LGBT Actors Who Got the Last Laugh After Being Called Unattractive

Many talented actors in the entertainment industry have faced initial rejection because they did not meet the rigid aesthetic standards of Hollywood. For many queer men this struggle was often compounded by stereotypes regarding their appearance and marketability. These performers proved that their unique features and exceptional skills were their greatest assets rather than liabilities. By achieving critical acclaim and mainstream success they have effectively silenced their early critics. Their careers serve as an inspiration for aspiring artists who do not fit the traditional leading man mold.

Ian McKellen

Ian McKellen spent the early part of his career establishing himself as a formidable presence in the British theater scene. He was frequently categorized as a character actor because he did not possess the typical Hollywood heartthrob look of his era. His transition to global superstardom occurred later in life with iconic roles in ‘The Lord of the Rings’ and ‘X-Men’. He has used his platform to advocate for gay rights and has become one of the most respected figures in modern cinema. His legacy is defined by his immense range and the dignity he brings to every character he portrays.

Harvey Fierstein

Harvey Fierstein rose to prominence with his distinctively raspy voice and unique physical presence that challenged the norms of Broadway and film. He refused to change his appearance or his persona to suit mainstream expectations of what a male lead should look like. His work in ‘Torch Song Trilogy’ and ‘Hairspray’ won him multiple Tony Awards and critical acclaim. He has consistently championed queer stories and proven that being true to oneself is a path to lasting success. His career serves as a blueprint for performers who do not fit into conventional boxes.

Nathan Lane

Nathan Lane is a celebrated actor who initially faced hurdles due to his unconventional looks and boisterous energy. He found his greatest successes on stage and screen by leaning into his comedic timing and unique physical expressiveness. His roles in ‘The Birdcage’ and ‘The Producers’ made him a household name and earned him numerous accolades. He has often spoken about the difficulties of finding a place in an industry that prizes a very specific type of masculinity. His enduring popularity proves that audiences value authenticity and talent over superficial traits.

Stephen Fry

Stephen Fry is a polymath who has navigated a successful career in acting and comedy despite not fitting the traditional leading man archetype. He often used his intellect and wit to carve out a niche for himself in a competitive industry. His performance in ‘Wilde’ demonstrated his ability to lead a major production with depth and sensitivity. He has been open about his struggles with self-esteem and mental health throughout his life. Today he is regarded as a national treasure in the United Kingdom and a global icon for the LGBTQ community.

Alan Cumming

Alan Cumming broke into the industry with a theatrical flair and an unconventional appearance that initially baffled some casting directors. He refused to conform to standard expectations and instead embraced a bold and eclectic style. His breakout role in the Broadway revival of ‘Cabaret’ showcased his incredible talent and paved the way for a diverse film career. He has appeared in major franchises such as ‘X2’ and the television series ‘The Good Wife’. His success highlights the power of individuality in a world that often demands conformity.

Jim Parsons

Jim Parsons became one of the most successful television actors in history despite being told he lacked the look for a traditional leading role. He spent years working in theater and small television parts before landing his life-changing role in ‘The Big Bang Theory’. His portrayal of Sheldon Cooper turned him into a global star and earned him multiple Emmy Awards. He has since transitioned into more dramatic roles on Broadway and in films like ‘The Boys in the Band’. His career is a prime example of how the right role can transform a performer into an icon.

Jesse Tyler Ferguson

Jesse Tyler Ferguson faced challenges early in his career because he was often seen as a character actor rather than a leading man. He found his niche in theater before achieving massive success on the long-running sitcom ‘Modern Family’. His portrayal of Mitchell Pritchett helped change the landscape of queer representation on television. He has continued to work on Broadway where he recently won a Tony Award for his performance in ‘Take Me Out’. His journey shows that perseverance and a commitment to one’s craft eventually lead to well-deserved recognition.

Tituss Burgess

Tituss Burgess is known for his incredible vocal range and a vibrant personality that did not always fit the narrow casting requirements of the past. He worked extensively on Broadway before his breakout role in the series ‘Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt’. His performance as Titus Andromedon became a cultural phenomenon and earned him several award nominations. He has often discussed the importance of representation for Black queer men in the entertainment industry. His success is a testament to the fact that being unapologetically yourself is a powerful career strategy.

Russell Tovey

Russell Tovey has spoken openly about being told his prominent ears and unconventional features would limit his career options. He ignored these critiques and focused on delivering powerful performances in both theater and television. He gained international recognition for his roles in ‘Looking’ and ‘The History Boys’. He has since become a prominent figure in the art world and continues to land significant roles in major productions. His career demonstrates that what some might consider physical flaws can actually become defining and celebrated traits.

Denis O’Hare

Denis O’Hare is a quintessential character actor who has built a prolific career by embracing his unique look and intense acting style. He often plays complex and unconventional characters that require a high degree of skill and vulnerability. His work in ‘American Horror Story’ and ‘True Blood’ has made him a fan favorite and a critical darling. He has consistently chosen projects that challenge him and allow him to showcase his versatility. His long and successful career proves that there is a deep demand for actors who bring something different to the table.

Michael Urie

Michael Urie first gained fame on ‘Ugly Betty’ where he played a character that celebrated a unique sense of style and personality. Before this role he was often told that his look was too specific for mainstream television. He used his comedic instincts and stage experience to make the character of Marc St. James an essential part of the show. He has since enjoyed a successful career in theater and as a director in various television projects. His career highlights the importance of finding roles that celebrate rather than hide one’s unique characteristics.

Jim Rash

Jim Rash is an Oscar-winning screenwriter and actor who has built a successful career by leaning into his comedic persona and distinct appearance. He is perhaps best known for his role as Dean Pelton on the cult favorite comedy series ‘Community’. His ability to commit fully to eccentric and physically demanding comedy made him a standout performer. He has also found great success behind the camera by writing and directing films like ‘The Way Way Back’. His career illustrates that being an unconventional performer can lead to a multifaceted and rewarding career.

Guillermo Díaz

Guillermo Díaz has often discussed how his appearance and background did not align with what many casting directors expected from a lead actor. He built his reputation by playing gritty and intense characters in films like ‘Half Baked’ and ‘Party Girl’. He reached a new level of fame with his role as Huck on the popular political thriller ‘Scandal’. He has broken barriers for Latino and queer actors by consistently playing complex and powerful roles. His success is a clear indication that talent and screen presence are what truly matter in the end.

Harvey Guillén

Harvey Guillén has become a breakout star by challenging body standards and racial stereotypes in Hollywood. He spent years playing small roles before landing the part of Guillermo de la Cruz in ‘What We Do in the Shadows’. His performance has been praised for its depth and comedic timing making him a central figure in the show. He has been vocal about the need for more diverse body types and identities to be represented on screen. His rising career is a significant win for visibility and inclusion in the entertainment industry.

Bowen Yang

Bowen Yang rose from a writer to a featured performer on ‘Saturday Night Live’ while bringing a unique and unapologetic energy to the show. He was often told that his style of humor and his look might be too niche for a mainstream audience. He quickly disproved this by becoming one of the most popular and influential members of the current cast. His work has earned him Emmy nominations and a spot on prestigious lists of influential people. He has successfully carved out a space for Asian American and queer voices in a historically traditional space.

Joel Kim Booster

Joel Kim Booster has built a thriving career as a comedian and actor by leaning into his personal experiences and unique perspective. He initially struggled to find a place in an industry that often overlooks Asian American men for leading roles. He took matters into his own hands by writing and starring in the hit film ‘Fire Island’. The movie was a critical success and showcased his ability to lead a major production. His career is currently on an upward trajectory as he continues to challenge industry norms.

Richard Gadd

Richard Gadd gained international acclaim after the massive success of his semi-autobiographical series ‘Baby Reindeer’. He spent years performing in the alternative comedy scene where his unconventional style and appearance were part of his artistic identity. The series became a global phenomenon and highlighted his incredible talent as both a writer and an actor. He has been praised for his bravery in tackling difficult subject matter with such raw honesty. His success proves that unique stories told by unconventional performers can resonate with a massive global audience.

Ben Platt

Ben Platt faced criticism regarding his appearance and age during his career but he consistently let his vocal talent and acting skill speak for itself. He rose to fame in the Broadway musical ‘Dear Evan Hansen’ for which he won a Tony Award. He later transitioned into film and television with roles in ‘The Politician’ and ‘Pitch Perfect’. Despite facing online backlash he has maintained a successful career across multiple mediums. His resilience and dedication to his craft have ensured that he remains a prominent figure in the entertainment world.

Billy Porter

Billy Porter spent decades working in the industry before becoming a fashion icon and an Emmy-winning actor. He was often told that he was too flamboyant or that his look was not masculine enough for mainstream success. He eventually found the perfect role in ‘Pose’ which allowed him to showcase his full range and charisma. He has since become a regular on red carpets and has used his fame to advocate for gender-fluid fashion and queer rights. His late-career surge is a powerful reminder that it is never too late to achieve your dreams.

Conrad Ricamora

Conrad Ricamora gained a large following for his role as Oliver Hampton on the drama series ‘How to Get Away with Murder’. He has often spoken about the challenges of being an Asian American actor in a business that frequently relies on stereotypes. His talent as both a singer and an actor has allowed him to move seamlessly between television and the Broadway stage. He has appeared in prestigious productions such as ‘The King and I’ and ‘Here Lies Love’. His continued success demonstrates that there is a strong appetite for diverse and talented leading men.

Robin de Jesús

Robin de Jesús is a three-time Tony Award nominee who has built a successful career by staying true to his roots and his identity. He often plays characters that are vibrant and full of heart which has made him a favorite among theater and film audiences. His performance in the film ‘tick tick BOOM’ showcased his range and earned him significant critical praise. He has been a consistent advocate for Afro-Latino representation in the arts. His career is a shining example of how passion and talent can overcome industry biases.

Maulik Pancholy

Maulik Pancholy is a versatile actor who has appeared in some of the most popular television comedies of the last two decades. He is well known for his roles in ’30 Rock’ and ‘Weeds’ as well as his voice work in ‘Phineas and Ferb’. He has often discussed the importance of being visible as an out queer actor of South Asian descent. In addition to his acting career he is also a successful author and activist for LGBTQ youth. His enduring presence in the industry shows the value of consistency and talent.

Wilson Cruz

Wilson Cruz made history as one of the first openly gay actors to play a gay character on television in ‘My So-Called Life’. He faced significant pressure early in his career and was told that his honesty about his identity would limit his opportunities. He persevered and has since appeared in numerous hit series including ‘Star Trek Discovery’ and ’13 Reasons Why’. He has become a respected leader in the community and a tireless advocate for representation. His long-standing career is a testament to his courage and his professional excellence.

BD Wong

BD Wong has enjoyed a prolific career in film and television while consistently breaking barriers for Asian American performers. He won a Tony Award for his Broadway debut in ‘M. Butterfly’ and has since appeared in major franchises like ‘Jurassic Park’. He often plays intelligent and complex characters that defy common tropes associated with his background. He has been out for much of his career and has successfully balanced a wide variety of roles. His success illustrates that a commitment to excellence can sustain a career for decades.

Mario Cantone

Mario Cantone is known for his high-energy personality and his unique comedic style that has made him a standout in every project he joins. He became a fan favorite on ‘Sex and the City’ where he played the outspoken Anthony Marentino. Before his television success he was a regular on the comedy circuit and performed on Broadway. He has never shied away from his identity and has always used his humor to connect with audiences. His career proves that a distinct and authentic voice is always in demand.

Anthony Rapp

Anthony Rapp rose to fame as a member of the original cast of the groundbreaking musical ‘Rent’. He has been a visible and vocal member of the LGBTQ community for his entire professional life. His career has spanned decades and includes significant roles in films like ‘Dazed and Confused’ and the series ‘Star Trek Discovery’. He has often played characters that are intellectual and sensitive which has allowed him to showcase his range. His enduring career shows the impact of being a pioneer in the industry.

Randy Rainbow

Randy Rainbow became a household name through his viral musical parodies that blend political satire with Broadway flair. He spent years working in theater and media before finding his unique niche on the internet. His success led to Emmy nominations and sold-out national tours where he showcases his comedic and vocal talents. He has proven that a performer can create their own path to stardom by using modern platforms to reach an audience. His career is a modern success story that highlights the importance of creativity and self-promotion.

Brian Jordan Alvarez

Brian Jordan Alvarez gained a following by creating and starring in his own digital content before making the jump to mainstream television and film. He is known for his incredible ability to play a wide range of eccentric characters in his viral sketches. He achieved widespread recognition for his role in the film ‘M3GAN’ and his own series ‘English Teacher’. He has used his unique look and comedic brilliance to establish himself as a rising star in the industry. His path to success shows that originality is a highly valued trait in today’s entertainment landscape.

Jordan Firstman

Jordan Firstman is a writer and actor who became an internet sensation during the pandemic with his hilarious character impressions. He has since parlayed his social media success into a legitimate acting career with roles in ‘Ms. Marvel’ and ‘Rotting in the Sun’. He is known for his unconventional style and his willingness to push boundaries with his humor. He often collaborates with other queer creators to tell stories that are fresh and unexpected. His rise to fame is a prime example of how digital fame can translate into a successful Hollywood career.

Murray Bartlett

Murray Bartlett spent many years as a hard-working actor before his career reached new heights with ‘The White Lotus’. He was often seen as a reliable character actor but not necessarily a leading man in major productions. His Emmy-winning performance as Armond turned him into one of the most talked-about actors of the year. He followed this success with a critically acclaimed role in ‘The Last of Us’. His late-career surge is a testament to his undeniable talent and the power of finding the perfect role.

Colman Domingo

Colman Domingo is a versatile performer who worked extensively in theater before becoming a major film star. He has often spoken about the challenges of being a Black queer man in an industry that can be slow to embrace change. His performances in ‘Euphoria’ and ‘Rustin’ have earned him widespread critical acclaim and prestigious award nominations. He is also an accomplished playwright and director who is dedicated to telling complex stories. His career is currently at an all-time high as he continues to take on powerful leading roles.

Andrew Scott

Andrew Scott was a respected stage and screen actor for years before his role as the priest in ‘Fleabag’ made him a global sensation. He was often described as having an unusual and captivating presence that set him apart from other performers. He has played iconic characters such as Moriarty in ‘Sherlock’ and the title role in ‘Ripley’. He is known for his incredible intensity and his ability to bring humanity to every character he portrays. His success highlights the industry’s growing appreciation for actors with a unique and powerful screen presence.

Ben Whishaw

Ben Whishaw is known for his slight frame and soulful performances which often contrast with the typical action heroes of cinema. He has built an impressive resume with roles in ‘Paddington’ and as Q in the ‘James Bond’ franchise. He has won multiple awards for his work in television dramas such as ‘A Very English Scandal’ and ‘This Is Going to Hurt’. He has always prioritized interesting and challenging roles over mainstream popularity. His career proves that a quiet and thoughtful approach to acting can lead to immense success.

Dan Levy

Dan Levy faced many rejections early in his career and was often told that his look was more suited for hosting than acting. He decided to create his own opportunity by co-creating and starring in the hit series ‘Schitt’s Creek’. The show became a historic success and swept the Emmy Awards in its final season. He has since become a major producer and actor with a focus on telling inclusive and heartwarming stories. His journey is a classic example of how self-belief and hard work can change the course of a career.

Sean Hayes

Sean Hayes achieved massive fame as Jack McFarland on ‘Will and Grace’ after years of studying and performing improv comedy. He did not fit the traditional image of a sitcom lead but his comedic genius made him an indispensable part of the show’s success. He has won an Emmy Award and a Tony Award for his work on television and the stage. He has also been a successful producer behind several hit television series. His career demonstrates that a unique comedic voice can resonate with audiences for decades.

John Benjamin Hickey

John Benjamin Hickey is a veteran of the stage and screen who has consistently worked in a wide variety of roles. He is often praised for his intelligence and his ability to ground even the most complex characters. He won a Tony Award for his performance in ‘The Normal Heart’ and has appeared in hit series like ‘The Good Wife’ and ‘In Treatment’. He has been a steady and reliable presence in the industry while remaining out and proud. His career reflects the value of being a dedicated and versatile professional.

George Takei

George Takei became an icon as Mr. Sulu on ‘Star Trek’ during a time when Asian American actors had very few opportunities. He faced significant challenges in his personal and professional life but remained committed to his craft. After coming out in his sixties he became a massive social media star and a leading voice for human rights. He has appeared on Broadway and in numerous films and television shows throughout his long career. His legacy is one of resilience and the power of using one’s voice for positive change.

Alec Mapa

Alec Mapa is a comedic actor who has built a successful career by embracing his personality and his heritage. He is often called the king of the guest star due to his many memorable appearances on shows like ‘Ugly Betty’ and ‘Desperate Housewives’. He has also written and performed successful solo shows that explore his experiences as a gay Asian man. He has been a vocal advocate for adoption and LGBTQ families for many years. His success shows that being a character actor can lead to a rich and meaningful career.

Rex Lee

Rex Lee gained fame for his role as Lloyd Lee on the hit series ‘Entourage’ where he often played the comedic foil. He has spoken about how his appearance and identity initially made it difficult to secure auditions for mainstream roles. His performance was so popular that he became a series regular and a fan favorite. He has since appeared in several other television series including ‘Suburgatory’ and ‘Young and Hungry’. His career is a reminder that talent and a great attitude can lead to lasting success in a tough industry.

Share your favorite success stories from these incredible actors in the comments.