LGBT Actors Who Faced the Most Backlash from the Audiences

Public scrutiny is an unavoidable aspect of fame but some LGBT actors have faced particularly intense waves of disapproval or controversy from audiences. This backlash often stems from personal scandals, professional decisions, or polarizing statements that alienate fanbases. While some actors manage to rehabilitate their images over time, others find their careers permanently altered by the negative reception. The following list explores male actors who have navigated significant public outcries and the specific circumstances that triggered them.

Kevin Spacey

Kevin Spacey faced an immediate and overwhelming career collapse following sexual assault allegations made against him in 2017. The actor attempted to deflect the story by coming out as gay in his response statement which drew immense criticism from the LGBT community and the general public. Critics argued he was conflating his sexuality with predatory behavior which further damaged his reputation. He was subsequently removed from ‘House of Cards’ and erased from the film ‘All the Money in the World’.

Jussie Smollett

Jussie Smollett became the center of a massive media firestorm after he staged a hate crime against himself in Chicago. The ‘Empire’ actor initially received an outpouring of support which turned to outrage when police investigations revealed the deception. He faced legal consequences and a complete rejection from the entertainment industry for exploiting social justice movements. The incident remains one of the most high-profile examples of a celebrity destroying their own credibility.

Jeffrey Tambor

Jeffrey Tambor received critical acclaim for his role as a trans woman in ‘Transparent’ but faced a sharp downfall due to harassment allegations. Accusations of sexual misconduct from his assistant and co-star Trace Lysette led to his firing from the show. The backlash was compounded by the ongoing debate regarding cisgender men playing transgender roles. His departure marked a bitter end to a show that had been a landmark for trans representation.

John Barrowman

John Barrowman faced renewed scrutiny when historic allegations of him exposing himself on the sets of ‘Doctor Who’ and ‘Torchwood’ resurfaced. Although he had previously apologized for what he termed high-spirited behavior, the changing industry standards led to a severe audience reaction. He was removed from immersive theater projects and faced calls for his removal from television hosting duties. The controversy highlighted the shift in what audiences consider acceptable workplace conduct.

Noah Schnapp

‘Stranger Things’ star Noah Schnapp faced a barrage of online criticism due to his social media activity regarding the conflict in Gaza. A video featuring stickers that many found insensitive circulated widely and led to calls for boycotts of the show’s final season. The young actor eventually released a statement clarifying his desire for peace but the digital footprint caused lasting friction with a segment of his fanbase. This incident demonstrated how quickly political expression can impact a young star’s standing.

Kit Connor

Kit Connor experienced a unique form of backlash where fans of ‘Heartstopper’ aggressively accused him of queerbaiting. The relentless harassment on social media eventually forced the young actor to come out as bisexual before he was ready. He expressed frustration that audiences missed the point of the show by forcing him to label himself publicly. The incident sparked a wider conversation about the toxicity of entitlement within fandoms.

Elliot Page

Elliot Page faced a predictable but intense wave of transphobic backlash from conservative audiences upon announcing his transition in 2020. While he received support from many, he also became a target for anti-trans rhetoric and online harassment campaigns. His memoir and subsequent interviews have detailed the hostility he encountered from both the public and industry figures. despite the noise, he continued to work on ‘The Umbrella Academy’ and advocate for trans rights.

Billy Eichner

Billy Eichner faced criticism following the box office disappointment of his romantic comedy ‘Bros’. The actor and writer blamed straight audiences for not showing up to support a gay film which many perceived as an antagonistic stance. Online discourse shifted from supporting the film to criticizing his marketing approach and perceived entitlement. The backlash overshadowed the positive critical reception the movie had initially received.

Ricky Martin

Ricky Martin navigated a disturbing period of backlash when his nephew filed a restraining order against him alleging a romantic relationship and harassment. The incest allegations caused a global media frenzy and severe reputational damage before the case was ultimately dismissed and the accuser withdrew the claims. Although he was legally cleared, the sensationalist nature of the headlines created a lingering shadow over his public image. He has since filed a lawsuit against his nephew for extortion and damages.

Neil Patrick Harris

Neil Patrick Harris faced delayed but severe backlash when a photo of a meat platter from his 2011 Halloween party resurfaced years later. The platter was designed to look like the corpse of Amy Winehouse who had died just months prior to the event. Social media users expressed disgust at the insensitivity of the joke which forced Harris to issue a formal apology. The incident tarnished his reputation as a generally unproblematic figure in Hollywood.

Ben Platt

Ben Platt endured a wave of mockery and criticism for his reprisal of the lead role in the film adaptation of ‘Dear Evan Hansen’. Audiences felt he was too old to play a high schooler and accused the production of nepotism since his father produced the film. The backlash was exacerbated by Platt’s defensive responses in interviews regarding the casting choices. The film ultimately struggled at the box office largely due to this negative word-of-mouth.

Zachary Quinto

Zachary Quinto sparked controversy within the LGBT community for his comments regarding HIV prevention and PrEP medication. He suggested that the availability of these drugs might lead to irresponsibility among gay men which drew ire for being judgmental and sex-negative. Activists and health educators criticized him for stigmatizing effective prevention methods. The backlash highlighted the generational divides in how gay men approach sexual health.

Russell Tovey

Russell Tovey faced criticism for comments he made in an interview where he expressed relief that his father did not allow him to become an effeminate “tap-dancing freak.” Many found the remarks to be rooted in internalized homophobia and offensive to more feminine gay men. The actor later apologized and claimed his words were taken out of context but the “masc-for-masc” attitude drew significant ire. It sparked a conversation about masculinity and acceptance within the queer community.

Matt Bomer

Matt Bomer faced a specific backlash when he was cast to play a transgender sex worker in the film ‘Anything’. Transgender activists and allies argued that a cisgender man should not play a trans woman and that the casting contributed to harmful stereotypes. Bomer defended the role as an artistic challenge but the film was largely boycotted and criticized upon release. The controversy served as a flashpoint in the growing movement for authentic casting.

George Takei

George Takei faced a serious allegation of sexual assault from a former model in 2017 which threatened his standing as a beloved icon. The accuser later changed his story and admitted that the events may not have happened as he initially described. While Takei was largely exonerated in the court of public opinion the initial backlash was swift and damaging. He continues to face political backlash regularly due to his outspoken activism on social media.

Rupert Everett

Rupert Everett has frequently courted controversy with his unfiltered opinions on the entertainment industry and gay parenting. He faced backlash for stating that he could not think of anything worse than being raised by two gay dads. His career also suffered after he initially came out as he claimed the industry stopped considering him for leading heterosexual roles. His candid nature has often alienated him from both Hollywood executives and LGBT advocacy groups.

Richard Chamberlain

Richard Chamberlain angered many in the LGBT community when he advised gay actors to stay in the closet to protect their careers. Having come out late in life himself he argued that leading man status was incompatible with open homosexuality. Younger actors and activists criticized his perspective as outdated and harmful to the progress of representation. The backlash positioned him as a figure out of touch with the modern entertainment landscape.

Ian McKellen

Ian McKellen faced criticism for comments he made during a podcast where he appeared to downplay the allegations against Kevin Spacey and Bryan Singer. He suggested that some accusers might be misinterpreting events or that the accused were victims of their own repression. The comments were seen as insensitive to victims of sexual assault and he subsequently issued an apology. The incident was a rare moment of public disapproval for the otherwise revered actor.

Stephen Fry

Stephen Fry faced a blasphemy investigation in Ireland after calling God a “maniac” during a television interview. His comments describing a deity who would create bone cancer in children sparked outrage among religious groups. While the police investigation was eventually dropped the incident generated massive international headlines and debate. Fry refused to retract his statements and stood by his atheist worldview despite the uproar.

Michael Barrymore

Michael Barrymore experienced one of the most dramatic falls from grace in British television history following the death of Stuart Lubbock at his pool party. Although he was never charged with the death the scandal and the revelations about the party atmosphere destroyed his family-friendly image. Audiences turned on the presenter and his attempts at career comebacks have been met with resistance and public protests. The unsolved nature of the case keeps the backlash alive decades later.

Boy George

Boy George faced severe public condemnation after he was convicted of falsely imprisoning a male escort in his home. The singer and occasional actor served prison time and was banned from entering the United States for a period. His involvement as a judge on ‘The Voice’ years later sparked complaints from viewers who felt he should not be given a platform. The seriousness of his crime continues to shadow his entertainment career.

Adam Lambert

Adam Lambert faced immediate backlash from conservative audiences following his performance at the 2009 American Music Awards. His sexually charged routine which included kissing a male band member resulted in thousands of complaints to the network. He was blacklisted from certain television appearances for a time as the industry reacted to the controversy. Lambert has since stated that the incident was a pivotal moment for visibility despite the negative reaction.

Gus Kenworthy

Olympian turned actor Gus Kenworthy faced criticism for his casting as a regular in ‘American Horror Story: 1984’. Viewers and critics panned his acting ability and argued he was cast solely for his physical appearance rather than talent. The backlash was compounded by the perception that he was taking a role that could have gone to a trained actor. He acknowledged the criticism but defended his right to transition into a new career path.

Troye Sivan

Troye Sivan faced backlash regarding his role in the controversial series ‘The Idol’ and his “Rush” music video. Critics accused him of promoting a specific, exclusionary body type and perpetuating the “twink” stereotype without including diverse body shapes. The singer and actor responded to the criticism by noting he was just using his friends and fellow artists in his work. The discourse highlighted the ongoing tensions regarding body image within the gay community.

Sean Hayes

Sean Hayes faced a complicated backlash for his iconic role as Jack McFarland on ‘Will & Grace’. While the show was popular, critics and some LGBT audiences accused him of setting gay men back by relying on flamboyant stereotypes. In later years, he faced criticism for his role in ‘The Three Stooges’ which many found underwhelming. He has since openly discussed the burden of representing an entire community through a single sitcom character.

Jesse Tyler Ferguson

Jesse Tyler Ferguson faced similar criticism to Sean Hayes for his portrayal of Mitchell Pritchett on ‘Modern Family’. Some viewers felt the character was too uptight and played into safe, non-threatening gay stereotypes for the comfort of straight audiences. The actor defended the role as being grounded in reality and representing a specific type of person. Despite the awards success, the show often sparked debates about the limitations of network television representation.

Jonathan Groff

Jonathan Groff faced a wave of criticism during the airing of the HBO series ‘Looking’ for allegedly not being convincing as a gay lead. A controversial review in a major publication labeled him a “miscast straight man” despite Groff being openly gay in real life. The backlash sparked a defense from the community about the diversity of gay mannerisms and the unfair scrutiny placed on out actors. The incident became a case study in how gay actors are policed on their authenticity.

Billy Porter

Billy Porter faced backlash for his comments criticizing Harry Styles appearing on the cover of Vogue in a dress. Porter argued that he had fought for years to wear non-binary fashion on red carpets while Styles was praised for doing the bare minimum. Audiences criticized Porter for gatekeeping gender-fluid fashion and attacking another artist. Porter later apologized to Styles but maintained his stance on the racial disparities in the fashion industry.

Luke Evans

Luke Evans faced scrutiny and backlash regarding the management of his public image and sexuality. After being open about his sexuality early in his career, he became more private while pursuing action roles which some interpreted as going back into the closet. This perceived retreat drew criticism from those who felt he was prioritizing commercial appeal over visibility. He has since normalized his public stance and posts openly about his personal life.

Cheyenne Jackson

Cheyenne Jackson faced an intense personal backlash from fans on social media following the dissolution of his first marriage and quick remarriage. Followers criticized the timing and optics of his relationship changes which led him to defend his privacy aggressively. The situation highlighted the parasocial relationships fans develop with out actors and the judgments placed on their private lives. He has since spoken about the difficulty of navigating divorce in the public eye.

Frankie Grande

Frankie Grande faced significant audience hostility during his appearance on the reality show ‘Big Brother’. Viewers found his personality to be grating and criticized him for leveraging his brother’s fame during the competition. The backlash was visible across social media platforms where he became one of the season’s most disliked contestants. He has continued to work in theater and television despite the polarizing reception.

Colton Haynes

Colton Haynes faced backlash when photos surfaced of him wearing blackface as part of a Halloween costume earlier in his life. The ‘Teen Wolf’ actor issued apologies and expressed regret for his ignorance regarding the offensive nature of the costume. He also opened up about his struggles with addiction and anxiety which garnered some empathy from the public. However, the incident remains a permanent blemish on his record.

Rock Hudson

Rock Hudson faced a tragic form of posthumous backlash after his death from AIDS-related complications in 1985. Revelations that he had continued to kiss co-star Linda Evans on ‘Dynasty’ while knowing his diagnosis caused panic and anger due to misinformation about transmission. The industry turned its back on his memory briefly before he became a symbol for the fight against the disease. His story exposed the deep-seated homophobia and fear that characterized the era.

Share your thoughts on these controversies in the comments.