5 Things About ‘Avengers: Infinity War’ That Made Zero Sense and 5 Things That Made Perfect Sense

Avengers: Infinity War (2018) is a massive superhero film that brings together dozens of Marvel characters to fight Thanos, a powerful villain aiming to wipe out half of all life. Fans loved its action, emotional moments, and bold story, but some parts left viewers scratching their heads, while others clicked perfectly.

The movie balances epic battles with deep character moments, but not every choice holds up under scrutiny. Here are five things that made no sense and five that worked brilliantly, starting with the confusing bits and alternating with the ones that nailed it.

Star-Lord’s Emotional Outburst (Zero Sense)

Star-Lord loses control when he learns Thanos killed Gamora, his love interest. He attacks Thanos, ruining the plan to remove the Infinity Gauntlet, which could have stopped the villain’s plan.

This moment feels forced and out of character. Star-Lord, usually a quick-thinking leader, ignores the stakes and costs the team a clear chance to win, making his reaction seem selfish and poorly timed.

Thanos’ Motivation (Perfect Sense)

Thanos believes wiping out half of all life will save the universe from overpopulation and resource depletion. His twisted logic stems from seeing his own planet, Titan, collapse due to these issues.

This reasoning, while extreme, gives Thanos depth as a villain. His calm conviction and willingness to sacrifice everything, including Gamora, make him a compelling and understandable antagonist.

Doctor Strange’s Time Stone Decision (Zero Sense)

Doctor Strange hands over the Time Stone to Thanos to save Tony Stark’s life. He claims it’s the only way, despite earlier saying he’d let Stark die to protect the stone.

This choice feels inconsistent with Strange’s duty as Sorcerer Supreme. The film doesn’t clearly explain why saving Stark is worth risking the universe, leaving viewers confused about his motives.

The Wakanda Battle Strategy (Perfect Sense)

Wakanda’s army faces Thanos’ forces in an open-field battle to protect Vision and the Mind Stone. They use advanced technology, tight formations, and teamwork to hold off the enemy.

This sequence shines because it shows Wakanda’s strength and unity. The strategy feels realistic, with clear stakes and a desperate effort to protect a key asset, making the battle thrilling and logical.

Vision’s Lack of Action (Zero Sense)

Vision, powered by the Mind Stone, is a super-intelligent being with immense strength. Yet, he spends much of the film weakened and barely fighting, even when Thanos’ forces attack.

This passivity doesn’t add up. Vision’s abilities should make him a major player, but his limited role feels like a plot device to keep the focus on other heroes, which weakens his character.

Thor’s Journey to Nidavellir (Perfect Sense)

Thor travels to Nidavellir with Rocket and Groot to forge Stormbreaker, a weapon capable of killing Thanos. The mission shows his determination to avenge his people and stop the villain.

This arc works because it gives Thor a clear goal and showcases his resilience. The forging scene is visually stunning and builds hope for a counterattack, tying perfectly into the story’s stakes.

The Snap’s Random Selection (Zero Sense)

Thanos’ snap wipes out half of all life randomly, affecting heroes and civilians alike. But the film doesn’t explain how this randomness works or why certain characters survive while others don’t.

This lack of clarity makes the snap feel arbitrary. Without a clear rule for who lives or dies, the emotional weight of the event loses some impact, leaving viewers puzzled.

Tony Stark’s Sacrifice Setup (Perfect Sense)

Tony Stark faces Thanos in a brutal one-on-one fight, knowing he’s outmatched but still trying to protect the universe. His desperation and courage highlight his growth from a self-centered playboy to a selfless hero.

This moment lands because it builds on Tony’s arc across the Marvel films. His willingness to risk everything feels earned, making the fight a standout for character development.

Gamora’s Death Location (Zero Sense)

Thanos sacrifices Gamora on Vormir to get the Soul Stone, but the film doesn’t explain why Vormir is the stone’s location or how Thanos knows to go there. The planet feels like a random plot device.

This lack of context makes the scene feel convenient. Without backstory on Vormir or the stone’s rules, Gamora’s death loses some emotional and narrative weight.

The Emotional Stakes of Failure (Perfect Sense)

The film ends with Thanos winning, wiping out half of all life, including many beloved heroes. The surviving characters grapple with shock, grief, and helplessness as they face the consequences.

This bold ending works because it raises the stakes like never before. The raw emotion and sense of loss make the story feel real and set up a powerful drive for the next film.

What’s your take on these moments from Avengers: Infinity War—share your thoughts in the comments!