Awesome Amazon Prime Original Series Nobody Talks About (But Should!)

Amazon Prime Video has a huge library of shows, but some gems get lost in the shuffle. While hits like ‘The Boys’ and ‘Reacher’ grab the spotlight, many original series fly under the radar despite their quality storytelling, unique ideas, or stellar casts. These shows deserve more love for their fresh takes, bold choices, or emotional depth.

Whether you’re into thrillers, comedies, or anime, there’s something for everyone in this list of overlooked Amazon Prime originals. From quirky character-driven tales to intense dramas, here are 15 series that need to be on your watchlist. Let’s dive in and discover these hidden treasures.

Dead Ringers (2023)

This psychological thriller stars Rachel Weisz as twin gynecologists pushing the limits of fertility science. The show, a remake of David Cronenberg’s film, dives into obsession and a toxic sibling bond with a creepy, unsettling vibe. It’s bold, visually striking, and doesn’t shy away from grotesque imagery. Weisz’s dual performance is a standout, carrying the show’s eerie tone.

Despite critical praise, ‘Dead Ringers’ didn’t get the buzz it deserved, likely due to its niche subject matter and lack of promotion. It’s perfect for fans of dark, thought-provoking stories that linger long after the credits roll. If you’re into psychological horror, this one’s a must-watch.

From Old Country Bumpkin to Master Swordsman (2025)

This anime follows a retired adventurer living a quiet life in a fantasy world. When his adopted daughter, now a famous hero, pulls him back into action, the story blends wholesome family moments with epic sword fights. The animation shines during intense combat, and the heartwarming tone makes it stand out.

‘From Old Country Bumpkin to Master Swordsman’ didn’t get much hype, possibly because anime fans often overlook Prime’s offerings. With a second season already greenlit, it’s a great time to jump in. This show is ideal for those who love character-driven stories with a mix of action and heart.

Expats (2024)

Starring Nicole Kidman, ‘Expats’ follows three women in Hong Kong whose lives intertwine after a child goes missing. The series explores grief, privilege, and secrets against a politically charged backdrop. It’s a slow burn with complex characters and no easy answers, making it a gripping character study.

Despite its star power, ‘Expats’ didn’t catch on, likely due to its heavy themes and subtle storytelling. It’s a mature drama that rewards patient viewers with deep emotional payoff. If you enjoy realistic stories about human struggles, this one’s worth your time.

I’m a Virgo (2023)

This quirky series, directed by Boots Riley, follows Cootie, a 13-foot-tall Black teenager exploring the world for the first time. It’s a wild, Afrosurrealist tale that tackles capitalism, racism, and hero myths with sharp humor and bold visuals. Jharrel Jerome’s performance anchors the show’s eccentric energy.

‘I’m a Virgo’ flew under the radar, possibly due to its unconventional style and limited marketing. It’s a fresh, inventive take on coming-of-age stories that’s unlike anything else on Prime. Fans of offbeat narratives will find this a hidden gem.

Harlem (2021)

This comedy-drama follows four Black women in their thirties navigating careers, love, and identity in New York’s Harlem neighborhood. It’s fun, stylish, and packed with relatable moments, balancing raunchy humor with heartfelt scenes. The chemistry between the leads makes every episode a joy.

Despite its charm, ‘Harlem’ never got the hype of similar shows like ‘Sex and the City.’ Its focus on everyday life over dramatic twists might have kept it niche, but it’s a sharp, underrated watch. If you love female-led comedies, this one’s a winner.

One Mississippi (2016-2017)

This semi-autobiographical comedy stars Tig Notaro as a woman returning to her Mississippi hometown after her mother’s death. It tackles grief, identity, and family with dry humor and quiet revelations. The slow pace and honest storytelling make it deeply moving.

‘One Mississippi’ was canceled after two seasons and didn’t get much attention, likely due to its understated vibe. It’s a heartfelt gem for those who appreciate subtle, character-focused stories. If you’re looking for something real and touching, give this a shot.

Good Girls Revolt (2015)

Set in a 1960s newsroom, this drama follows women fighting for equality at a fictional magazine. It’s inspired by real events and captures the era’s social changes with strong performances and sharp writing. The costumes and retro vibe add to its charm.

Canceled after one season, ‘Good Girls Revolt’ never found a wide audience, likely due to comparisons to ‘Mad Men.’ It’s a compelling look at workplace sexism and ambition that deserves a second look. If you enjoy historical dramas, this one’s a must.

Too Old to Die Young (2019)

This gritty crime drama, directed by Nicolas Winding Refn, follows a cop navigating a surreal, violent underworld. Its slow pace, vivid colors, and bold style make it feel like a fever dream. Strong supporting performances add depth to its eerie vibe.

‘Too Old to Die Young’ was divisive due to its deliberate pacing and niche appeal, so it stayed under the radar. It’s a bold, visually stunning series for fans of dark, unconventional storytelling. If you love cinematic shows, this one’s worth a try.

The Last Tycoon (2017)

This drama, starring Kelsey Grammer, dives into the glamour and grit of 1930s Hollywood. Based on F. Scott Fitzgerald’s unfinished novel, it follows a studio executive navigating power struggles and romance. The lavish sets and costumes bring the era to life.

Despite its high production value, ‘The Last Tycoon’ didn’t click with audiences, possibly due to its slow pace and lack of buzz. It’s a stylish period piece that’s perfect for fans of classic Hollywood stories. Give it a chance for its rich visuals and drama.

Mad Dogs (2015)

This dark comedy follows four friends whose tropical vacation turns into a chaotic crime caper. With a mix of humor and tension, it’s a wild ride with a stellar cast, including Billy Zane. The single season wraps up neatly, making it a complete story.

‘Mad Dogs’ didn’t get much promotion and faded quickly, but its blend of laughs and thrills makes it a hidden gem. It’s perfect for fans of fast-paced, twisty shows. If you’re into crime comedies, this one’s a great pick.

Sneaky Pete (2015)

Giovanni Ribisi stars as a conman posing as a long-lost family member to pull off a scam. This crime drama mixes clever twists with family dynamics and a touch of humor. The strong cast, including Bryan Cranston, keeps you hooked.

Despite a solid run, ‘Sneaky Pete’ never became a breakout hit, possibly due to its low-key marketing. It’s a fun, smart series with a satisfying conclusion that’s great for fans of heist stories. Check it out for a thrilling ride.

The Night Manager (2016)

This tense spy thriller stars Tom Hiddleston as a hotel manager recruited to infiltrate a criminal empire. Hugh Laurie plays the chilling villain, and the cat-and-mouse game keeps you on edge. Its sleek production and gripping plot make it a standout.

‘The Night Manager’ got some praise but didn’t maintain mainstream buzz, likely overshadowed by bigger shows. It’s a polished, suspenseful series perfect for espionage fans. If you love tight thrillers, this one’s a must-watch.

Undone (2019)

This animated series follows Alma, a woman exploring her past through trippy, time-bending visuals after a car accident. Using rotoscope animation, it blends emotional depth with surreal storytelling. Rosa Salazar’s performance grounds the wild narrative.

‘Undone’ didn’t get the attention it deserved, possibly due to its unique style and quiet release. It’s a stunning mix of heart and mind-bending visuals, ideal for fans of BoJack Horseman. If you want something fresh and moving, this is it.

Homecoming (2018)

Julia Roberts stars in this psychological thriller about a social worker unraveling a conspiracy at a mysterious veteran facility. Its tight pacing, eerie tone, and Sam Esmail’s sharp direction make it a gripping watch. The first season is a standout.

Despite early buzz, ‘Homecoming’ faded from conversation, possibly due to a less impactful second season. It’s a tense, twisty series that’s perfect for fans of smart thrillers. Dive in for a compact, suspenseful story.

What’s your favorite underrated Amazon Prime original series—share your picks in the comments and let’s get the word out about these hidden gems!