Tobey Maguire, 50, Faces Criticism Over Outing With 20-Year-Old Influencer
Tobey Maguire has ignited a fiery conversation across the internet after being spotted in the company of Mishka Silva, a 20-year-old social media influencer, during Super Bowl LX. The 50-year-old Spider-Man veteran was seen deep in conversation with Silva in a high-profile VIP box at Levi’s Stadium on February 8.
While the Seattle Seahawks were busy securing their victory over the New England Patriots, the cameras shifted focus to the stands, where the thirty-year age gap between the actor and the model became the evening’s most viral takeaway.
The sighting was further amplified when Silva shared a subtle Instagram story that featured her crossing into Maguire’s personal space, with her heels visible alongside his trademark black trainers.
On social media platforms like X, the reaction was swift and polarized, with many users expressing discomfort over the fact that Silva is only one year older than Maguire’s eldest daughter, Ruby.
One viral post noted that the influencer wasn’t even born when the first Spider-Man movie came out, highlighting the generational divide that has led to comparisons between Maguire and his frequent party companion, Leonardo DiCaprio.
Tobey Maguire en el Super Bowl. pic.twitter.com/lWqwa0xO7I
— Cerebros (@CerebrosG) February 9, 2026
Despite the heavy criticism, a vocal contingency of fans has defended the pairing, arguing that the public should stay out of the business of two consenting adults. Those in Maguire’s corner were quick to point out that the actor has maintained a respectful and private life since his 2016 split from jewelry designer Jennifer Meyer.
Meyer herself has reportedly remained on excellent terms with Maguire, even as she prepares for a new chapter of her own, recently announcing her pregnancy with fiancé Geoffrey Ogunlesi.
Away from the tabloid headlines, Tobey Maguire is currently navigating a significant career revival that balances blockbuster nostalgia with behind-the-scenes leadership. On the other side of this viral moment, Mishka Silva is rapidly evolving from a niche fashion influencer into a mainstream persona.
Silva has also begun exploring a music career, appearing in various music videos and hinting at her own upcoming releases. Whether this Super Bowl outing was a casual meeting between friends or something more, it has undoubtedly placed both the veteran actor and the rising star at the absolute center of the cultural conversation.
Do you think the intense public scrutiny over celebrity age gaps is a necessary cultural conversation about power dynamics, or has the internet become too judgmental regarding the private lives of consenting adults? Share your thoughts in the comments.
