The 10 Most Overrated Video Games That Fell Short

Video games often spark heated discussions among players, with some titles gaining massive followings. However, not every hyped-up game lives up to its reputation, leaving many fans disappointed.

I’ve compiled a list of 10 games that, despite their widespread acclaim, don’t fully justify the praise. These games aren’t terrible, but their flaws make their lofty status questionable.

10. ‘Fortnite’ (2017)

‘Fortnite’ exploded onto the scene with its vibrant battle royale and cultural crossovers. Its accessibility and constant updates drew millions, making it a global phenomenon.

Yet the gameplay loop of shooting and building grows stale fast. The heavy focus on microtransactions and pop-culture skins often overshadows any depth the game could offer.

9. ‘Call of Duty: Black Ops II’ (2012)

‘Call of Duty: Black Ops II’ earned praise for its branching campaign and fast-paced multiplayer. Its futuristic twist felt bold, and it became a fan favorite.

The story, though, lacks emotional weight, and multiplayer sticks to repetitive formulas. The grind for unlocks and microtransaction push also dampens the experience.

8. ‘God of War: Ragnarok’ (2022)

‘God of War: Ragnarok’ was celebrated for its stunning visuals and emotional story. Kratos and Atreus’ Norse adventure won awards for its cinematic flair.

But the combat feels too familiar to its 2018 predecessor, lacking fresh ideas. The bloated open world, packed with filler side quests, drags down the pacing.

7. ‘Final Fantasy VII’ (1997)

‘Final Fantasy VII’ is often hailed as a groundbreaking RPG with iconic characters like Cloud and Sephiroth. Its influence on the genre is undeniable.

The plot’s twists can feel convoluted, and the blocky graphics age poorly. Combat lacks the strategic depth of later RPGs, making battles feel repetitive.

6. ‘Death Stranding’ (2019)

‘Death Stranding’ was lauded for its bold vision and unique world. Hideo Kojima’s story, paired with Norman Reedus’ role, promised something groundbreaking.

The core gameplay—delivering packages across barren landscapes—feels monotonous. Quirky mechanics, like weaponized bodily fluids, come off as more bizarre than fun.

5. ‘Dragon Age: Inquisition’ (2014)

‘Dragon Age: Inquisition’ won fans with its expansive world and deep characters. BioWare’s storytelling earned it high praise and awards.

The open world, however, is stuffed with repetitive fetch quests. Combat feels clunky, straying from the series’ tactical roots, disappointing longtime players.

4. ‘Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots’ (2008)

‘Metal Gear Solid 4’ was celebrated for concluding Solid Snake’s story. Its cinematic cutscenes and stealth gameplay earned near-perfect scores.

But lengthy cutscenes dominate, leaving little room for actual play. The stealth feels simplified, with action-heavy options reducing the challenge of earlier entries.

3. ‘BioShock Infinite’ (2013)

‘BioShock Infinite’ impressed with its vibrant city of Columbia and companion Elizabeth. The visuals and narrative ambition won critical acclaim.

The shooting mechanics feel generic, lacking innovation. The story’s complex themes get tangled, leaving players more confused than satisfied by the end.

2. ‘Tetris’ (1984)

‘Tetris’ is a cultural icon, praised for its addictive puzzle design. Its simplicity made it a staple across countless platforms.

The unchanging formula grows repetitive quickly, lacking the depth of modern puzzle games. Its legendary status feels more nostalgic than deserved.

1. ‘Grand Theft Auto V’ (2013)

‘Grand Theft Auto V’ is often called a masterpiece for its massive open world and three-protagonist story. Its online mode keeps players hooked years later.

But the single-player campaign feels bloated with repetitive missions, and the story’s tone swings wildly. The online grind and microtransaction focus also frustrate many players.

Which game do you think gets more praise than it deserves, or did I overlook one? Share your take in the comments!