After 5 Seasons, ‘The Boys’ Just Achieved Something Most Shows Never Do Despite the Finale Backlash

According to Rotten Tomatoes data shared across public ratings tracking, The Boys has managed to keep a “Fresh” critic score across all five of its seasons, which is something very few long-running shows manage to do.

The ratings across the seasons stay strong throughout the show’s run. Season 1 sits at 85 percent, Season 2 jumps to 97 percent, Season 3 peaks at 98 percent, Season 4 holds at 92 percent, and Season 5 returns to 97 percent. Even with changes in tone, story direction, and audience debate, critics have consistently marked each season as generally positive.

At first glance, this kind of consistency might look like perfect agreement, but part of it comes down to how Rotten Tomatoes works. The platform does not calculate an average score. Instead, it uses a simple system where each review is labeled either positive or negative. That means a critic giving a season a 3 out of 5 can still count as “Fresh.” This system can make overall percentages look higher than a traditional grading average would suggest.

As the show progressed, some critics did point out issues like slower pacing or repeated story ideas. However, many still praised the show’s production quality, performances, and dark humor. That meant even mixed reviews often still counted as positive overall.

Another major factor is the show’s identity. Reported by critics over multiple seasons, The Boys has been praised for its sharp satire of politics, media, and corporate power. Even when certain episodes or arcs felt uneven, reviewers often highlighted how the show stayed relevant to real-world issues, which helped maintain overall positive reception.

The performances also played a big role. Antony Starr’s portrayal of Homelander and Karl Urban’s performance as Billy Butcher were repeatedly singled out as strong points. Even when critics had complaints about the story structure, the acting kept reviews in favorable territory.

There is also the idea of changing critic pools over time. Some early reviewers who disliked the show’s extreme violence or tone may have stopped covering later seasons. This leaves a more consistent group of critics who already appreciate the series, which can naturally keep ratings stable across time.

While critics have stayed largely positive, audience reactions have become more divided in later seasons. Fans have debated character arcs, pacing, and the direction of the story more intensely as the series went on.

Still, the overall outcome is clear. Across five seasons, The Boys has remained consistently “Fresh,” showing a rare level of critical stability for a long-running, controversial, and highly stylized series.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!