Tobey Maguire, 50, Sparks Outrage After Cozying Up With 20‑Year‑Old Model at Super Bowl
Tobey Maguire, the 50-year-old Spider-Man star, has set tongues wagging after being spotted getting cozy with 20-year-old American model Mishka Silva during the Super Bowl on Sunday. The pair were seen enjoying a private conversation from a VIP suite at Levi’s Stadium in Santa Clara, California.
Photos from the event showed Silva smiling and playing with her hair while sitting next to Maguire, appearing relaxed and engaged in their chat. Footage of them even appeared on the stadium’s jumbotron, quickly making the rounds online.
Even Tobey Maguire is happy for Bad Bunny 🫶 #SuperBowl pic.twitter.com/Td3jiEvMU4
— lebaza 𓅓 (@jonathanlebaza) February 9, 2026
The duo wasn’t alone. Celebrities including Jessica Alba, Cardi B, Travis Scott, Dylan Sprouse, and Kevin Costner were also in the suite, making it a star-studded gathering. Silva, who has modeled for Guess, Steve Madden, Too Faced, and Smashbox, later posted some of her own Super Bowl photos on Instagram.
She captioned one carousel, “Super bowl weekend was so good i forgot to take photos, thank you @raisingcanes,” showing her gratitude to the fast-food chain that hosted her.
One of the photos featured Silva in a fringed, brown suede jacket, which caught attention online. The jacket’s designer, Kaeya Winter, even shared a screenshot of a news article about the images with the caption: “Love it when my jacket becomes famous at the Super Bowl lol @mishkasilva.”
Maguire’s love life has been widely covered in the media. He was married to jewelry designer Jennifer Meyer, 48, from 2007 until their separation in 2016 and divorce finalization in 2020. The couple has two children together: Ruby, 19, and Otis, 16.
After his divorce, Maguire dated model Tatiana Dieteman, 33, for three years before splitting in 2022. In 2024, he was briefly linked to 20-year-old actress and model Lily Chee, sparking online discussion due to their age difference. At the time, social media users pointed out the large gap, with one X user commenting, “Spider-Man was released a year BEFORE she was born this is crazy,” earning over 13,000 likes.
The speculation about Maguire’s relationships has led to public defenses from Meyer. During a previous controversy, Meyer explained that Maguire was only helping Chee to her car, writing, “being a good guy.” She added, “And now he has [been] blasted online for dating someone he is not. But thank you for your rude comment. I hope it made you feel better today. Wishing you love and light.”
Tobey Maguire’s choice to sit close to someone much younger will naturally attract attention and debate. While some may see it as harmless fun, others are bound to question the age gap. What do you think about Maguire’s Super Bowl moment? Share your thoughts in the comments.
