‘Insidious: Out of the Further’s’ Rotten Tomatoes Score Proves This Horror Franchise Still Has Bite
Horror franchises rarely make it to a sixth installment without wearing out their welcome, but the ‘Insidious‘ universe has managed to keep finding fresh angles more than a decade after James Wan and Leigh Whannell first cracked open the door to The Further. That’s largely thanks to a rotating cast of directors willing to put their own spin on the material while keeping series mainstay Lin Shaye anchored at its center.
This time, the reins have passed to Jacob Chase, the filmmaker behind 2020’s ‘Come Play,’ who both wrote and directed the newest chapter after basing the story on an idea he developed with ‘The Conjuring 2’ writer David Leslie Johnson-McGoldrick. The film introduces an entirely new family to torment, moving the franchise away from the Lambert clan that carried the first five entries.
That gamble appears to be paying off, at least critically. ‘Insidious: Out of the Further’ has debuted with a 67% score on Rotten Tomatoes, making it the second-highest-rated installment in franchise history behind only the original 2010 film.
The film follows Gemma, played by Amelia Eve, a young mother raising her daughter in the same house she grew up in. Gemma discovers she can travel into The Further, the purgatorial realm at the center of the franchise’s mythology, and soon realizes she possesses an even rarer ability: she can pull whatever lurks there back into the real world with her.
That twist has given critics plenty to chew on, and reactions have ranged from enthusiastic to lukewarm. IGN called it “a better soft reboot than a sixth franchise entry has any right to be,” praising the film for delivering “a popcorn-rattling ride full of fun, creative scares.” Meanwhile, other outlets have been far less charitable, with IndieWire reportedly dismissing it as “direly, dreadfully boring.”
Polygon offered a more measured take, arguing that the film “works best when it focuses on the generational tale of mothers and what they pass down to their daughters,” while noting that heart can get lost amid the noise elsewhere in the film. That generational throughline has become something of a calling card for this new chapter, distinguishing it from earlier sequels that leaned more heavily on jump scares than emotional stakes.
Critics have also singled out the film’s craftsmanship as a highlight regardless of where they land on the story itself. In its review, The Wrap praised the sound design as one of the film’s “secret weapons,” even while noting that the screenplay leans on some predictable beats given how many times this franchise well has been drawn from.
For context on where this ranks historically, the original ‘Insidious’ has long held the crown as the franchise’s best-reviewed film. It’s followed by ‘Insidious: Chapter 3,’ which came in behind that, with the more recent ‘Insidious: The Red Door,’ ‘Insidious: Chapter 2,’ and ‘Insidious: The Last Key’ trailing further down the list. That the newest entry has climbed above nearly the entire back catalog speaks to how much goodwill Chase’s reboot approach has generated among critics.
Lin Shaye’s continued presence as Elise Rainier remains a constant thread tying the franchise together, even as the character roster shifts around her. Wan and Whannell, who directed and co-wrote earlier entries respectively, have stepped back into producer roles for this installment, a pattern that’s become increasingly common as the series has passed creative control to a new generation of horror filmmakers.
‘Insidious: Out of the Further’ opens in theaters on August 21, giving genre fans a fresh scare just as the fall horror season begins to ramp up. Given the tug-of-war between glowing and scathing reviews so far, audience reaction over opening weekend will likely determine whether the film’s critical standing holds or shifts as more reviews roll in.
For a franchise many assumed had said everything it needed to say after five prior entries, proving there’s still fresh terror to mine from The Further is no small feat. Whether this reboot direction becomes the template for future ‘Insidious’ films remains to be seen, but critics seem cautiously optimistic that the series isn’t running out of ideas just yet.
Are You Excited for Insidious: Out of the Further?
Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!
