Is Martian Manhunter Actually in HBO’s ‘Lanterns’? Here’s the Truth Behind the Confusion

Superhero television has a funny way of scrambling fan expectations before a single frame even airs, especially when a show’s title sounds like it’s referencing one character while actually building toward something else entirely. HBO’s newest DC series has managed to do exactly that, and the confusion has only grown louder as the show’s mythology has unfolded.

“Lanterns” follows veteran Green Lantern Hal Jordan, played by Kyle Chandler, as he trains newest recruit John Stewart, played by Aaron Pierre, while the two investigate a mysterious alien incident in Rushville, Nebraska. As the series has rolled out its central villains, one name in particular has sent longtime DC fans down a rabbit hole of speculation.

That name is the Manhunters, a shapeshifting alien threat introduced as the show’s primary antagonists. Given the obvious phonetic overlap with J’onn J’onzz, the beloved Justice League hero known as Martian Manhunter, plenty of viewers have understandably assumed the two are connected, or that J’onn himself might finally be making his live-action debut through this series.

He isn’t. Despite the shared name and shapeshifting ability, the Manhunters featured in “Lanterns” are an entirely separate concept from Martian Manhunter, and no casting or appearance has been confirmed for the character anywhere in the show.

In the world of “Lanterns,” the Manhunters are described by one alien character as “the most dangerous beings to ever exist in the galaxy,” a robotic police force originally created by the Guardians of the Universe long before the Green Lantern Corps ever existed. According to the show’s mythology, these Manhunters can shapeshift to take the form of any species, allowing them to blend seamlessly into human populations while investigating or eliminating threats.

That backstory tracks closely with the character’s comic book origins. In DC Comics lore, the Manhunters served as the Guardians’ original artificial-intelligence police force, patrolling the universe until they eventually turned against their creators and began wiping out entire planets, an uprising that ultimately led to their replacement by the Green Lantern Corps.

The shapeshifting ability and shared “Manhunter” name aren’t entirely coincidental, either. While the robotic Manhunters and Martian Manhunter are not the same entity, comic book lore has previously revealed that the robotic Manhunters actually took their name, and much of their underlying technology, from the ancient Martian civilization that once protected their homeworld, a group closely tied to J’onn J’onzz’s own origins.

That lore connection has made the mix-up almost inevitable for casual viewers encountering the Manhunters for the first time. Between the identical name and the shapeshifting powers both groups share, it’s an easy assumption to make, especially for fans who know Martian Manhunter primarily through his shapeshifting abilities in shows like “Justice League” and “Justice League Unlimited.”

Adding to the intrigue, “Lanterns” has already confirmed strong ties to James Gunn’s broader DC Universe, including John Stewart’s confirmed appearance in the upcoming “Man of Tomorrow” film alongside Superman and Lex Luthor. With DC actively building out its shared cinematic and television universe, fans have reasonably speculated that any Manhunter-related storyline could eventually open the door for Martian Manhunter’s own introduction somewhere down the line.

For now, though, that remains speculation rather than confirmed plans. James Gunn has previously teased that the Manhunters would play a vital role in the DCU’s broader storytelling, but nothing officially released so far ties that plotline directly to J’onn J’onzz or hints at his casting.

Given how deliberately James Gunn and Peter Safran have connected projects across DC Studios’ “Gods and Monsters” chapter, it wouldn’t be surprising if the Manhunters’ storyline in “Lanterns” eventually laid groundwork for Martian Manhunter’s proper introduction in a future project. That kind of connective tissue has already defined much of the DCU’s rollout strategy, from Guy Gardner’s appearances spanning “Superman,” “Peacemaker” and now “Lanterns,” to Sinestro’s live-action debut within the same series.

Until DC Studios makes an official announcement, though, fans should treat any Martian Manhunter appearance in “Lanterns” as unconfirmed. The robotic Manhunters remain their own distinct threat within the show’s central mystery, one rooted in ancient Green Lantern comic lore rather than a direct tie-in to J’onn J’onzz’s own story.

With “Lanterns” continuing its weekly rollout on HBO and HBO Max through its October 4 finale, fans will have plenty of time to see exactly how deep the show’s Manhunter mystery ultimately goes.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!