Marvel’s ‘She-Hulk: Attorney at Law’ (2022) brought a fresh vibe to the MCU with its blend of legal drama and superhero comedy. Tatiana Maslany shines as Jennifer Walters, a lawyer who gains Hulk-like powers after an accident with her cousin Bruce Banner, played by Mark Ruffalo. 

The show leans into humor, fourth-wall breaks, and a lighter tone compared to other MCU projects. I loved some parts but scratched my head at others. Here’s my take on five things that didn’t add up and five that hit the mark.

Things That Made Zero Sense

Jennifer’s Instant Hulk Mastery

Jennifer transforms into She-Hulk and somehow nails her powers right away. Unlike Bruce, who struggled for years to control his Hulk side, she’s flipping between forms like it’s no big deal. It feels unrealistic that she’d adapt so fast without any real training or emotional turmoil. The show brushes off her learning curve, which undermines the stakes of her transformation.

This quick mastery also makes Bruce’s struggles look trivial. I get that the show wants to show Jen’s confidence, but it skips over the messy growth that could’ve made her journey more relatable. It’s like she’s handed a perfect superhero package without earning it.

The Spotty CGI Quality

The show’s visuals, especially She-Hulk’s CGI, are hit-or-miss. Sometimes Jen looks solid, but other times her green form feels like a cartoon character in a live-action world. The budget seems stretched thin compared to big-screen MCU projects, and it shows in awkward movements or flat textures. For a character defined by her Hulk form, this inconsistency pulls you out of the story.

It’s not just Jen—some action scenes and background effects look rushed too. When the lead character’s appearance feels off, it’s hard to stay immersed. I wanted to believe in She-Hulk, but the visuals often made it tough.

Overloaded Cameos

The show packs in tons of MCU cameos, from Wong to Daredevil. While some add fun, others feel forced, like they’re there just to remind you this is an MCU show. These guest stars often overshadow Jen’s story, making it feel like a parade of familiar faces rather than her own adventure. It’s distracting when the plot pauses for another cameo.

I love a good crossover, but the sheer number here feels like fan service over substance. It’s as if the writers didn’t trust Jen to carry the show on her own, which is a shame given Maslany’s talent.

The Inconsistent Tone

‘She-Hulk’ wants to be a legal comedy, superhero romp, and social commentary all at once. The mix doesn’t always gel, swinging from goofy humor to heavy themes like online trolling or workplace sexism without much warning. One minute Jen’s joking with the audience, the next she’s dealing with serious issues, and the shifts feel jarring.

This tonal whiplash makes it hard to settle into the show’s vibe. I wanted a clearer focus—either lean into the comedy or dive deeper into the drama. Trying to do it all leaves some episodes feeling scattered.

Underdeveloped Villains

The main antagonist, Todd Phelps, aka HulkKing, feels like a letdown. His plan to steal Jen’s blood and his online hate group, Intelligencia, are intriguing but never fully explored. He’s more of a petty jerk than a menacing threat, and his defeat feels rushed. Other villains, like Titania, pop up but don’t get enough depth to make an impact.

I wanted a bad guy who could match Jen’s wit and strength. Instead, the villains feel like afterthoughts, which weakens the stakes and makes Jen’s victories less satisfying.

Things That Made Perfect Sense

Tatiana Maslany’s Performance

Tatiana Maslany is the heart of the show, bringing charm and relatability to Jennifer Walters. She nails the balance of witty lawyer and reluctant superhero, making Jen feel like someone you’d grab a drink with. Her comedic timing and emotional depth carry even the weaker episodes.

Whether she’s breaking the fourth wall or navigating awkward dates, Maslany makes Jen shine. I couldn’t imagine anyone else in the role—she’s the reason to keep watching.

Fourth-Wall Breaks

Jen’s habit of talking directly to the audience is a nod to the comics and a standout feature. These moments add a playful, self-aware vibe, letting Jen comment on the absurdity of her world or even the MCU itself. The finale, where she confronts the writers and K.E.V.I.N., is a bold, hilarious twist that feels true to her character.

The fourth-wall breaks give the show a unique identity. I loved how they let Jen take control of her story, making her feel like a real person navigating a wild universe.

The Legal Comedy Angle

The show’s focus on Jen as a lawyer handling superhuman cases is a fresh spin for the MCU. Episodes where she tackles quirky legal battles, like representing Abomination or dealing with a superhero divorce, are fun and grounded. It’s a great way to explore the everyday side of a world full of gods and monsters.

This legal lens makes Jen’s story distinct from other MCU heroes. I enjoyed seeing her use her brain as much as her brawn, even if the show didn’t always stick to the courtroom.

Commentary on Gender Dynamics

The show smartly weaves in Jen’s experiences as a woman, from workplace pressure to online harassment. Her line about managing anger daily as a woman explains why she controls her Hulk side better than Bruce. It’s a sharp take on real-world issues, grounded in Jen’s perspective without feeling preachy.

These moments resonate because they tie into Jen’s character arc. I appreciated how the show used her Hulk identity to explore how women navigate power and judgment in a male-dominated world.

The Light, Fun Vibe

Unlike the high-stakes drama of other MCU shows, ‘She-Hulk’ keeps things breezy and fun. The short episodes and comedic tone make it an easy watch, perfect for unwinding. It’s not trying to be ‘Avengers: Endgame’ (2019)—it’s more like a superhero sitcom, and that’s a refreshing change.

This lighthearted approach suits Jen’s laid-back personality. I enjoyed the show’s willingness to poke fun at itself and the MCU, making it a great palate cleanser in the franchise.

What’s your take on ‘She-Hulk: Attorney at Law’—which moments made you laugh or left you confused? Drop your thoughts in the comments!