Robert Eggers’ Films Ranked by Rotten Tomatoes Scores

Robert Eggers has carved a unique niche in cinema with his haunting, history-soaked stories. His films, drenched in folklore and meticulous detail, pull us into worlds where dread and beauty collide.

We’re diving into his four feature films, ranked by their Rotten Tomatoes critic scores, from lowest to highest. Each movie showcases Eggers’ knack for crafting unsettling tales that linger long after the credits roll.

4. Nosferatu (2024)

Certified Fresh: 84%, Audience: 73%

Eggers’ take on the vampire classic ‘Nosferatu’ is a gothic fever dream. Bill Skarsgård transforms into the eerie Count Orlok, stalking Lily-Rose Depp’s tormented Ellen Hutter. The film’s shadowy visuals and creeping tension make it a bold reimagining of the 1922 silent film. Critics praised its atmosphere, though some felt the pacing dragged compared to Eggers’ tighter works.

The audience score, the highest among his films, shows we’re drawn to its chilling vibe. Skarsgård’s monstrous performance and Eggers’ knack for blending folklore with horror keep this vampire tale fresh. It’s a visual feast, but its slower moments place it at the bottom of this list.

3. The Lighthouse (2019)

Certified Fresh: 90%, Audience: 72%

‘The Lighthouse’ traps us on a stormy New England island with two unraveling men. Willem Dafoe and Robert Pattinson deliver raw, unhinged performances as lighthouse keepers spiraling into madness. Shot in stark black-and-white with a claustrophobic frame, the film feels like a descent into a nautical nightmare. Critics loved its bold mix of humor, horror, and myth.

We’re hooked by its wild energy, though its dense dialogue and surreal twists can feel like a puzzle. The near-square aspect ratio and gritty texture make every scene suffocating. It’s a testament to Eggers’ ability to push boundaries while keeping us glued to the screen.

2. The Northman (2022)

Certified Fresh: 90%, Audience: 64%

‘The Northman’ is Eggers’ blood-soaked Viking epic, following Amleth, played by Alexander Skarsgård, on a brutal quest for revenge. With Nicole Kidman, Anya Taylor-Joy, and Willem Dafoe rounding out the cast, the film dives deep into Norse mythology. Its sweeping visuals and savage action scenes are a departure from Eggers’ smaller-scale horrors. Critics lauded its ambition, despite its box office struggles.

The lower audience score suggests its grim tone and dense lore didn’t click with everyone. We admire its unflinching look at Viking life, from rituals to raw violence. It’s a gripping saga that balances mythic grandeur with Eggers’ signature unease.

1. The Witch (2015)

Certified Fresh: 91%, Audience: 61%

‘The Witch’ launched Eggers as a horror visionary. Set in 1630s New England, it follows a Puritan family unraveling near a sinister forest. Anya Taylor-Joy shines as Thomasin, accused of witchcraft as strange events spiral. The film’s slow-burn dread and period-accurate dialogue create a suffocating sense of doom. Critics hailed it as a modern horror classic.

We’re split on its deliberate pace, with some finding it chilling and others too sluggish. The film’s power lies in its ambiguity, blending psychological and supernatural horror. Black Phillip, the menacing goat, remains an iconic figure, cementing ‘The Witch’ as Eggers’ highest-rated gem.

Which Robert Eggers film creeps you out the most, or is there one you think deserves more love? Drop your thoughts in the comments!