Will ‘The Five-Star Weekend’ Get a Season 2 on Peacock? Here’s What We Know

Jennifer Garner fans binged all eight episodes of ‘The Five-Star Weekend’ the moment it dropped, and now the burning question is whether Hollis Shaw’s Nantucket getaway will continue. The Peacock limited series, based on Elin Hilderbrand’s bestselling novel, wrapped its freshman run this week, leaving plenty of viewers hungry for more.

Between the star power and the source material, it is easy to see why so many are already asking about season two. Here is everything currently known about the future of ‘The Five-Star Weekend.’

‘The Five-Star Weekend’ Season 2 Status

As of now, there is no season two on the books for ‘The Five-Star Weekend.’ Peacock has only announced one season of the series so far, and the book it is based on does not have a sequel at this time. That means there is no ready-made blueprint for the writers to pull from if the streamer decides to keep the story going.

Still, the door has not been closed entirely. A second season is not out of the question, especially considering how similarly structured dramas like ‘Big Little Lies’ and ‘Nine Perfect Strangers’ have proven that a limited series premise can expand later.

Both of those shows started as one and done adaptations before returning for additional installments once audience demand made a compelling case.

For now, though, ‘The Five-Star Weekend’ is being marketed and treated as a self contained event. The series is officially classified as an upcoming American drama television miniseries that premiered on Peacock on July 9, 2026. The word ‘miniseries’ is doing a lot of work there, and it suggests Peacock designed this as a finite story from the start rather than an open ended franchise.

The Elin Hilderbrand Nantucket Novel Source Material

Part of the reason a season two feels uncertain comes down to the source material itself. The show adapts Elin Hilderbrand’s 2023 novel of the same name, with Bekah Brunstetter developing, writing and executive producing the series. Hilderbrand is known for standalone beach reads rather than sprawling multi book sagas, which makes a direct sequel less likely without an entirely new script.

That has not stopped the author from staying deeply involved in the rollout. A companion official podcast hosted by Hilderbrand herself debuted the same day as the show, with new episodes releasing every Thursday throughout July.

Hilderbrand is joined on the podcast by a rotating cast of stars from the series to discuss the story as it unfolds for viewers.

The producing team behind the adaptation is stacked as well. Bekah Brunstetter, Sue Naegle, Ali Krug, Jennifer Garner, Elin Hilderbrand, Merri Howard, Beth Schacter, and Minkie Spiro all serve as executive producers, with the series produced by Universal Content Productions. That level of behind the scenes talent suggests the property is being treated as a prestige swing, even if it stays limited.

Jennifer Garner’s Hollis Shaw Storyline

At the center of it all is Garner’s Hollis Shaw, a famed cook and best selling author whose seemingly perfect life begins to unravel after the sudden death of her husband, exposing cracks in her marriage and her complicated relationship with her daughter. To cope, Hollis decides to host a weekend getaway at her Nantucket home with friends representing different chapters of her life, including one final surprise fifth guest.

Garner has been candid about how personal the project felt to make. Speaking about the show’s themes, Garner told Entertainment Weekly she hopes viewers feel how much the cast loves and understands them, and how much female friendship means to the group, before pausing to soften the sentiment about how important that bond has been to her own life.

Her costars echoed similar feelings about the project’s focus on midlife womanhood. D’Arcy Carden, who plays Brooke Kirtley, described midlife to Entertainment Weekly as a fascinating age where friends in the same group can simultaneously be sending kids to college, expecting a baby, remarrying, or navigating divorce. That range of experience gave the ensemble plenty to work with across all eight episodes.

Critics have generally responded well to how Hollis’s arc was handled. One review noted that the series smartly avoids arguing that Hollis is secretly a mess, instead investigating what it costs to appear like she has it all together, and how that need for control strains her relationship with her daughter and her reliability as a friend. That kind of grounded character work is exactly why fans are so invested in whether Hollis’s story continues.

Five Star Weekend Cast And Reception

Garner is surrounded by a genuinely stacked ensemble. The series also stars D’Arcy Carden, Gemma Chan, Regina Hall, Chloe Sevigny, Harlow Jane, and Timothy Olyphant. Each actress plays a friend from a distinct era of Hollis’s life, which gives the show its rotating cast of perspectives.

Critically, the show has landed in solid, if not spectacular, territory. Rotten Tomatoes reported a 75 percent approval rating with an average score of 6.7 out of 10 based on 12 reviews, while Metacritic assigned it a 70 out of 100 based on 10 critics, indicating generally favorable reviews. Those numbers suggest a warmly received summer watch rather than a runaway critical darling, which may factor into any future renewal conversations.

Reviewers have also placed the series within a broader genre of moneyed beach dramas. One critique described the trend of shows where wealthy characters gather on a cold beach to compare notes and solve intrigues, comparing ‘The Five-Star Weekend’ to Nicole Kidman projects like ‘Big Little Lies,’ ‘The Undoing,’ and ‘The Perfect Couple.’ Despite fitting that mold, the same review argued the show manages to surprise audiences even when its beats feel predetermined.

With all eight episodes now streaming and no confirmed plans for more, ‘The Five-Star Weekend’ currently stands as a complete story rather than the start of a franchise. Given the strength of this ensemble and Hollis’s unresolved journey, do you think Peacock should find a way to bring this Nantucket friend group back for another getaway?