Elizabeth Olsen’s Underrated Films: 10 Hidden Gems Worth Watching

Elizabeth Olsen has carved out an impressive career, blending indie dramas with blockbuster hits. While most know her as Wanda Maximoff in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, her work outside the superhero spotlight reveals a versatile actress who shines in quieter, character-driven stories.

From gripping thrillers to heartfelt comedies, Olsen’s lesser-known roles show her ability to bring depth and emotion to any project. Let’s dive into ten of her most underrated films that deserve more attention, ranked from tenth to first, showcasing her range beyond the MCU.

Liberal Arts (2012)

This charming comedy-drama follows Jesse, a college admissions officer, who returns to his alma mater and sparks a connection with Zibby, a lively sophomore played by Olsen. The age gap between them stirs up questions about life and love.

Olsen’s portrayal of Zibby is warm and vibrant, making her feel like a real person rather than a cliché. Directed by Josh Radnor, the film blends humor and heart, with Olsen’s chemistry with her co-star adding a genuine spark.

Kodachrome (2018)

In this road-trip drama, Olsen plays Zooey, a nurse joining a dying photographer and his estranged son on a journey to develop old film at the last Kodachrome lab. The story explores family ties and closure.

Olsen’s supporting role stands out, bringing quiet strength to the emotional core. Paired with Jason Sudeikis and Ed Harris, her performance adds warmth to a bittersweet tale of reconciliation.

Red Lights (2012)

This psychological thriller centers on a psychologist and her assistant investigating a famous psychic. Olsen plays Sally Owen, a student caught up in the tense world of paranormal research.

Her subtle yet engaging performance holds its own alongside Cillian Murphy and Sigourney Weaver. Though the film received mixed reviews, Olsen’s early work here shows her knack for grounding complex stories.

Very Good Girls (2014)

Olsen stars as Gerry, one of two best friends navigating love and loss before heading to college. The plot thickens when both fall for the same guy, testing their bond.

Her chemistry with Dakota Fanning brings authenticity to this coming-of-age story. Olsen captures the messy emotions of youth, making this indie drama a hidden gem despite its modest reception.

In Secret (2014)

Based on Émile Zola’s novel, this dark period drama features Olsen as Thérèse, a woman trapped in a loveless marriage who spirals into a dangerous affair. The story blends love, betrayal, and tragedy.

Olsen’s intense performance carries the film’s gothic tone, showcasing her ability to portray complex, conflicted characters. Her work opposite Oscar Isaac adds depth to this overlooked thriller.

I Saw the Light (2015)

This biographical drama tells the story of country music legend Hank Williams, with Olsen as his wife, Audrey. The film explores their turbulent marriage amid his rise to fame.

Olsen’s heartfelt portrayal of Audrey’s frustration and love steals the show. Despite the film’s mixed reviews, her performance brings emotional weight to this musical tale.

Kill Your Darlings (2013)

Olsen plays Edie Parker, a novelist and wife of Jack Kerouac, in this drama about the Beat Generation’s early years. The story follows a group of poets caught up in a murder scandal.

Though her role is smaller, Olsen’s presence adds warmth to the ensemble, including Daniel Radcliffe and Dane DeHaan. Her understated performance fits the film’s intense, artistic vibe.

Silent House (2011)

In this chilling horror film, Olsen plays Sarah, a young woman trapped in her family’s vacation home, facing eerie and possibly supernatural events. The real-time filming adds to the tension.

Olsen’s gripping performance carries the film, blending fear and vulnerability. Her ability to hold the audience’s attention in this early role makes it a standout in her career.

Ingrid Goes West (2017)

This dark comedy tackles social media obsession, with Olsen as Taylor Sloane, an influencer who becomes the target of a fan’s fixation. The story blends humor with sharp commentary.

Olsen shines as the seemingly perfect yet flawed Taylor, balancing charm and vanity. Her chemistry with Aubrey Plaza makes this satire both fun and thought-provoking.

Martha Marcy May Marlene (2011)

Olsen’s breakout role as Martha, a young woman escaping a cult, remains her most powerful performance. The film weaves between her past trauma and present struggles, creating a haunting character study.

Her raw, emotional portrayal captures the pain of rebuilding a life after abuse. This indie thriller showcases Olsen’s talent for complex roles and deserves far more recognition.

Which of Elizabeth Olsen’s underrated films is your favorite, or did we miss one you love? Drop your thoughts in the comments!