James Gunn’s Feature Films Ranked by Rotten Tomatoes Scores

James Gunn has carved out a unique space in Hollywood with his bold, irreverent style, blending humor, heart, and quirky storytelling. From low-budget horror-comedy to massive superhero blockbusters, his work spans genres, always leaving a distinct mark with sharp writing and memorable characters.

We love how Gunn balances wild creativity with emotional depth, often turning underdog stories into fan favorites. Below, we rank every feature film he’s directed, including one TV special, based on their Rotten Tomatoes Tomatometer scores, diving into what makes each project stand out.

9. Movie 43 (2013)

Tomatometer: 5% | Audience Score: 24%

This anthology comedy aimed for shock value with a star-studded cast, including Kate Winslet, Hugh Jackman, and Emma Stone. Gunn directed the ‘Beezel’ segment, a bizarre short about a creepy animated cat. The film’s crude humor and disjointed sketches didn’t land, earning brutal reviews for lacking cohesion. Critics called it a chaotic mess, and audiences largely agreed, turned off by the uneven tone.

Despite the star power, the film’s scattershot approach failed to deliver laughs or heart. Gunn’s segment, while weirdly memorable, couldn’t salvage the project. It’s a rare misstep in his career, showing even bold swings can miss.

8. Super (2010)

Tomatometer: 50% | Audience Score: 56%

Starring Rainn Wilson as a vigilante cook turned superhero, ‘Super’ is a dark, gritty take on the genre. Ellen Page shines as his chaotic sidekick, bringing wild energy to this low-budget tale. Critics were split, praising its originality but finding its violent shifts jarring. Audiences enjoyed the quirky charm but felt the tone wobbled.

Gunn’s early attempt at superhero storytelling shows his knack for flawed, human characters. While not a hit, it laid groundwork for his later triumphs, proving he could tackle big ideas on a small scale.

7. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 (2023)

Tomatometer: 82% | Audience Score: 94%

The final chapter of Gunn’s ‘Guardians’ trilogy delivers emotional closure for Rocket, Star-Lord, and the crew. With Zoe Saldaña, Chris Pratt, and Dave Bautista back, it’s a heartfelt sci-fi epic. Critics admired its bold visuals and character focus but noted a crowded plot. Fans, however, adored the emotional payoff and humor.

This film showcases Gunn’s growth, blending spectacle with deep character arcs. It’s a fitting end to the trilogy, proving his ability to make us laugh and cry in equal measure.

6. Superman (2025)

Tomatometer: 83% | Audience Score: 92%

Gunn’s take on the iconic hero, starring David Corenswet, reimagines Superman as a hopeful beacon in a cynical world. The film balances classic heroism with modern stakes, earning strong praise for its fresh approach. Critics lauded its heart and visuals, though some felt it leaned too safe. Audiences embraced the optimism and action.

This reboot shows Gunn’s knack for reviving beloved characters with sincerity. It’s a bold start to his DC Universe vision, setting a high bar for what’s next.

5. Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 (2017)

Tomatometer: 85% | Audience Score: 87%

Peter Quill’s journey continues as he uncovers his cosmic roots, joined by Chris Pratt, Zoe Saldaña, and a hilarious Baby Groot. Critics loved the vibrant visuals and humor but noted a slightly overstuffed story. Fans ate up the emotional family themes and killer soundtrack.

Gunn doubles down on heart and humor here, making the Guardians feel like family. It’s a colorful, chaotic sequel that keeps the franchise’s spirit alive.

4. Slither (2006)

Tomatometer: 87% | Audience Score: 63%

Gunn’s directorial debut is a gory horror-comedy about alien slugs invading a small town. Starring Nathan Fillion and Elizabeth Banks, it’s a love letter to B-movies with sharp wit. Critics praised its gross-out charm and tight pacing, though audiences were less sold on the creepy vibe.

This cult classic shows Gunn’s early flair for blending genres. It’s a wild, slimy ride that proves he could make low-budget magic.

3. The Suicide Squad (2021)

Tomatometer: 90% | Audience Score: 82%

This bloody, chaotic reboot follows a ragtag team of villains, led by Margot Robbie and John Cena, on a bonkers mission. Critics raved about its bold action and dark humor, calling it a standout in the DC lineup. Fans loved the wild energy, though some found it too intense.

Gunn’s vision shines here, turning B-list characters into stars with heart and grit. It’s a violent, hilarious gem that redefines the team-up genre.

2. Guardians of the Galaxy (2014)

Tomatometer: 92% | Audience Score: 92%

This surprise Marvel hit introduced us to Star-Lord, Rocket, and Groot, played by Chris Pratt, Bradley Cooper, and Vin Diesel. Critics hailed its fresh humor and retro soundtrack, making it a sci-fi classic. Fans fell hard for the lovable misfits and epic space vibes.

Gunn turned unknown heroes into household names with this film. It’s a perfect mix of action, laughs, and heart, setting the stage for a beloved trilogy.

1. The Guardians of the Galaxy Holiday Special (2022)

Tomatometer: 94% | Audience Score: 81%

This TV special brings the Guardians together for a festive, chaotic adventure. Starring Chris Pratt and Pom Klementieff, it’s a short, joyful romp with a killer holiday soundtrack. Critics loved its lighthearted fun and tight story, while fans enjoyed the goofy charm.

Gunn crafts a bite-sized delight that captures the Guardians’ spirit. It’s a testament to his ability to make even small projects feel big and heartfelt.

Which James Gunn film is your top pick, or is there a hidden gem we overlooked? Drop your thoughts in the comments!