TV Shows That Recast Characters and Pretended You Wouldn’t Notice

Television production often faces hurdles that necessitate casting changes, such as scheduling conflicts, creative shifts, or personal decisions by actors. While some series address these transitions through plot devices, many choose to simply replace an actor and continue the narrative as if no change occurred. This practice relies on the audience’s willingness to accept a new face in a familiar role to maintain the continuity of the story. These instances range from minor side characters to pivotal leads who define the dynamic of a series.

‘The Fresh Prince of Bel-Air’ (1990–1996)

Janet Hubert portrayed the original Vivian Banks for the first three seasons of the sitcom. Following her departure due to creative differences and contract disputes, Daphne Maxwell Reid took over the role for the remainder of the series. The show made a brief meta-joke about her appearance in the fourth season premiere, but otherwise proceeded without acknowledging the change. Reid’s version of the character was notably softer and less confrontational than Hubert’s portrayal. This remains one of the most famous examples of a major character being replaced mid-run.

‘Roseanne’ (1988–1997)

Lecy Goranson originally played the eldest daughter, Becky Conner, before leaving the show to attend college. Sarah Chalke was brought in to play the character in the sixth season, leading to a long-running joke regarding her changing face. Goranson eventually returned for the eighth season, but when she had scheduling conflicts again, Chalke stepped back into the role. The series famously poked fun at the situation during various credit sequences and dialogue exchanges. Despite the humor, the show continued to treat both actresses as the same person within the narrative.

‘Game of Thrones’ (2011–2019)

Ed Skrein originated the role of Daario Naharis in the third season of ‘Game of Thrones’. He appeared as a long-haired, clean-shaven mercenary who becomes a key ally to Daenerys Targaryen. By the fourth season, Michiel Huisman took over the role with a completely different aesthetic, sporting a beard and shorter hair. The series never offered an in-universe explanation for the mercenary’s dramatic change in physical appearance. This transition occurred while the character was becoming a more prominent romantic interest for the Dragon Queen.

‘Game of Thrones’ (2011–2019)

The character Gregor Clegane, known as the Mountain, was portrayed by three different actors throughout the series. Conan Stevens played the knight in the first season, followed by Ian Whyte in the second season. Starting in the fourth season, Hafþór Júlíus Björnsson took over the role and remained until the series finale. Despite the character’s terrifying reputation and massive physical presence, the visual shifts between actors were handled without narrative acknowledgement. This frequent recasting is a rare example of a single role changing hands multiple times within a high-profile production.

‘Game of Thrones’ (2011–2019)

Tommen Baratheon was initially portrayed by child actor Callum Wharry during the first two seasons of the show. As the character’s role became more central to the political maneuvering in King’s Landing, the producers decided to recast the part. Dean-Charles Chapman, who had previously played a minor character in the series, took over as the young king in the fourth season. This change allowed for more complex dramatic scenes as Tommen navigated his marriage to Margaery Tyrell. The show treated the older, more articulate Tommen as the same child seen in earlier episodes.

‘Game of Thrones’ (2011–2019)

Myrcella Baratheon was first played by Aimee Richardson in the early seasons of the fantasy epic. When the character returned from Dorne in the fifth season, the role was taken over by Nell Tiger Free. The recasting was intended to reflect the character’s transition into a more mature storyline involving a political betrothal. Richardson famously learned of the recasting along with the public and posted a humorous response on social media. The narrative continued her arc without commenting on the change in her appearance.

‘Bewitched’ (1964–1972)

Dick York played the original Darrin Stephens, the mortal husband of the witch Samantha, for five seasons. York was forced to leave the series due to a chronic back injury that made it impossible for him to continue working. Dick Sargent took over the role in the sixth season and remained until the show ended. The transition was so seamless that the term “The Darrin Syndrome” was coined to describe such recasts. The show made no attempt to explain why Darrin suddenly looked and acted differently.

‘Last Man Standing’ (2011–2021)

Molly Ephraim played Mandy Baxter for the first six seasons of the series when it aired on ABC. After the show was canceled and later picked up by Fox, Ephraim had moved on to other projects and was unavailable to return. Molly McCook was cast to replace her, appearing significantly taller and having blonde hair compared to Ephraim’s brunette look. The show addressed the change with a few jokes in the seventh season premiere but then moved on. McCook portrayed the character for the final three seasons of the sitcom.

‘Last Man Standing’ (2011–2021)

The character of Kristin Baxter underwent a recast after the first season of the show. Alexandra Krosney originally played the eldest daughter, but producers decided to take the character in a different direction for the second season. Amanda Fuller was brought in to play a more mature version of Kristin who was navigating motherhood and a career. Along with the actor change, the character’s son, Boyd, was also aged up and recast. These changes were part of a larger creative overhaul when the series changed showrunners.

‘Family Guy’ (1999–)

Lacey Chabert provided the voice for Meg Griffin during the first season and part of the second season of the animated comedy. Due to her busy schedule with other projects, Chabert left the show, and Mila Kunis was cast as the permanent replacement. Kunis has voiced the character for over two decades, making the role one of her most recognizable performances. The show has occasionally referenced the change in meta-humor, but generally treats Meg as the same character. Chabert’s original performance is still heard in early episodes in syndication.

‘Arrested Development’ (2003–2019)

Ann Veal, George Michael’s girlfriend, was played by Alessandra Torresani in her first appearance in the second season. When the character returned for more episodes, Mae Whitman took over the role for the rest of the series. The show used the recasting to bolster a running joke that Ann was so “bland” and “unforgettable” that people constantly forgot she existed. The producers initially considered using a different actress for every single appearance of the character. However, Whitman’s comedic timing made her a permanent fixture in the cast.

‘Riverdale’ (2017–2023)

Ross Butler played the role of Reggie Mantle in the first season of the Archie Comics adaptation. When Butler was cast as a lead in another series, he was unable to return for the second season of ‘Riverdale’. Charles Melton took over the role and became a series regular as Reggie’s presence in the story expanded. The show did not explain the change, though Reggie’s personality became more central to the plot in later seasons. Melton eventually became the definitive version of the character for many fans.

‘The Fosters’ (2013–2018)

Jake T. Austin played Jesus Adams Foster for the first two seasons of the drama series. Following his departure, the character was involved in a serious car accident that served as a narrative bridge for the recasting. When Jesus returned from a period of recovery, he was portrayed by Noah Centineo. The show used the traumatic brain injury resulting from the crash to explain changes in the character’s behavior. However, the physical change in actors was treated as a standard transition without explicit comment on his new look.

‘That ’70s Show’ (1998–2006)

Lisa Robin Kelly played Laurie Forman, Eric’s older sister, as a recurring and later main character. Due to personal issues, Kelly left the show and the character was written out for several seasons. When Laurie returned in the sixth season, she was portrayed by Christina Moore. The change was jarring for many viewers, and Moore only appeared in a handful of episodes before the character was written out again. The show continued the story without referencing why Eric’s sister looked like a different person.

‘Seinfeld’ (1989–1998)

Frank Costanza was originally played by John Randolph in the fourth season episode titled ‘The Handicap Spot’. When the character was scheduled to return, Larry David decided to cast Jerry Stiller to bring a more energetic and abrasive energy to the role. Stiller’s performance became iconic and defined the character for the rest of the series. For syndication, the scenes featuring Randolph were eventually reshot with Stiller to ensure visual consistency. However, the original broadcast version featured the two different actors in the same role.

‘Seinfeld’ (1989–1998)

Morty Seinfeld, Jerry’s father, first appeared in the second episode of the first season played by Phil Bruns. Larry David felt that Bruns’ portrayal was too laid-back and wanted a father figure who was more “curmudgeonly” and defensive. Barney Martin took over the role starting in the second season and remained until the show’s conclusion. Unlike the scenes with Frank Costanza, the pilot scenes with Bruns were never reshot with Martin. This leaves a permanent record of the character’s original face in the series’ earliest days.

‘Modern Family’ (2009–2020)

Lily Tucker-Pritchett was played by twin toddlers Jaden and Ella Hiller for the first two seasons of the mockumentary. As the character grew older, the producers wanted an actress who could deliver dialogue and engage in more complex comedic scenes. Aubrey Anderson-Emmons joined the cast in the third season and remained until the series ended. The show acknowledged the character’s rapid growth through a few jokes but otherwise treated the transition as a natural part of her childhood. Anderson-Emmons became a core member of the ensemble cast.

‘Mad Men’ (2007–2015)

The role of Bobby Draper was famously played by four different young actors over the course of seven seasons. Maxwell Huckabee, Aaron Hart, Jared Gilmore, and Mason Vale Cotton all took turns portraying Don Draper’s son. The showrunners did not attempt to hide the changes, though the character’s age and personality remained relatively consistent. Some fans noted the recurring swaps, leading to the character being jokingly referred to as “the Bobby Drapers.” The production prioritized finding child actors who could handle the increasing dramatic weight of the series as Bobby aged.

‘Boy Meets World’ (1993–2000)

Morgan Matthews, the youngest sister of Cory and Eric, was played by Lily Nicksay for the first two seasons. The character then disappeared for a long stretch of time before returning in the middle of the third season. When she reappeared, she was portrayed by Lindsay Ridgeway, and the show made a meta-joke about how long her “time-out” had lasted. Ridgeway remained in the role for the rest of the series. The show leaned into the humor of the situation rather than providing a logical explanation.

‘The Munsters’ (1964–1966)

Beverley Owen was the first actress to play Marilyn Munster, the “plain” member of the supernatural family. Owen appeared in thirteen episodes before deciding to leave the series to get married and move to New York. Pat Priest was brought in as her replacement and finished the rest of the show’s two-season run. The two actresses bore a strong resemblance to each other, which helped the transition go unnoticed by many casual viewers. Marilyn remained a consistent character throughout the cast change.

‘Sense8’ (2015–2018)

Aml Ameen portrayed Capheus “Van Damn” Onyango during the first season of the science fiction series. Following creative differences with the directors, Ameen left the show before the second season began. Toby Onwumere was cast to replace him and made his debut in the Christmas special. The show addressed the change with a brief line about the character looking different after a haircut. Despite the new actor, Capheus’ role in the “sensate” cluster remained vital to the overarching plot.

‘Crazy Ex-Girlfriend’ (2015–2019)

Santino Fontana played Greg Serrano, a primary love interest, for the first season and part of the second season. After Greg left the story to attend law school, the character remained absent for two years. When he returned in the fourth season, he was portrayed by Skylar Astin. The show used this recasting as a narrative device, suggesting that the protagonist saw him differently now that she had undergone personal growth. This was a rare instance where the recast was integrated into the show’s psychological themes.

‘The Office’ (2005–2013)

Helene Beesly, Pam’s mother, was first played by Shannon Cochran in the second season episode ‘The Dundies’. When the character returned to the series in the sixth season to begin a relationship with Michael Scott, she was played by Linda Purl. Purl’s version of the character was more prominent and appeared in several episodes throughout the middle of the series. The show made no mention of the change in appearance despite the character’s new importance. Fans of the series often cite this as one of the show’s most noticeable inconsistencies.

‘The Office’ (2005–2013)

In the fourth season finale, Andy Bernard’s father is briefly played by an uncredited actor during a scene at Andy’s engagement party. When the character, Walter Bernard Sr., returned for a significant role in the eighth season, he was portrayed by Stephen Collins. This version of the character was significantly more cold and dismissive than the man briefly glimpsed years earlier. The show also retroactively changed the character’s name between these appearances. These inconsistencies highlight the shifting nature of Andy’s backstory as his character evolved.

‘Dynasty’ (1981–1989)

Fallon Carrington was originally played by Pamela Sue Martin for the first four seasons of the prime-time soap opera. After Martin chose to leave the series, the character was presumed dead in a plane crash to allow for a narrative gap. When the character was revealed to be alive in the fifth season, she was portrayed by Emma Samms. Samms continued the role in the spinoff ‘The Colbys’ before returning to the main series. The show treated the return of Fallon as a major event, regardless of the new actress.

‘Dallas’ (1978–1991)

Barbara Bel Geddes portrayed the matriarch Miss Ellie Ewing for the majority of the legendary soap opera. In 1984, she stepped away for health reasons, and Donna Reed was cast as her replacement for one season. When Bel Geddes felt healthy enough to return the following year, the producers fired Reed and brought Bel Geddes back. This created a situation where the character changed faces twice in a very short period. The series continued its complicated plotlines without addressing the physical fluctuations of the Ewing matriarch.

‘Batman’ (1966–1968)

The role of Catwoman was famously played by two different actresses during the original run of the ‘Batman’ television series. Julie Newmar originated the role and played the character for the first two seasons. When Newmar was unavailable for the third season, Eartha Kitt stepped into the role. Kitt’s portrayal was celebrated for its distinct energy and purring delivery. Despite the change in both actress and racial background, the show treated the character as the same persistent nemesis.

‘The Goldbergs’ (2013–2023)

Jackie Geary, the girlfriend of Adam Goldberg, was originally played by Rowan Blanchard in the fourth and fifth seasons. When Blanchard left the series to pursue other opportunities, the role was taken over by Alexis G. Zall in the sixth season. The character’s appearance changed significantly, but the relationship with Adam continued as if nothing had happened. Eventually, the character was written out of the show as the narrative moved toward Adam’s high school graduation. The recast allowed the show to conclude the character’s arc naturally.

‘Supergirl’ (2015–2021)

Alura Zor-El, Kara’s biological mother, was portrayed by Laura Benanti during the first two seasons of the series. Due to Benanti’s commitments on Broadway, she was unable to continue the role when the character became more active in the plot. Erica Durance, who had previously played Lois Lane in ‘Smallville’, was cast as the new Alura for the third season and beyond. The show utilized the change to bring another legacy DC actor into the fold. The transition was handled without an in-universe explanation for Alura’s new face.

‘Gossip Girl’ (2007–2012)

Eleanor Waldorf, Blair’s fashion designer mother, appeared in the pilot episode played by Florencia Lozano. By the second episode, Margaret Colin had taken over the role and remained for the duration of the series. Colin’s portrayal became the definitive version of the character, balancing her demanding professional life with her complex relationship with Blair. The pilot remains the only instance where Lozano is seen as the character in the series’ history. The show proceeded without ever acknowledging that Blair’s mother had changed between the first and second episodes.

Share your favorite or most jarring television recastings in the comments.