‘The Westies’ Season 1 Review: A Gangster Saga That Knows Its History but Struggles to Find Its Own Voice
New York gangster stories have been a cornerstone of prestige television for decades, and MGM+ clearly understands the appetite for another entry in that lineage. ‘The Westies‘ plants its flag in 1980s Hell’s Kitchen, chronicling the real-life Irish American crime gang that carved out territory alongside the far larger Italian mafia, using the construction of the Jacob Javits Convention Center as the engine driving its central conflict.
The premise carries obvious promise, and the production clearly put real effort into recreating its period setting. Smoke-filled bars, boxy sedans, and a soundtrack leaning on the era’s grit all work together to sell 1980s Manhattan, even with a Toronto-based shoot standing in for the real streets. The costuming occasionally muddles the exact decade, sliding between late 70s and early 90s influences, but the overall texture of the world still lands.
Where the season truly comes alive is in its cast. J.K. Simmons anchors the show as Eamon Sweeney, playing him with a working-class charm that occasionally slips into something colder and more dangerous underneath.
Tom Brittney matches him scene for scene as Jimmy Roarke, Sweeney’s most trusted enforcer, and their mentor-mentee dynamic gives the season its most consistently compelling throughline, even when the writing around them plays things safer than the genre demands.
Titus Welliver deserves special mention as Glenn Keenan, an informant caught between the law and the underworld he’s meant to be reporting on. He brings a weariness to the role that hints at real interior damage, carrying scenes that might otherwise coast on genre familiarity.
Sarah Bolger’s Bridget adds another layer as an IRA operative pulled back into old entanglements, though her romance with Jimmy occasionally tips into repetitive territory, with both characters spending an unusual amount of screentime warning each other to be careful.
That romance is emblematic of the season’s biggest issue, which is a tendency to reach for well-worn beats rather than build something distinctly its own. The show’s version of John Gotti and the broader Italian mafia rivalry never feels like more than a composite of gangster archetypes audiences have already seen dozens of times, and much of the emotional weight given to Sweeney’s inner conflict feels more asserted by the plot than earned through the writing itself.
Mickey Flanagan’s arc as a Vietnam veteran wrestling with PTSD gestures toward something more substantial, but the show rarely digs deep enough into that pain to make it land with the force it clearly wants.
Visually, the series settles into the same subdued, desaturated look that has become the default for so much prestige streaming television, occasionally broken up by genuinely kinetic and well-edited action sequences that favor a rough, reactive style of street fighting over slick choreography. The direction rarely takes big risks, favoring competence over the kind of visual ambition that elevated the genre’s true landmarks, though a handful of episodes do show real flashes of style when the show allows itself room to experiment.
None of this makes ‘The Westies’ a bad watch. It moves briskly across its eight-episode run, never overstaying its welcome, and the chemistry between its lead performances carries real momentum even through its more formulaic stretches. What it lacks is the sense of danger and moral complexity that separates the genre’s best work from its merely competent imitators, leaving Sweeney feeling more like a beloved uncle than a man capable of real menace.
After Reading the Review, Will You Watch 'The Westies'?
By the time the season wraps, it closes its central conflicts with real satisfaction while leaving enough threads dangling for a second season, should MGM+ choose to greenlight one. I came away entertained by the performances and mildly frustrated by how rarely the writing matched their ambition, landing on a solid 7 out of 10 for a season that’s easy to enjoy in the moment but unlikely to linger long after the credits roll.
Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!
