Is John Stewart Stronger Than Hal Jordan? ‘Lanterns’ Just Dropped a Major Hint

Debates about which superhero packs the most raw power have fueled comic book arguments for decades, and few rivalries generate quite as much passionate disagreement as the one between two of Earth’s most prominent Green Lanterns. HBO’s newest DC series just reignited that exact conversation with a single moment that longtime fans immediately picked up on.

“Lanterns” has spent its opening episodes establishing the dynamic between veteran Hal Jordan and his reluctant new recruit, John Stewart, with Hal treating the pairing as a fairly standard mentor-trainee relationship. That framing shifted noticeably in Episode 2, when the show hinted that John might possess abilities Hal himself can barely comprehend, reigniting one of Green Lantern comics’ most enduring power debates.

According to the show, that hint arrives when John, still learning the basics of using his ring, unintentionally manifests a small green bird construct rather than simply flying the way Hal instructed. It’s a small moment, but one that carries significant weight given how the comics have historically portrayed John Stewart’s abilities.

In the comics, Hal Jordan is widely considered the single most powerful Green Lantern of all time, a reputation built on feats that border on the absurd. At one point, Hal recreated the entirety of his home city, Coast City, using his ring alone, complete with fully realized people, though it’s worth noting that particular feat occurred while he was possessed by an evil cosmic entity.

John Stewart, meanwhile, has built his own reputation as one of the Corps’ most consistently powerful members through a very different skill set. As a former Marine sniper turned architect, Stewart’s constructs are known for being extraordinarily detailed and precise rather than simply large, once famously creating a rifle construct capable of hitting a target located in another star system entirely.

The debate over which Lantern is truly stronger has raged among fans for years, since Green Lantern power ultimately comes down to willpower and construct skill rather than any fixed measure of physical strength. That ambiguity has allowed different comic runs to depict either character as dominant depending on the story being told, with some writers even suggesting Stewart briefly held the title of most powerful Green Lantern in the universe following certain storylines.

The significance of John’s bird moment lies specifically in what it reveals about his instincts as a brand-new ring bearer. The show seems to be teasing that John could possess abilities Hal isn’t even capable of conceiving, a detail that tracks closely with John’s comic book history as one of the most naturally gifted Lanterns to ever wield a ring.

That framing raises an interesting question for the show going forward, given how firmly Hal’s comic book legacy is tied to being considered the definitive most powerful Green Lantern in DC history. Whether “Lanterns” ultimately leans into positioning John as Hal’s equal, or eventually surpasses him entirely, remains to be seen as the season continues unfolding.

Part of what makes the Hal-versus-John debate so difficult to settle definitively comes down to how differently each character approaches using his ring. Hal’s power has traditionally been described as rooted purely in personal willpower and raw emotional resolve, allowing him to generate massive, forceful constructs through sheer determination.

John, by contrast, approaches the ring with the mindset of someone who understands how things are actually built, translating his military and architectural background into intricate, highly complex constructs rather than simply overwhelming force. That fundamental difference in approach has made the two characters notoriously difficult to directly compare, even among longtime comic readers who’ve debated the matchup for years.

With “Lanterns” continuing its weekly rollout on HBO and HBO Max, John’s early hints of extraordinary potential suggest the show may be building toward a genuine power dynamic shift between its two leads as the season progresses.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!