‘The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth’ Draws Backlash Over Alleged Generative AI in Key Scenes

Netflix
Share:

When ‘The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth‘ was announced, it sounded almost too strange to be true. Quentin Tarantino was bending his own 10th-and-final-film rule, and he wrote a continuation that would be handed to David Fincher to direct. The combination also reunited Brad Pitt with two filmmakers who have consistently brought out his best work.

The film stars Pitt alongside Elizabeth Debicki, Scott Caan and Yahya Abdul-Mateen II, and it spins off from ‘Once Upon a Time… in Hollywood.’ Early reviews have pushed its Rotten Tomatoes score to 84%, a Certified Fresh rating. It debuts on Netflix on Dec. 23 after a limited IMAX run.

Not every reaction has been glowing, though, and one criticism is now driving the conversation. Giovanni Lago of Next Best Picture says Fincher uses generative AI in key moments of the film. The review calls the result distracting and questions the choice to use the technology at all.

RELATED:

‘The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth’ Gets Its Rotten Tomatoes Score, but Does It Top ‘Once Upon a Time in Hollywood’?

In his review for Next Best Picture, Lago describes the generative AI as “noticeably distracting” and labels it an eyesore. He argues that the cinematography otherwise establishes a strong visual language for Fincher’s take on the material. That contrast makes the alleged AI moments stand out even more.

He notes that whenever Jeff Cronenweth steps in as cinematographer for reshoots, the shift is noticeable, since Erik Messerschmidt otherwise shot the film. Messerschmidt shot on digital rather than celluloid, and some critics praise his grainy, ’70s-style cinematography. The AI criticism therefore targets specific scenes instead of the film’s overall look.

Viewers online have echoed the complaint, and some said they were surprised the issue had not been mentioned in reviews. Some have even listed timestamps where they believe the technology appears, and others have criticized the filmmakers for risking their reputations.

There is an important caveat. Nobody involved with the movie has publicly confirmed the alleged AI usage. Everything circulating so far stems from critics and viewers interpreting what they saw on screen.

Fincher has spoken about artificial intelligence before, and his remarks have been nuanced. He has expressed skepticism about whether the technology can replicate the personal touch that makes art meaningful. In an interview with British GQ, however, he called AI a really powerful tool.

In a conversation with the Los Angeles Times, he said he is not a Luddite and does not fear the unknown when asked about generative AI. That stance may explain why the allegation feels surprising to some fans and unsurprising to others. It also keeps the debate open until the filmmakers address it.

The timing also lands amid a larger industry shift. Netflix recently used generative AI to create a building collapse scene in the sci-fi show ‘El Eternauta.’ CEO Ted Sarandos has said generative AI won’t just make the streamer’s content cheaper to make but better, too. Netflix also became the first major player to publish a rulebook for generative AI in production.

‘Further Mis-Adventures’ will mark the final film Fincher makes for Netflix, completing a three-picture contract put in place in 2020. Under that deal, he also directed ‘Mank’ and ‘The Killer.’ That gives the film extra weight as the end of a significant creative partnership.

Sony boss Tom Rothman told Variety the project ended up at Netflix because Tarantino was not comfortable with anyone but Fincher directing his script. Fincher is exclusive to Netflix, so Sony would not stand in the way. Fincher has also said that one of the first big calls on the project was whether Tarantino’s script should become a film or a series.

Outside the AI debate, the response is largely positive. Critics generally praise the film as a fun, relaxed hangout movie with a cool, confident Pitt performance. Elizabeth Debicki and Scott Caan receive strong praise, while the plot is widely described as thin and slow to build toward a violent, spectacular finale.

Opinions are split on whether it surpasses the original. Several critics also say the film does not offer enough large-scale visuals to justify the IMAX format. For a movie with this much pedigree, the visual questions may end up shaping its legacy.

Does alleged generative AI use hurt your interest in The Further Mis-Adventures of Cliff Booth?

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!

Don't miss:

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted