The Most Overrated Shows of 2025 Ranked
The television landscape in 2025 has seen an unprecedented number of returning favorites and high budget newcomers vying for audience attention. Major streaming platforms have relied heavily on established intellectual properties to maintain their subscriber bases. While many of these productions achieve significant viewership numbers they do not always meet the high expectations set by their marketing campaigns. This list examines the shows that generated substantial conversation but ultimately fell short of the immense hype surrounding their release.
‘FUBAR’ (2023–2025)
Arnold Schwarzenegger returns for a second season of action and comedy as a veteran operative who works alongside his daughter. The show emphasizes lighthearted banter and over the top stunts to entertain a broad audience. Critics have noted that the humor is often dated and the action lacks the impact of the lead earlier cinematic work. Despite being a popular choice for casual viewing the series is viewed by many as a generic addition to the streaming catalog.
‘Ginny & Georgia’ (2021–2025)
The third season of this popular drama continues to explore the complicated relationship between a mother and her teenage daughter. The show features a mix of high school romance and dark criminal secrets from the past. Critics often point out the inconsistent tone and the tendency to incorporate too many subplots into a single season. Despite its massive viewership the series is frequently criticized for its lack of focus and heavy use of soap opera tropes.
‘The Recruit’ (2022–2025)
Noah Centineo returns as the young lawyer who finds himself involved in dangerous international politics during the second season. The show blends action with workplace comedy as the protagonist navigates the bureaucracy of the intelligence community. Many viewers feel that the plot relies on far fetched scenarios and unbelievable character decisions to move forward. Although the lead performance is charismatic the series struggles to balance its conflicting tones effectively.
‘The Night Agent’ (2023–2025)
The second season of this thriller follows an agent as he embarks on new high stakes missions around the globe. The show remains a massive hit for the streaming platform due to its fast paced action and suspenseful cliffhangers. Many critics point out that the series relies heavily on generic spy tropes and predictable government conspiracies. While it provides easy entertainment the lack of original ideas makes it feel like many other shows in the genre.
‘Ironheart’ (2025)
Dominique Thorne stars as Riri Williams in this series about a young inventor who creates a highly advanced suit of armor. The show explores the intersection of technology and magic as the protagonist faces off against a new villain. Some critics have pointed out that the character development feels secondary to the broader requirements of the interconnected universe. While the visual effects are modern the story follows a standard superhero origin template.
‘Percy Jackson and the Olympians’ (2023–2025)
The second season adapts the next book in the series as the young demigods embark on a dangerous quest to save their camp. The series continues to target a younger audience while staying faithful to the source material by Rick Riordan. Some older fans find the tone to be too juvenile and the action sequences to be lacking in tension. While the lead actors have grown into their roles the pacing of the quest often feels disjointed.
‘Avatar: The Last Airbender’ (2024–2025)
The second season of this live action reimagining follows the protagonists as they begin their mastery of earthbending in a new kingdom. The show attempts to balance the humor of the original animated series with a more mature and cinematic tone. Some fans feel that the character arcs are rushed to fit the limited number of episodes provided. Although the world building is expansive the dialogue often feels stiff and overly expository.
‘IT: Welcome to Derry’ (2025)
This prequel series explores the history of a haunted town and the terrifying presence that lurks beneath the streets. The show features a new cast of characters who encounter supernatural threats during the middle of the twentieth century. Critics suggest that the reliance on jumpscares and established lore prevents the series from standing on its own. While the production design is impressive the story often feels like a collection of horror cliches.
‘Suits LA’ (2025)
This spin off of the legal drama moves the action to a new city with a firm specializing in entertainment and media law. Stephen Amell stars as a former federal prosecutor who must navigate the power dynamics of the legal world. Some viewers believe the show relies too heavily on the reputation of the original series without offering anything new. While the production is slick the writing often feels like a imitation of the sharp dialogue found in the parent show.
‘Alien: Earth’ (2025)
The iconic science fiction horror franchise comes to television with a story set on Earth before the events of the original films. The series explores the arrival of a dangerous organism and the corporate machinations of a powerful company. Some viewers were disappointed by the focus on human politics rather than the horror elements of the franchise. Despite the high production value the pacing is much slower than the cinematic entries in the series.
‘Foundation’ (2021–2025)
The third season of this ambitious science fiction epic continues to adapt the sprawling history of a galactic empire. The show features a massive cast and stunning visual effects that rival major motion pictures. Some viewers find the complex narrative structure and philosophical themes difficult to follow over long periods of time. Despite the impressive production values the emotional core of the series can sometimes feel lost in the grand scale.
‘Gen V’ (2023–2025)
The second season of this spin off continues to follow superpowered students as they uncover corporate secrets at their university. The show features the same graphic violence and cynical social commentary as the main series. Some viewers believe the shock value is starting to lose its impact after multiple years of similar content. While the young cast is talented the plot often feels like a bridge to the next season of the flagship show.
‘The Sandman’ (2022–2025)
Tom Sturridge returns as the personification of dreams in the second season of this fantasy epic. The new episodes adapt popular storylines with a focus on celestial politics and ancient myths. Some critics argue that the series is too faithful to the source material at the expense of television pacing. While the imagery is stunning the cold and detached nature of the lead character can make it difficult for viewers to connect emotionally.
‘Squid Game’ (2021–2025)
The third season of the South Korean survival drama concludes the story of a man who attempts to dismantle the deadly competition from the inside. Director Hwang Dong hyuk returns to deliver more high stakes games that serve as a critique of modern capitalism. Some viewers believe the series has lost the element of surprise that made the first season a global phenomenon. The constant focus on shock value can sometimes detract from the development of the supporting characters.
‘Beef’ (2023–2025)
The second season of this anthology series features a new cast involved in a escalating feud that spirals out of control. Oscar Isaac and Carey Mulligan lead the new story which explores themes of obsession and repressed anger. Some critics feel that the concept worked better as a limited series rather than an ongoing project. While the performances are excellent the narrative arc feels less fresh than the acclaimed first installment.
‘The White Lotus’ (2021–2025)
The third season of the anthology series moves to Thailand to examine the lives of wealthy guests at a luxury resort. Creator Mike White maintains the signature blend of social satire and dark comedy while introducing a new mystery. Some critics suggest the structure of the show has become predictable following the success of the previous seasons. While the ensemble cast delivers strong performances the central message regarding class privilege feels familiar to returning fans.
‘Wednesday’ (2022–2025)
Jenna Ortega returns as the iconic daughter for a second season of mystery and macabre humor at a special academy. The series continues to emphasize visual flair and viral moments to appeal to a younger demographic. Many critics argue that the writing lacks the depth required to sustain a long term drama. Despite the record breaking viewership numbers the plot often relies on common teen tropes and predictable twists.
‘One Piece’ (2023–2025)
The live action adaptation of the popular manga continues with the pirates entering the dangerous waters of a vast ocean. The second season introduces fan favorite characters and villains from the original source material. Many viewers feel that the translation from animation to live action loses some of the original charm and energy. Although the budget is immense the visual effects can occasionally feel inconsistent during the larger action scenes.
‘Peacemaker’ (2022–2025)
The second season of this series continues the irreverent adventures of a antihero under the direction of James Gunn. The show maintains its blend of vulgar humor and violent action while introducing new members to the task force. Some fans believe that the comedic tone has become forced and less effective than in the first season. While the character study of the lead remains interesting the secondary plots often feel like filler.
‘Andor’ (2022–2025)
The final season of this prequel explores the growing rebellion against an empire through the eyes of a reluctant hero. This series is known for its grounded approach to the franchise and its focus on political intrigue. Some fans feel that the slow pacing of the story makes it difficult to remain engaged throughout every episode. Although the writing is sophisticated the lack of traditional franchise elements has limited its appeal to a broader audience.
‘The Bear’ (2022–2025)
The fourth season follows a talented chef and his kitchen staff as they navigate the high pressure environment of a fine dining restaurant. The series is celebrated for its frantic energy and intense performances from the lead actors. Critics have noted that the relentless pacing can become exhausting for the audience over multiple seasons. While the show remains a awards favorite some feel that the stakes have become repetitive since the initial episodes.
‘Daredevil: Born Again’ (2025)
Charlie Cox returns as a blind vigilante in this revival that brings the character into a broader interconnected universe. The show aims to recapture the gritty tone of the original series while integrating established heroes and villains. Many fans were disappointed by the creative changes made during the lengthy production process. While the action sequences are well choreographed the episodic structure feels less cohesive than previous iterations.
‘Yellowstone’ (2018–2025)
The final episodes of this modern western saga conclude the battle for a family ranch without the presence of the lead actor. The series has become a cultural phenomenon by focusing on the conflicts between land developers and traditional ranchers. Many fans feel that the off screen drama surrounding the production has negatively impacted the quality of the final narrative. While the cinematography remains beautiful the resolution of the major plot lines feels rushed to many long time viewers.
‘Dexter: Resurrection’ (2025)
Michael C. Hall returns to his most famous role in this new series that follows the events of a previous revival. The story explores how a serial killer survives a critical situation and finds a new purpose in a modern setting. Many fans feel that the franchise has already reached its natural conclusion and that further entries are unnecessary. While the lead performance remains strong the premise feels increasingly tired after multiple attempts to reboot the brand.
‘Black Mirror’ (2011–2025)
The seventh season of the dystopian anthology series features six new stories including a sequel to a fan favorite episode. Creator Charlie Brooker continues to explore the dark side of technology and its impact on human relationships. Some critics suggest that the series has struggled to stay ahead of real world developments in recent years. While individual episodes are often thought provoking the overall quality of the season is viewed as uneven by many fans.
‘Severance’ (2022–2025)
This series continues the surreal story of employees who have surgically divided their memories between work and personal lives. The second season delves deeper into the mysteries of a powerful corporation and the true nature of the procedure. While the atmospheric tension remains a highlight the slow progression of the overarching plot has frustrated some viewers. The critical acclaim for the visual style often masks a narrative that moves at a very deliberate speed.
‘Invincible’ (2021–2025)
The third season of this animated drama explores the fallout of a alien invasion and the growing responsibilities of a young hero. The show is praised for its complex characters and willingness to subvert traditional expectations. Many fans have expressed frustration with the long delays between seasons and the inconsistent release schedule. While the story remains compelling some feel the animation quality does not always match the epic scale of the narrative.
‘The Last of Us’ (2023–2025)
The second season adapts the polarizing events of a popular video game as the protagonists face the consequences of their past actions. Pedro Pascal and Bella Ramsey lead the cast through a landscape filled with both human and infected threats. While the production quality is undeniable some viewers found the narrative choices to be frustratingly bleak. The intense media coverage often focuses on the controversy of the source material rather than the execution of the show.
‘Stranger Things’ (2016–2025)
The fifth and final season of this supernatural series concludes the long journey of a group of teenagers against otherworldly threats. Each episode functions as a feature length film with massive scale and high stakes for every character involved. Despite the emotional weight of the finale some viewers found the expanded runtimes and complex lore to be overwhelming. The nostalgia driven narrative remains popular even as critics point out the repetitive nature of the central conflicts.
Share your thoughts on these television rankings in the comments.
