Excellent Amazon Prime Original Movies Nobody Talks About (But Should!)

Amazon Prime Video has a huge library of movies, but some gems get overlooked. While big hits like ‘The Boys’ and ‘Reacher’ steal the spotlight, many original films deserve more love for their unique stories, strong performances, and fresh ideas.

This list highlights Amazon Prime original movies that flew under the radar. From sci-fi thrillers to heartfelt dramas, these films offer something for everyone and are worth your time.

The Vast of Night (2020)

Set in 1950s New Mexico, ‘The Vast of Night’ is a sci-fi gem about two teens who stumble upon a strange radio signal. The story follows a switchboard operator and a radio DJ as they uncover a mystery tied to extraterrestrial activity, inspired by real events like the Foss Lake disappearances.

First-time director Andrew Patterson creates an eerie atmosphere with clever camerawork, including a stunning tracking shot. The film’s low-budget charm, sharp dialogue, and gripping pace make it a must-watch for sci-fi fans.

I’m Your Woman (2020)

‘I’m Your Woman’ is a 1970s crime drama starring Rachel Brosnahan as Jean, a woman forced to flee after her husband’s criminal ties unravel. She navigates danger and betrayal while protecting her newborn, uncovering her own strength along the way.

Directed by Julia Hart, the film flips the typical crime story by focusing on the woman’s perspective. Brosnahan’s powerful performance anchors this tense, emotional journey, making it a standout in Prime’s catalog.

Totally Killer (2023)

‘Totally Killer’ blends slasher horror, comedy, and time travel in a fun, 1980s-inspired package. Kiernan Shipka stars as Jamie, who travels back to 1987 to stop a serial killer after her mother’s murder.

The film pays homage to classic slashers while adding a sci-fi twist and sharp humor. Shipka’s energetic performance and the nostalgic vibe make this a thrilling, underseen gem for genre fans.

Everybody’s Talking About Jamie (2021)

‘Everybody’s Talking About Jamie’ is a vibrant musical drama about a British teen chasing his dream to become a drag queen. Facing bullying and prejudice, Jamie finds strength with support from his mother and a mentor.

Max Harwood shines as Jamie, with catchy songs and emotional depth driving the story. The film’s 82% Rotten Tomatoes score and strong supporting cast, including Richard E. Grant, make it a joyful, uplifting watch.

I Want You Back (2022)

‘I Want You Back’ is a sharp romantic comedy about two strangers, Peter and Emma, who team up to sabotage their exes’ new relationships. Their plan spirals into chaos, leading to unexpected personal growth and laughs.

The cast, including Charlie Day and Jenny Slate, brings charm and chemistry to this familiar but well-executed premise. It’s a fun, heartfelt film that’s perfect for a light movie night.

Sylvie’s Love (2020)

‘Sylvie’s Love’ is a romantic drama set in 1950s New York, following Sylvie, a young woman with dreams of working in television, and her romance with a jazz saxophonist. Their love faces challenges from career ambitions and societal pressures.

Tessa Thompson delivers a captivating performance, earning a Critics’ Choice Award nomination. The film’s celebration of Black love and its lush visuals make it a beautiful, underappreciated story.

One Night in Miami… (2020)

‘One Night in Miami’ imagines a night in 1964 when Malcolm X, Muhammad Ali, Jim Brown, and Sam Cooke gather to celebrate Ali’s boxing victory. Their conversation dives into their roles in the Civil Rights Movement and personal struggles.

Directed by Regina King, the film blends powerful dialogue with stellar performances from Kingsley Ben-Adir, Eli Goree, Aldis Hodge, and Leslie Odom Jr. It’s a gripping, thought-provoking drama that deserves more attention.

The Big Sick (2017)

‘The Big Sick’ is a heartfelt romantic comedy based on the real-life love story of Kumail Nanjiani and Emily Gordon. It follows a couple navigating cultural differences and a sudden health crisis that tests their bond.

With a strong cast, including Nanjiani, Zoe Kazan, Holly Hunter, and Ray Romano, the film balances humor and drama beautifully. Its 86% Metacritic score and authentic storytelling make it a modern rom-com classic.

Sound of Metal (2019)

‘Sound of Metal’ follows Ruben, a metal drummer played by Riz Ahmed, who loses his hearing and must adapt to a new life. He joins a community for Deaf recovering addicts, facing his inner struggles along the way.

The film’s raw emotion, immersive sound design, and Ahmed’s Oscar-nominated performance create a powerful experience. It’s a moving, character-driven story that’s one of Prime’s best originals.

Uncle Frank (2020)

‘Uncle Frank’ is a 1970s-set comedy-drama about Frank, a gay man, and his niece Beth, who travel to a family funeral. The journey forces Frank to confront his past and find self-acceptance.

Paul Bettany and Sophia Lillis deliver strong performances, blending humor with heartfelt moments. The film’s exploration of identity and family makes it a touching, underseen gem.

Brittany Runs a Marathon (2019)

‘Brittany Runs a Marathon’ stars Jillian Bell as Brittany, a woman who decides to run the New York City Marathon after a health scare. Her journey to fitness becomes a path to self-discovery and confidence.

The film avoids clichés, offering an honest look at personal growth with humor and heart. Bell’s authentic performance makes this a refreshing, inspiring comedy worth watching.

The Report (2019)

‘The Report’ is a gripping procedural thriller about a Senate staffer, played by Adam Driver, investigating the CIA’s use of torture after 9/11. The film follows his relentless pursuit of truth despite political obstacles.

Directed by Scott Z. Burns, it’s a tense, fact-driven drama with a stellar cast, including Annette Bening. Its sharp focus and Driver’s intense performance make it a standout political thriller.

You Were Never Really Here (2017)

‘You Were Never Really Here’ is a dark, intense thriller about Joe, a traumatized veteran who rescues trafficked girls. When a job goes wrong, Joaquin Phoenix’s character is pulled into a dangerous conspiracy.

Directed by Lynne Ramsay, the film combines brutal action with deep emotional weight. Phoenix’s haunting performance and Ramsay’s bold visuals make this a gripping, overlooked masterpiece.

Música (2024)

‘Música’ is a vibrant romantic comedy about a young man with synesthesia, where senses like sound and color blend together. Rudy Mancuso stars and directs, exploring love and creativity through his unique perspective.

The film’s lively energy and chemistry between Mancuso and Camila Mendes make it a standout. Its creative depiction of synesthesia adds a fresh twist to the rom-com genre.

Air (2023)

‘Air’ tells the true story of Nike’s game-changing deal with Michael Jordan to create the Air Jordan shoe line. Matt Damon stars as Sonny Vaccaro, the scout who risks everything to make it happen.

Directed by Ben Affleck, the film is a fast-paced drama with a stellar cast, including Viola Davis and Jason Bateman. Its engaging look at business and ambition makes it a hidden gem.

What’s your favorite underrated Amazon Prime original movie—share your picks in the comments!