Quentin Tarantino Once Called Stephen King’s Top-Grossing Film a Rip-Off

Back in 2019, Quentin Tarantino shared his thoughts on Stephen King’s blockbuster horror story It, calling the movie a rip-off of a classic 1980s horror film.

During a conversation with Eli Roth on the History of Horror: Uncut podcast, Tarantino compared the story of It to Wes Craven’s 1984 film A Nightmare on Elm Street, which famously starred a young Johnny Depp.

“He just replaces Freddy Krueger with Pennywise. It’s just exactly like he sees ‘Nightmare on Elm Street’ — ‘Oh wow, that’s a really neat idea,’” Tarantino explained. He added, “That’s really clever. That’s cool. Well, let me take that idea and let me do my version of it.’ Now, his version of it is going to be a 560-page novel.”

Tarantino seemed impressed with King’s creativity but suggested the story borrowed heavily from the iconic slasher film. However, many critics and fans have pushed back against this claim.

Pennywise, the demonic clown terrorizing the children of Derry, and Freddy Krueger, the dream-stalking killer, have very different methods, motives, and origins. While both are horror icons, their stories and the worlds they inhabit are not remotely the same.

Stephen King’s novel, published in 1986, focuses on a group of children confronting their deepest fears in a small town over decades, blending supernatural horror with coming-of-age themes.

Wes Craven’s A Nightmare on Elm Street, on the other hand, tells the story of a killer who attacks teenagers in their dreams, relying on slasher horror and suspense. Despite Tarantino’s claims, the differences in tone, characters, and narrative structure show that It is far from a simple remake.

While Tarantino’s remarks generated headlines, they also sparked debates among horror fans about influence versus imitation in the genre. Many argue that horror films often borrow ideas from previous works, but originality comes from how those ideas are executed. It, with its mix of supernatural horror, psychological depth, and nostalgic 1980s setting, remains a unique entry in King’s long career and in modern horror cinema.

Tarantino’s comments remind us of the ongoing conversation in Hollywood about inspiration, homage, and originality. While he may see parallels, most audiences recognize that Pennywise and Freddy Krueger are distinct figures who shaped the horror genre in their own ways.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!