‘Clayface’ Box Office Surge Puts a $44 Million Horror Movie Ahead of ‘Supergirl’

DC Studios
Share:

DC Studios spent 2026 testing two very different strategies. In summer, it rolled out ‘Supergirl,’ a PG-13 tentpole with a big-budget price tag, and in the fall it quietly followed up with ‘Clayface,’ an R-rated body horror movie built for a fraction of the cost.

The results have not been what anyone predicted. ‘Supergirl’ was released on June 26, 2026, to mixed reviews from critics, while ‘Clayface’ arrived just before Halloween with modest expectations and a very different pitch for DC fans.

The ‘Clayface’ box office run now sits at $121.3 million worldwide after its 4th weekend, and it is about to overtake ‘Supergirl’s global total of about $126.5 million. That is a remarkable turnaround for a film that started roughly $20 million behind the summer release at the global box office.

The latest numbers show $63.6 million domestically and $57.7 million internationally across 76 markets. Overseas, the film earned $3.3 million this weekend, a 51.5% drop, while domestic grosses added $3.7 million, down 45%.

Industry trackers expect the movie to finish with a global run of $130 million to $150 million. That would put ‘Clayface’ comfortably ahead of ‘Supergirl’ as soon as next weekend.

The gap in spending is where this story gets interesting. ‘Clayface’ carries a reported production budget of $44 million, not including marketing, while ‘Supergirl’ cost between $170 million and $186 million to make.

‘Supergirl’ has since been labeled a box-office bomb, with a global gross of about $126.5 million. ‘Clayface’ has reportedly already broken even, and a solid run overseas could help push it further into profitable territory.

For a studio that needed a win, that ratio matters. The film opened to $24 million domestically from 3,458 theaters and $19 million internationally, for a $43 million global start. It took No. 1 in North America that weekend, even though its domestic debut was about 63% of the $38 million that ‘Supergirl’ opened to.

The movie then crossed $100 million globally in its 3rd weekend, reaching $109 million with $56.6 million domestically and $52.4 million internationally.

RELATED:

DC’s ‘Clayface’ Melts Past Its Budget at the Box Office, and the Numbers Beat Expectations

The movie landed an A- CinemaScore and strong marks on Rotten Tomatoes, with a 77% critics score and a 94% audience score. Those are impressive numbers for a body horror film, and they explain why it has held up better than expected in theaters.

Even so, ‘Clayface’ has not been immune to the usual drop-offs. Domestic grosses fell 38.8% in the third weekend despite the film losing 532 theaters, and more than 1,000 locations had dropped it by the start of its 4th week.

Director James Watkins knew the movie needed to be a hard-edged experience. He said he saw an opportunity to make “a really great roller coaster ride” that leaned into body horror, telling SWAGGER that he had never done a body horror film before.

The creative approach was equally important. Watkins said he could have gone even further with the gore, telling Filmhounds “I could have shown a lot more,” and described conversations with James Gunn and Matt Reeves in which they signed off on the intensity.

Tom Rhys Harries stars as Matt Hagen, alongside Naomi Ackie, Max Minghella, Eddie Marsan and David Dencik. The screenplay comes from Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini, based on a story by Flanagan.

Peter Safran said the film would avoid a campy tone and compared its style to ‘The Fly,’ while Rentrak’s Paul Dergarabedian praised DC for taking an R-rated risk.

The contrast between the 2 films makes a compelling case for smaller genre projects alongside major superhero releases. One was a summer event that struggled to justify its cost, while the other is a lean horror movie that found its audience on word of mouth.

If ‘Clayface’ passes ‘Supergirl’ next weekend, it will be a striking symbol of how DC’s fortunes can turn on budget and tone rather than brand power. Whether the studio takes that lesson into its next slate remains to be seen.

Should DC Studios make more mid-budget, R-rated films like 'Clayface' instead of relying mainly on expensive superhero blockbusters?

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!

Don't miss:

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted