Robert Pattinson’s Bond Casting Sparks ‘Not Alpha Male’ Complaints From Fans, but 007 Has Heard It Before

Amazon MGM Studios
Share:

Every new James Bond arrives with a ritual that is almost as old as the franchise itself. A casting is announced, the internet erupts, and a wave of fans declares the new actor all wrong for the role. The arrival of Robert Pattinson as 007 is no exception.

Pattinson comes to the part with plenty of baggage in the best sense. At 40, he first gained attention as Cedric Diggory in ‘Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire’, then became a global star as Edward Cullen in the 5-film ‘Twilight’ saga. He then moved to independent films including ‘Cosmopolis’, ‘Good Time’, ‘High Life’ and ‘The Lighthouse’, before returning to major studio work with ‘Tenet’ and ‘The Batman’.

That résumé is exactly what some viewers are now debating. Amazon MGM Studios confirmed on November 16 that Pattinson will be the seventh actor to play James Bond, succeeding Daniel Craig. The Hollywood Reporter says plenty of fans are already griping online about the choice, and one of the most repeated criticisms is that he doesn’t come across as an alpha male.

The outlet describes a wave of online gripes in the wake of the news. One fan said he lacks the magnetic charm and rugged confidence of a Bond character, while another snarked, “I’ve seen sexier potatoes.” Other comments questioned his ruggedness, confidence and ability to portray Bond as a convincing ladies’ man and action hero.

Some critics also worry that audiences will see Edward Cullen or Bruce Wayne rather than Bond, and some wanted a less established actor for the role. In short, the complaints are less about talent and more about image.

RELATED:

‘Hunger Games’ Star Ralph Fiennes Thinks the New James Bond Should Also Become the New Voldemort

The reaction is also entirely routine. Any actor cast as Bond is going to get bashed, and even Daniel Craig was roundly criticized by fans in 2005, with complaints that he wasn’t handsome enough and that Bond can’t be blonde. Our visual concept of Bond is formed entirely by the other 6 actors who have played the role, so anybody new is tough to imagine at first.

Not everyone is unhappy. Many fans defend the casting, citing Pattinson’s acting range and his career beyond blockbusters, and some believe his work in darker, more complex roles could give Bond a different dimension.

Another piece argued he might not be as tough as Craig or as suave as Sean Connery, but has a mix of qualities that make him a smart choice. A third noted that Ian Fleming commissioned a sketch of 007 in the 1950s that bears an uncanny resemblance to the actor.

The reaction has reached far beyond fan forums. The Los Angeles Times described 007 fans of the internet as shaken and stirred, and even the royal family acknowledged the casting. Ralph Fiennes was also among those reacting.

If anyone knows how to handle a fan backlash, it is the new Bond. When he was cast in ‘Twilight’, most fans were unhappy, and Pattinson described the reaction as unanimous unhappiness. He also said he received bags of letters from angry fans insisting he couldn’t play Edward because he was Diggory.

The same thing happened with Batman. Before he was officially announced, a petition with thousands of signatures was already urging DC to reconsider. Pattinson later said he was shocked he wasn’t mocked even more, joking that the reaction was only 70 percent negative.

According to a November 13 Puck report, Pattinson negotiated his commitment to 3 Bond films, down from the 4 reportedly required of Josh O’Connor and Jack Lowden, and was offered significantly more money than the others. No exact salary was disclosed, and Amazon MGM declined to comment.

His first appearance will be in the untitled 26th official Bond film, with Denis Villeneuve directing and Steven Knight writing the screenplay. Production is expected to begin in 2027, and no release date has been announced.

What do you think of Robert Pattinson being cast as the next James Bond?

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!

Don't miss:

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted