DC’s Cheap Horror Gamble ‘Clayface’ Is About to Leave ‘Supergirl’ in the Dust

DC Studios
Share:

Superhero movies are no longer guaranteed hits, and DC Studios has spent the year learning that lesson the hard way. The studio’s rebooted slate has produced wildly different results, and the gap between its biggest swing and its smallest one is getting harder to ignore. The latest twist in that story involves a body horror movie about a shapeshifting Batman villain.

For the first time since 2023, DC released two movies in the same calendar year. Both are part of James Gunn’s DC Universe, but they couldn’t be more different, which includes their box office performances. One arrived with a blockbuster budget and fizzled, while the other slipped in with modest expectations.

The summer entry was supposed to be a major step for the franchise. ‘Supergirl‘ was released on June 26, 2026, to mixed reviews from critics. It was a box-office bomb, grossing $126.4 million against a production budget of $170 million to $186 million.

The final numbers were historically poor. With a final total of $125.8 million, ‘Supergirl’ became the lowest-grossing DC movie since 2004’s ‘Catwoman.’ DC Studios co-chair Peter Safran said the film did not meet the studio’s box office expectations.

RELATED:

‘Clayface’ Director Finally Addresses the Batman Scene That Never Made It to Screen

Now ‘Clayface‘ is chasing that number, and it is catching up fast. After its fourth weekend in North America, it grossed $3.7 million and took its global total to $121.3 million, while ‘Supergirl’ finished with $126.5 million. That means it is on course to pass its predecessor’s entire haul next weekend.

The film has already pulled ahead in one key area. It had already beaten ‘Supergirl’ in international box office revenue. Its international total stands at $57.7 million across 76 markets, with $63.6 million in the United States.

The turnaround is notable because the film began behind. It started roughly $20 million behind the summer release at the global box office. In the United States, it debuted at No. 1 with $24 million across 3,458 theaters, and worldwide it opened to a reported $43 million.

It also reached milestones at a slower pace than its rival. ‘Clayface’ crossed $100 million at the global box office 6 days slower than ‘Supergirl’ did. The difference is staying power, with the horror film holding better week after week.

Money is where the two films diverge most. ‘Clayface’ carries a reported production budget of $44 million, not including marketing. Other trades have it somewhere between $35 million and $44 million, because DC Studios has not revealed an official figure.

That price tag gives the movie room to breathe. GamesRadar reported that the film made its budget back in its opening weekend. Reports on break-even vary, with CBM noting the film is not expected to break even until it reaches digital and Blu-ray, so the numbers do not necessarily invite celebration.

The film itself is a departure for the studio. ‘Clayface’ is an American body horror film directed by James Watkins, with Tom Rhys Harries starring as Matt Hagen, alongside Naomi Ackie, David Dencik, Max Minghella and Eddie Marsan. Mike Flanagan wrote the story, and Matt Reeves is among the producers.

Critics were lukewarm but not unkind. GamesRadar’s 3 out of 5-star review called it DC Studios’ biggest experiment to date. The film arrived just before Halloween, which gave its R-rated pitch a seasonal boost.

The comparison is a gift for headlines, but it does not erase the studio’s problems. ‘Supergirl’ remains a major financial loss, and ‘Clayface’ is a far smaller project. Still, the results suggest audiences will turn out for genre-driven, lower-cost stories.

The contrast with the studio’s biggest hit is also striking. ‘Superman’ made the equivalent of ‘Supergirl’s entire run in its opening weekend, going on to gross $618.7 million worldwide. That gap shows how much room DC still has to grow, even as ‘Clayface’ turns a modest win into a talking point.

Should DC Studios make more low-budget horror movies like 'Clayface'?

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!

Don't miss:

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted