Black Actresses Who Undeservedly Face Public Scrutiny

Black actresses frequently navigate a landscape where their casting announcements and personal lives draw disproportionate amounts of criticism compared to their peers. Social media platforms often become breeding grounds for intense backlash regarding their inclusion in beloved sci-fi and fantasy franchises. These performers often face critiques that focus heavily on their race or appearance rather than their professional capabilities. Examining their careers highlights the resilience required to maintain a presence in the global entertainment industry.

Halle Bailey

Bailey faced an overwhelming wave of racist trolling after Disney announced her casting as Ariel in the live-action remake of ‘The Little Mermaid’. Critics claimed her appearance did not match the original animated character despite her vocal prowess being widely praised by the production team. She maintained her composure throughout the press tour while focusing on the positive impact her role had on young Black girls. The film ultimately succeeded at the box office despite the initial attempts to boycott the production.

Leslie Jones

Jones endured a targeted harassment campaign on social media following the release of the 2016 reboot of ‘Ghostbusters’. Trolls flooded her accounts with hateful imagery and racist rhetoric that forced her to temporarily leave Twitter. She spoke out against the platforms for not doing enough to protect users from such coordinated abuse. Her career continued to flourish with stand-up specials and hosting gigs that showcased her distinct comedic voice.

Moses Ingram

Ingram received hundreds of racist messages upon her debut as Reva Sevander in the ‘Star Wars’ series ‘Obi-Wan Kenobi’. The studio and co-star Ewan McGregor publicly defended her and condemned the toxic behavior coming from a segment of the fanbase. She addressed the comments directly on her social media to expose the reality of being a Black woman in a major franchise. Her performance brought a complex intensity to the role of the Inquisitor despite the external noise.

Lashana Lynch

Lynch faced significant backlash when rumors circulated that her character in ‘No Time to Die’ would inherit the 007 title. Traditionalist fans expressed outrage at the idea of a Black woman taking over the mantle from the James Bond character. She emphasized in interviews that her character Nomi was a distinct agent who challenged the established dynamics of the franchise. Her portrayal was eventually met with critical acclaim for adding modern depth to the spy series.

Anna Diop

Diop was subjected to derogatory comments regarding her skin tone and costume when early set photos leaked from the show ‘Titans’. Fans of the comic books complained that she did not look like the orange-skinned alien Starfire they expected. She disabled comments on her Instagram account to block out the negativity while filming the first season. The actress later delivered a commanding performance that won over many skeptics as the series progressed.

Candice Patton

Patton dealt with years of harassment from a vocal minority of fans after being cast as Iris West in the CW series ‘The Flash’. Many viewers refused to accept a Black actress in a role that was traditionally white in the comic books. She openly discussed the lack of support she felt from the studios during the early seasons of the show. Her tenure as Iris West lasted for nine seasons and established her as a central figure in the Arrowverse.

Amandla Stenberg

Stenberg has faced criticism since childhood when fans of ‘The Hunger Games’ reacted negatively to her casting as Rue. The backlash resurfaced recently with her lead role in the ‘Star Wars’ series ‘The Acolyte’ where she faced review bombing. She released a song responding to the discourse and highlighting the repetitive nature of the prejudice she encounters. Her work consistently challenges societal norms and explores complex themes of identity.

Tessa Thompson

Thompson experienced scrutiny when she was cast as Valkyrie in ‘Thor: Ragnarok’ because the character was blonde and white in the source material. She also faced criticism for her role in ‘Men in Black: International’ from those who claimed the franchise was becoming too woke. She approaches her roles with a focus on representation and redefining what heroes look like in blockbusters. Her interpretation of Valkyrie has since become a fan favorite within the Marvel Cinematic Universe.

Francesca Amewudah-Rivers

Amewudah-Rivers became the target of online abuse after it was announced she would play Juliet opposite Tom Holland in a stage production of ‘Romeo & Juliet’. The theater company issued a statement condemning the deplorable racial abuse directed at a member of their company. Industry peers rallied around her to offer support and validate her talent as a dramatic actress. She continued to prepare for the role without letting the internet commentary derail her West End debut.

Leah Sava Jeffries

Jeffries was only a child when she faced backlash for landing the role of Annabeth Chase in ‘Percy Jackson and the Olympians’. The author of the book series Rick Riordan stepped in to defend her casting and told dissatisfied fans that she was perfect for the part. She handled the pressure with maturity and focused on bringing the character’s intelligence and strength to the screen. Her performance in the first season was widely regarded as a highlight of the adaptation.

Jodie Turner-Smith

Turner-Smith sparked debate when she was cast to play the English queen Anne Boleyn in a channel 5 historical drama. Critics argued that historical figures should only be played by actors of the same race while ignoring the show’s stylized approach. She expressed that her focus was on capturing the essence and humanity of the woman rather than mere physical resemblance. The series allowed her to showcase her dramatic range in a role typically closed off to women of color.

Jada Pinkett Smith

Pinkett Smith often finds herself at the center of public vitriol due to her candid discussions about her marriage and personal life. People frequently attack her character based on snippets from her show ‘Red Table Talk’ without viewing the full context of the conversations. The incident at the 2022 Academy Awards intensified the scrutiny she faces regarding her influence on her family. She continues to work as a producer and actress while maintaining a strong presence in Hollywood.

Gabourey Sidibe

Sidibe has faced relentless body shaming and cruel jokes about her appearance since her breakout role in ‘Precious’. Critics and internet trolls often focus on her weight rather than her nominations and consistent work in film and television. She responds to the hate with confidence and refuses to hide or alter her personality to appease detractors. Her roles in ‘American Horror Story’ and ‘Empire’ demonstrated her versatility beyond her debut film.

Viola Davis

Davis faced unexpected criticism for her portrayal of Michelle Obama in the series ‘The First Lady’. Viewers mocked her facial expressions and decision to purse her lips to mimic the former First Lady. She admitted that playing a living icon was terrifying and noted that critics can be incredibly harsh on artistic choices. Her illustrious career includes achieving EGOT status and delivering powerful performances in films like ‘Fences’.

Zendaya

Zendaya faced early backlash when she was cast as MJ in the Marvel Cinematic Universe ‘Spider-Man’ films. Purists were upset that the character was not the traditional Mary Jane Watson from the comic books. She has also faced critiques that suggest her success is due solely to colorism rather than her acting skills. She silenced many doubters with her Emmy-winning performance as a troubled teen in the HBO drama ‘Euphoria’.

Halle Berry

Berry faced immense ridicule for her starring role in the 2004 film ‘Catwoman’ which was a critical and commercial failure. She famously accepted her Razzie award in person to own the failure and criticize the writing she was given. Recent years have seen her fighting ageism and critics who dismiss her action roles in films like ‘John Wick: Chapter 3’. She remains the only Black woman to have won the Academy Award for Best Actress.

Tiffany Haddish

Haddish frequently draws ire for her unfiltered behavior and loud public persona at industry events. Many people find her comedy style polarizing and critique her for allegedly trying too hard to be funny. She has also faced legal and personal controversies that have turned public opinion against her sharply. Despite the noise she continues to secure roles in major films like ‘Haunted Mansion’ and voice work in animation.

Keke Palmer

Palmer faced comparisons to Zendaya that attempted to diminish her long career and suggest she was less successful. She defended her resume by pointing out she has been a lead actress in films and television for nearly two years. Social media users also scrutinized her choices as a mother and her wardrobe at public events. She utilized the attention to fuel her creative projects and maintain her status as a multi-talented entertainer.

Cynthia Erivo

Erivo garnered controversy when she was cast as the American historical figure Harriet Tubman in the film ‘Harriet’. Some critics argued that a British actress should not play an African American hero due to the specific lineage of slavery. She also faces preemptive criticism regarding her upcoming role as Elphaba in the film adaptation of ‘Wicked’. Her vocal talent and dedication to her craft have earned her awards just shy of EGOT status.

Letitia Wright

Wright faced a public relations crisis following her sharing of a video questioning COVID-19 vaccines on social media. Fans of the Marvel Cinematic Universe called for her removal from the ‘Black Panther’ franchise during the height of the controversy. She eventually returned to lead the sequel ‘Black Panther: Wakanda Forever’ where she carried the emotional weight of the film. Her performance was praised even as some viewers remained divided on her personal views.

Zoe Saldaña

Saldaña faced intense backlash for wearing dark makeup and a prosthetic nose to play Nina Simone in the biopic ‘Nina’. She later apologized for taking the role and acknowledged that she should have used her power to elevate a dark-skinned actress. Debates about her place in Hollywood often center on colorism and the roles available to Afro-Latina women. She remains one of the highest-grossing actresses of all time due to her work in ‘Avatar’ and ‘Guardians of the Galaxy’.

Whoopi Goldberg

Goldberg frequently trends on social media for her controversial takes as a moderator on ‘The View’. Her comments regarding the Holocaust led to a suspension from the show and widespread condemnation from various organizations. Critics often overlook her legendary contributions to film and comedy when focusing on her daytime television soundbites. She retains a loyal fanbase that appreciates her candor and history as an EGOT winner.

Raven-Symoné

Raven-Symoné often attracts criticism for her statements in interviews regarding her identity and name. Her rejection of labels has alienated some members of the Black community who feel she distances herself from her heritage. She grew up in the public eye on ‘The Cosby Show’ and has navigated stardom for decades. Her return to Disney Channel for ‘Raven’s Home’ showed her lasting appeal to family audiences.

Meghan Markle

Markle faced a torrent of abuse from the British tabloid press and royalists after marrying Prince Harry. The criticism often utilized coded racist language and double standards compared to other royals. Her acting career on ‘Suits’ was frequently minimized or mocked by detractors during her time in the UK. She has since pivoted to producing and podcasting while continuing to advocate for women and families.

Lizzo

Lizzo has dealt with fat-shaming and bullying throughout her rise to fame in both music and acting. Her appearance in ‘The Mandalorian’ was met with vitriol from fans who felt her cameo did not fit the tone of the show. Recent legal allegations from former dancers have further complicated her public image and invited aggressive commentary. She previously stepped back from Twitter to protect her mental health from the constant barrage of negativity.

Sophia Nomvete

Nomvete became the first Black woman to play a dwarf in ‘The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power’. Racist trolls attacked the casting choice by claiming it violated the lore established by J.R.R. Tolkien. She attended the premiere in a dress that highlighted her pride in the role despite the online harassment. Her character Disa became a standout element of the series for her warmth and commanding screen presence.

Adjoa Andoh

Andoh faced backlash for a comment she made during the coronation coverage of King Charles III about the balcony looking terribly white. The remark sparked thousands of complaints to regulators from viewers who felt attacked by her observation. She clarified that she was referring to the lack of diversity in that specific visual moment rather than attacking the individuals. Her role as Lady Danbury in ‘Bridgerton’ remains a celebrated performance that anchors the hit series.

Golda Rosheuvel

Rosheuvel plays Queen Charlotte in ‘Bridgerton’ and has faced questions about the historical accuracy of a Black queen in Regency England. Some purists argue against the diverse casting of the show despite its fictionalized nature. She embraces the role as a celebration of Black aristocracy and natural hair on a global platform. Her portrayal was so popular that it spawned a prequel series dedicated to her character’s origin story.

Tamara Smart

Smart faced skepticism and harsh reviews for her role in the Netflix adaptation of ‘Resident Evil’. Fans of the video game franchise were unhappy with the changes made to the character of Albert Wesker and his daughters. She navigated the disappointment of the show’s cancellation after just one season. She continues to build her resume with roles in other fantasy projects like ‘Percy Jackson and the Olympians’.

Ella Balinska

Balinska co-starred in the Netflix ‘Resident Evil’ series and faced the same wave of fan dissatisfaction as her onscreen sister. The script and direction were heavily criticized which often blew back onto the actors who were doing their best with the material. She previously starred in the 2019 ‘Charlie’s Angels’ reboot which also struggled to find an audience. Her physical capability in action roles remains a strong point in her growing filmography.

Dominique Thorne

Thorne received hate for her introduction as Riri Williams in ‘Black Panther: Wakanda Forever’. Some fans felt her character Ironheart was shoehorned into the plot to set up future Disney+ projects. Critics attacked the design of her suit and her character’s intellect as being unrealistic. She is set to lead her own series which aims to flesh out her backstory and silence the detractors.

Kiersey Clemons

Clemons filmed scenes as Iris West for ‘Justice League’ only to have them cut from the theatrical release. When she was restored in the director’s cut she faced the same racist resistance that Candice Patton dealt with on television. She also starred in the live-action ‘Lady and the Tramp’ which drew complaints about race-swapping human characters. She continues to take on diverse roles in independent films and major studio projects.

Samantha Marie Ware

Ware faced backlash after she accused Lea Michele of microaggressions on the set of ‘Glee’. While many supported her speaking out she also received hate from diehard fans of the show’s star. The controversy sparked a larger conversation about how Black actors are treated as background decoration in ensemble shows. She has remained vocal about industry inequities while continuing her acting career.

Amber Riley

Riley has had to defend herself against fans of ‘Glee’ who pit the cast members against one another. She has been open about the lack of solo storylines she received compared to her white co-stars during the show’s run. People often typecast her solely as a singer and overlook her acting abilities in non-musical roles. She recently won ‘The Masked Singer’ and continues to perform on stage in London and New York.

Chloe Bailey

Bailey faces constant scrutiny regarding her transition from a child star to a more mature adult image. Critics on social media frequently shame her for posting confident or revealing photos and videos. Her acting roles in ‘Grown-ish’ and ‘Swarm’ have shown her range but the conversation often returns to her public persona. She advocates for self-expression and refuses to tone down her presence for the comfort of others.

Normani

Normani faces frustration from fans and critics alike due to the long delays in her debut album release. While primarily a singer she has ventured into voice acting and faced criticism for not focusing enough on music. The internet jokes about her career stalling often cross the line into mean-spirited harassment. She continues to work on her artistry at her own pace despite the external pressure to produce content.

Susan Wokoma

Wokoma plays Edith in the ‘Enola Holmes’ films and has faced complaints about the film’s feminist and diverse reimagining of the Sherlock Holmes world. The inclusion of a Black female martial arts instructor for Enola was deemed unrealistic by some historical sticklers. She brings a sharp wit and physical comedy to the role that balances the tone of the film. Her background in British comedy has established her as a reliable scene-stealer.

Ebony Obsidian

Obsidian plays a major role in ‘Sistas’ where the writing and character choices often frustrate viewers. Fans sometimes conflate the actor with the character and direct their anger at the storylines toward her social media. She navigates the passionate fanbase of Tyler Perry productions with grace. Her performance provides a grounding element in a show known for its melodramatic twists.

Kelly Rowland

Rowland recently faced a wave of negative press following an altercation with a security guard on the red carpet at Cannes. She stated that she felt she was treated differently than other women who walked the carpet that day. Internet commenters debated her reaction and labeled her difficult without knowing the full context. She has spent decades in the spotlight and continues to star in and produce films for Netflix.

Jennifer Hudson

Hudson faced ridicule for her role in the film adaptation of ‘Cats’ due to the poor CGI and critical failure of the movie. She also faces critiques regarding her hosting style on her daytime talk show which some find too enthusiastic. Despite the hate she achieved EGOT status at a young age proving her immense talent across all mediums. Her show has been renewed and continues to gain traction with daytime audiences.

Share your thoughts on these talented actresses and their roles in the comments.