5 Things About ‘The Incredible Hulk’ That Made Zero Sense and 5 Things That Made Perfect Sense

The Incredible Hulk (2008) kicked off as the second film in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, bringing Bruce Banner’s green alter ego to life with Edward Norton in the lead. Directed by Louis Leterrier, it aimed to reboot the character after the mixed reception of Hulk (2003), leaning into action and a fugitive story that echoed the classic 1970s TV series.

I found it a solid entry, packed with thrilling moments, but not without flaws. Some parts felt spot-on for the Hulk’s mythos, while others left me scratching my head. Let’s dive into five things that didn’t add up and five that hit the mark perfectly.

Emil Blonsky’s Rapid Transformation Made Zero Sense

Emil Blonsky, played by Tim Roth, goes from a skilled soldier to a monstrous Abomination in what feels like no time. He’s injected with a super-soldier serum and later gets a dose of Banner’s gamma-irradiated blood, turning him into a hulking beast. 

The speed of this change is jarring. Unlike Bruce, who struggles with his Hulk side for years, Blonsky’s shift happens too fast, with little buildup to explain his physical or mental leap. It feels like the story rushed to give Hulk a big bad to fight without grounding Blonsky’s descent.

Bruce’s Fugitive Life Made Perfect Sense

Bruce Banner living as a fugitive, hiding in Brazil’s favelas, feels like a natural fit for his character. He’s on the run from the military, trying to stay calm to avoid transforming. 

This setup captures the tragic, lonely vibe of the Hulk from the comics and the 1970s TV show. Edward Norton’s performance sells Bruce’s quiet desperation, making his struggle to blend in and stay under the radar a compelling anchor for the film.

Betty Ross’s Underdeveloped Role Made Zero Sense

Liv Tyler’s Betty Ross, Bruce’s love interest, feels like a missed opportunity. She’s a scientist and General Ross’s daughter, but the film barely explores her beyond being a romantic figure. 

Her character lacks depth, with no real arc or impact on the story outside of supporting Bruce. Given her importance in the comics, it’s odd that she’s reduced to a sidekick who doesn’t get to shine on her own.

The Nod to the TV Series Made Perfect Sense

The film’s tribute to The Incredible Hulk (1978-1982) TV series is a standout. From the iconic theme music playing faintly in the background to Bruce’s drifter lifestyle, it nails the tone of the classic show. 

Cameos like Lou Ferrigno as a security guard add a fun touch for longtime fans. These nods ground the movie in Hulk’s history, making it feel like a love letter to the character’s roots.

The Military’s Obsession with Weaponizing Hulk Made Zero Sense

General Ross, played by William Hurt, is dead-set on capturing Bruce to recreate the Hulk as a military weapon. But this plan feels flimsy when you consider the Hulk’s uncontrollable nature. 

Why would the army think they could harness a rage-fueled giant who smashes everything in sight? The logic falls apart, as there’s no clear strategy for controlling or replicating the Hulk without causing chaos.

Hulk’s Action Sequences Made Perfect Sense

The film’s action scenes deliver exactly what you’d want from a Hulk movie. When he smashes through buildings or takes on the military, it’s pure chaos in the best way. 

The final battle with Abomination in Harlem is a highlight, showcasing Hulk’s raw power. The darker green design and gritty CGI make him feel like a terrifying force, perfectly capturing the comic book spectacle.

Bruce’s Cure Research Being Dropped Made Zero Sense

Bruce works with Dr. Samuel Sterns to find a cure for his Hulk transformations, and they seem close to a breakthrough. Yet, after the film, this plotline is never revisited in the MCU. 

It’s strange that Bruce, a brilliant scientist, wouldn’t keep pursuing this, especially since he still struggles with control in later films like The Avengers (2012). The abandoned thread feels like a loose end that deserved follow-up.

The MCU Connections Made Perfect Sense

The Incredible Hulk plants early seeds for the MCU’s shared universe. Tony Stark’s cameo at the end, tying the film to Iron Man (2008), is a smart move that hints at the Avengers forming. 

SHIELD’s subtle presence, like their logo on equipment, adds to the interconnected feel. These touches make the film a key stepping stone in building the larger Marvel narrative.

Tim Roth’s Casting as Blonsky Made Zero Sense

Tim Roth is a talented actor, but he feels miscast as Emil Blonsky, an elite soldier. His smaller stature and less imposing presence don’t quite match the role of a tough, battle-hardened operative. 

When Blonsky becomes Abomination, the contrast is even starker. A more physically commanding actor might have made his transformation and rivalry with Hulk feel more believable.

Edward Norton’s Casting Made Perfect Sense

Edward Norton as Bruce Banner is a casting win. His ability to portray a tormented, introspective scientist grappling with a monster inside feels spot-on. 

Norton brings a quiet intensity that makes Bruce’s fear of losing control palpable. His performance carries the emotional weight of the character, making you root for him despite the chaos he unleashes.

What’s your take on The Incredible Hulk (2008)—love it, hate it, or somewhere in between? Drop your thoughts in the comments!