Cancelled ‘Emerald Knights’ Concept Art Shows Guy Gardner Saving the Day in the Green Lantern Series We Never Got
HBO’s ‘Lanterns’ may have given Green Lantern fans a grounded, small-town murder mystery, but it was never the only version of the story in play. Before it existed, a very different series was taking shape, and new ‘Emerald Knights’ concept art is giving fans a peek at what they missed. HBO Max had ordered the show to series in 2020, with the plot built around a multitude of Lanterns.
The cancelled project had real momentum behind it. It was picked up for 10 episodes, later trimmed to 8, with Seth Grahame-Smith as showrunner and Marc Guggenheim writing. Casting had even begun before everything fell apart.
The latest piece to surface is a striking one. It shows Guy Gardner standing in the wreckage of an exploding naval ship, shielding first responders with a glowing green construct while fire rages behind him. The image is credited to concept artist Rado Markovic and comes by way of the studio One Pixel Brush.
It’s a very different tone from the brooding detective vibe of ‘Lanterns’. One Pixel Brush recently posted several pieces on ArtStation, including a set piece with 2 of the leads facing a Manhunter. Together, the images suggest a show built around large, heroic set pieces rather than quiet investigation.
New concept art from the cancelled Green Lantern series ‘EMERALD KNIGHTS’ has surfaced! Guy Gardner shields first responders from an exploding naval ship in the key art. (via One Pixel Brush | Artist: Rado Markovic) https://t.co/0RszVzNTxW
— DC Film News (@DCFilmNews) November 20, 2026
The series was designed to jump between time periods. It would have been split across 1941, with Jeremy Irvine as Alan Scott, and 1984, with Finn Wittrock as Guy Gardner alongside a new half-alien Lantern named Bree Jarta. That structure alone would have set it apart from anything else in the DC lineup.
The roster was also crowded. Jessica Cruz, Simon Baz, Kilowog and Sinestro were all planned to appear, with the Manhunters serving as the main villains. Bree was never cast, since the production never found an actress for the role.
Guy’s look has drawn plenty of discussion. One outlet noted that he looks a lot more like the 90s Lantern Kyle Rayner. The absence of his signature bowl-cut is jarring, though Guggenheim said the suit would have been tweaked to reflect his Justice League International look.
Wittrock’s hair is part of that conversation too. It’s unclear whether the tweak would have extended beyond the costume to his entire look. Either way, the art shows a version of the character who is less cartoonish and more battle-ready.
The shift in direction came with a change of leadership. In its coverage of the slate presentation, The Hollywood Reporter quoted Peter Safran saying Greg Berlanti’s vision was “more of a space opera.” DC Studios wanted something more terrestrial, closer to a detective story.
Both Guggenheim and Grahame-Smith moved on, and the plans were replaced by new ones that became this year’s ‘Lanterns’. The cast felt the loss. Irvine has said he was gutted by the cancellation, adding that the scripts were great.
The timing is part of the appeal. ‘Lanterns’ premiered on HBO on Aug. 16 and aired weekly through Oct. 4. Fans have spent the weeks since weighing what the show delivered against the space-faring spectacle it didn’t.
There’s also uncertainty around its future. A Variety report suggests the series won’t return for a second season, though HBO and DC Studios haven’t officially announced a cancellation. With that unconfirmed, nostalgia for the road not taken is only growing louder.
Although ‘Emerald Knights’ shares plot points with ‘Lanterns’, it would have been far more space-based. The concept art backs that up with big team battles, alien monsters and a hero who throws himself between danger and civilians.
The ship-explosion key art makes the case in a single image. It shows Gardner as protector first and brawler second, a version of him that rarely gets the spotlight. Whether or not any of it ever reaches the screen, fans now have a vivid sense of what that show might have looked like.
Which Green Lantern series would you rather have watched?
Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!
