. Tony Stark gave his life, and Steve Rogers passed the shield to Sam Wilson. Yet the Robert Downey Jr. and Chris Evans return is now one of the biggest talking points ahead of ‘Avengers: Doomsday’.

Marvel’s own history made this a surprise. Kevin Feige told Vanity Fair in 2023 that the studio would keep Iron Man’s final moment and never want to magically undo it. When Hugh Jackman returned as Wolverine, Feige said it proved a comeback for Downey or Evans could be done, but only if great care was taken.

Now Feige has explained the thinking behind the decision. He argues that legacy in this universe is not a one-and-done affair, because storytelling, mythology and Marvel itself don’t work that way. In his view, stopping was never really an option.

RELATED:

Pedro Pascal Reveals the Surprising Bond Between Reed Richards and Doctor Doom in ‘Avengers: Doomsday’

The plan didn’t happen overnight. At CinemaCon, Feige described the Downey relationship as one of the closest the studio has, saying they kept seeing each other after ‘Endgame’ while the idea of a reunion went unspoken for years. Around early 2023, the team began to feel it could really work, and Feige then pitched Downey in person. The pitch happened at Downey’s home.

Downey isn’t returning as Iron Man, though. He plays Victor Von Doom, and Feige has said the studio didn’t want to simply bring Tony Stark back. Reports from Feige’s Chinese press interview also say he settled on Downey after watching ‘Oppenheimer’.

Evans’ return followed a different path. He told Entertainment Weekly at San Diego Comic-Con that Marvel had been trying to bring him back since ‘Endgame’, but none of the ideas felt right. Downey’s return became the deciding factor.

At CinemaCon, Evans also said he would only return if there was a real reason. Joe Russo told Fandango that the team found a path forward that required both actors for the story to be told. Russo also argued that the right way to bring Evans back was to continue Steve’s story rather than do something else with the role. Anthony Russo told Empire that the story can’t work without Steve’s central role, and Evans himself claimed on stage that the heroes in ‘Doomsday’ need Steve Rogers.

Fans have worried that the casting is a trick. Speaking to Empire, Feige addressed the popular theory that Doom is a Tony Stark variant. He compared it to Evans’ return, asking whether Steve Rogers is a Johnny Storm variant, and said Doom is simply Victor Von Doom.

The comparison points to Evans’ earlier turn as the Human Torch before he became Captain America. The comments appear in Empire’s 22-page ‘Avengers: Doomsday’ package, which also features interviews with the Russo brothers, Downey, Evans and Chris Hemsworth.

Not everyone is convinced. Some critics argue the returns are a calculated nostalgia play, pointing to the contrast with Tony’s sacrifice. One Syfy writer also viewed Downey’s casting, Evans’ return and the Russo brothers’ hiring as signs of strain, though he noted they can make the franchise easier for casual viewers to follow.

Feige has pushed back on the buildup complaint. At San Diego Comic-Con, he argued that Thanos’ early setup was modest and that ‘Doomsday’ is Doom’s real introduction, which he described as peeling the onion. The film is meant to work for fans who know Doom from the comics and for newcomers alike.

The Russo brothers say they returned only after finding a story they felt was worth telling, and they have described it as a beginning. Feige has also said Marvel has films planned all the way to 2042, and that ‘Avengers: Secret Wars’ is meant to close older storylines while setting up the future.

‘Avengers: Doomsday’ opens on December 18, and the trailer reportedly drew 503 million views at launch. Whether the strategy pays off will depend on whether the story justifies the reunion.

Do you think bringing Robert Downey Jr. and Chris Evans back to the MCU is a smart move?

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!

Don't miss:

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted