Gay Actors Who Should Receive Way More Praise

The entertainment industry has seen a significant shift in representation with more openly gay actors taking on diverse and complex roles. These talented performers have moved beyond stereotypes to deliver powerful performances across film, television, and theater. Many of them have garnered critical acclaim yet still deserve broader recognition for their contributions to the craft of acting. Highlighting their work showcases the depth of talent available when casting directors embrace authentic representation. The following list celebrates gay actors who consistently deliver memorable performances and merit greater accolades.

Andrew Scott

This Irish actor gained worldwide fame for his riveting portrayal of Moriarty in the series ‘Sherlock’. He displayed incredible range and vulnerability as the Priest in the celebrated comedy-drama ‘Fleabag’. His work extends to film with acclaimed roles in movies such as ‘All of Us Strangers’ where he delivered a deeply emotional performance. Scott acts with a unique intensity that allows him to command every scene he inhabits. He continues to be a force in both independent cinema and major television productions.

Ben Whishaw

Ben Whishaw possesses a distinctive voice and presence that has made him a favorite among critics and audiences alike. He provides the gentle and iconic voice for the title character in the ‘Paddington’ film franchise. His performance in the miniseries ‘A Very English Scandal’ earned him a Golden Globe for his portrayal of Norman Scott. Whishaw often chooses complex characters in projects like ‘Cloud Atlas’ and ‘Women Talking’ that highlight his versatility. His ability to convey deep emotion with subtle expressions makes him a standout performer in every genre.

Colman Domingo

Colman Domingo is a dynamic performer who has transitioned seamlessly between stage and screen. He garnered significant attention for his role as Ali in the hit HBO series ‘Euphoria’. His lead performance in the film ‘Rustin’ showcased his ability to carry a major biopic with charisma and gravity. Domingo also writes and directs, bringing a multifaceted perspective to his work in the industry. His commanding screen presence ensures he leaves a lasting impression in both supporting and leading roles.

Jonathan Bailey

Jonathan Bailey achieved international stardom with his role as Anthony Bridgerton in the period drama ‘Bridgerton’. He demonstrated his dramatic chops and willingness to take risks in the limited series ‘Fellow Travelers’. Bailey has a strong background in musical theater and won an Olivier Award for his work on the London stage. His performances are characterized by intense chemistry with co-stars and a deep emotional commitment to his characters. He represents a new generation of leading men who are openly gay and thriving in mainstream media.

Matt Bomer

Matt Bomer captivated audiences for years as the charming con artist Neal Caffrey in the series ‘White Collar’. He delivered a heartbreaking performance in the television movie ‘The Normal Heart’ which earned him a Golden Globe Award. Bomer has successfully moved between television and film with roles in ‘Magic Mike’ and ‘The Boys in the Band’. His classic Hollywood looks are matched by a sincere depth that he brings to dramatic roles. He consistently advocates for diverse storytelling while maintaining a prolific career.

Lee Pace

Lee Pace first gained a cult following for his role as the pie-maker Ned in the whimsical series ‘Pushing Daisies’. He commands attention with his imposing physical presence and intensity in the sci-fi epic ‘Foundation’. His versatility is evident in his portrayal of Thranduil in ‘The Hobbit’ trilogy and Ronan the Accuser in ‘Guardians of the Galaxy’. Pace brings a unique blend of warmth and authority to his characters that sets him apart. He remains a favorite among genre fans for his ability to ground fantastical roles in reality.

Russell Tovey

Russell Tovey has built a steady career with memorable roles in British and American television. He played the werewolf George Sands in the supernatural drama ‘Being Human’ and gained further acclaim in the series ‘Looking’. Tovey is also an accomplished stage actor who received praise for his performance in ‘Angels in America’. His acting style often balances vulnerability with a rugged charm that appeals to a wide audience. He continues to challenge himself with diverse projects in independent film and television.

Luke Evans

Luke Evans has established himself as a bona fide action star and dramatic actor. He is well known for playing Gaston in the live-action adaptation of ‘Beauty and the Beast’. His filmography includes major blockbusters such as ‘Fast & Furious 6’ and ‘The Hobbit’ series. Evans brings a powerful physicality and a rich singing voice to his performances. He has proven that openly gay actors can successfully lead high-octane action films and romantic narratives.

Murray Bartlett

Murray Bartlett experienced a major career resurgence with his Emmy-winning role as Armond in ‘The White Lotus’. He followed this success with a touching performance in the post-apocalyptic drama ‘The Last of Us’. Bartlett acted as a central figure in the series ‘Looking’ which explored the lives of gay men in San Francisco. His ability to mix comedy with deep pathos allows him to create complex and sympathetic characters. He has become a sought-after talent for prestigious limited series.

Jonathan Groff

Jonathan Groff originated the role of King George III in the Broadway phenomenon ‘Hamilton’ and voiced Kristoff in ‘Frozen’. He demonstrated his dramatic capabilities as the lead in the psychological crime thriller ‘Mindhunter’. Groff starred in the HBO series ‘Looking’ and its subsequent wrap-up movie. He seamlessly navigates between voice acting, musical theater, and serious television drama. His clean-cut image contrasts with the dark and complex themes he often explores in his screen work.

Jeremy Pope

Jeremy Pope burst onto the scene with breakout performances on Broadway and in Ryan Murphy’s series ‘Hollywood’. He received critical acclaim for his lead role in the military drama ‘The Inspection’. Pope is one of the few actors to receive two Tony Award nominations in the same year for separate roles. His screen presence is magnetic and marked by a raw emotional honesty. He represents a rising talent who chooses projects that challenge social norms and expectations.

Zachary Quinto

Zachary Quinto became a household name playing the villain Sylar in the superhero drama ‘Heroes’. He took on the iconic mantle of Spock in the rebooted ‘Star Trek’ film franchise. Quinto delivered chilling performances in multiple seasons of the anthology series ‘American Horror Story’. He produces and acts in projects that highlight independent voices and queer stories. His intense gaze and precise delivery make him ideal for intelligent and often menacing characters.

Wilson Cruz

Wilson Cruz made history as Rickie Vasquez in the teen drama ‘My So-Called Life’ as one of the first openly gay characters played by a gay actor. He plays Dr. Hugh Culber in ‘Star Trek: Discovery’ and continues to break barriers in science fiction. Cruz is a fierce advocate for LGBTQ+ representation and brings that passion to his roles. His career spans decades of consistent work in television and theater. He infuses his characters with a sense of dignity and resilience.

Guillermo Díaz

Guillermo Díaz is best known for his intense role as Huck in the political thriller ‘Scandal’. He played a key role in the dark comedy series ‘Weeds’ as a drug trafficker. Díaz often portrays tough characters with hidden layers of sensitivity and loyalty. His work challenges the typical casting of gay actors by frequently inhabiting aggressive or dangerous roles. He remains a compelling character actor who adds depth to every ensemble he joins.

Haaz Sleiman

Haaz Sleiman garnered praise for his role in the independent film ‘The Visitor’. He appeared as a nurse in the dark comedy series ‘Nurse Jackie’ and played a superhero’s husband in ‘Eternals’. Sleiman brings visibility to gay Arab-American men through his diverse choice of roles. His performances are often marked by a quiet strength and emotional intelligence. He continues to push for authentic representation of intersectional identities in Hollywood.

BD Wong

B.D. Wong has had a prolific career appearing in hits like ‘Jurassic Park’ and its modern sequels. He played Dr. George Huang for many years on the long-running series ‘Law & Order: Special Victims Unit’. Wong won a Tony Award for his debut performance in ‘M. Butterfly’ on Broadway. He voiced the character Shang in the animated classic ‘Mulan’. His career is defined by intelligent characters and a steady presence in some of the biggest franchises in history.

Cheyenne Jackson

Cheyenne Jackson is a versatile performer with a strong background in Broadway musicals and television. He has appeared in several seasons of ‘American Horror Story’ playing a variety of eccentric characters. Jackson starred in the sitcom ‘Call Me Kat’ and the quirky comedy ’30 Rock’. He possesses a classic leading man quality combined with excellent comedic timing. His work spans genres from horror to musical comedy with equal proficiency.

Robin de Jesús

Robin de Jesús is a three-time Tony Award nominee known for his energetic stage presence. He delivered a memorable performance in the film adaptation of ‘Tick, Tick… Boom!’ alongside Andrew Garfield. He reprised his stage role for the Netflix film version of ‘The Boys in the Band’. De Jesús often plays characters who are vibrant, witty, and deeply loyal to their friends. He brings an undeniable spark and authenticity to Latinx queer roles.

Michael Urie

Michael Urie became a fan favorite as the stylish assistant Marc St. James in ‘Ugly Betty’. He creates distinct comedic characters on stage and in shows like ‘Shrinking’. Urie directed and produced the film adaptation of the play ‘He’s Way More Famous Than You’. His rapid-fire delivery and physical comedy skills are reminiscent of classic sitcom stars. He remains a constant and beloved presence in the New York theater scene.

Dan Levy

Dan Levy created, wrote, and starred in the cultural phenomenon ‘Schitt’s Creek’. His portrayal of David Rose introduced a pansexual character to mainstream audiences in a normalized way. Levy won multiple Emmy Awards for his work on the series as an actor and creator. He brings a sharp wit and emotional depth to his projects. His success has opened doors for more inclusive storytelling in comedy.

Tituss Burgess

Tituss Burgess found mainstream fame as the aspiring actor Titus Andromedon in ‘Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt’. His operatic voice and comedic timing earned him multiple Emmy nominations. Burgess originated the role of Sebastian the Crab in the Broadway adaptation of ‘The Little Mermaid’. He steals scenes with his larger-than-life persona and expressive facial reactions. He continues to be a unique force in musical comedy and television.

Denis O’Hare

Denis O’Hare is a celebrated character actor known for his chameleon-like ability to disappear into roles. He has played everything from a vampire king in ‘True Blood’ to a mute butler in ‘American Horror Story’. O’Hare won a Tony Award for his performance in the play ‘Take Me Out’. His distinct look and intensity make him a favorite for directors seeking unconventional performances. He consistently elevates the material with his committed and often eerie portrayals.

John Benjamin Hickey

John Benjamin Hickey is a respected veteran of stage and screen with a Tony Award to his name. He played the brother in the dramedy ‘The Big C’ and appeared in ‘The Good Wife’. Hickey starred in the Broadway inheritance drama ‘The Inheritance’ which transferred to a major production. His acting is grounded and naturalistic which fits well in complex family dramas. He brings a sense of reliability and warmth to his supporting roles.

Stephen Fry

Stephen Fry is a British national treasure known for his intellect and wit. He played the title role in the biopic ‘Wilde’ which chronicled the life of Oscar Wilde. Fry appeared in the dystopian thriller ‘V for Vendetta’ and the ‘Hobbit’ films. His career encompasses writing, presenting, and acting across various mediums. He brings a sophisticated and often dry humor to his dramatic and comedic roles.

Nathan Lane

Nathan Lane is a comedy legend known for his exuberant performances in film and theater. He starred alongside Robin Williams in the classic comedy ‘The Birdcage’. Lane voiced Timon in the animated masterpiece ‘The Lion King’. He has won multiple Tony Awards and continues to tackle heavy dramatic roles on stage. His ability to switch between high-energy comedy and tragic drama is unmatched.

Billy Porter

Billy Porter redefined red carpet fashion while delivering a powerhouse performance in the series ‘Pose’. He won an Emmy Award for his portrayal of Pray Tell in the groundbreaking show about ballroom culture. Porter has a long history on Broadway and won a Tony for ‘Kinky Boots’. His work celebrates resilience and flamboyance with deep emotional undercurrents. He stands as a major icon for gender-fluid expression and artistic excellence.

Rupert Everett

Rupert Everett became an international star with his role in ‘My Best Friend’s Wedding’. He voiced Prince Charming in the ‘Shrek’ sequels and starred in adaptations of Oscar Wilde plays. Everett wrote and directed the film ‘The Happy Prince’ about Wilde’s final years. His career has seen him play aristocratic and often acerbic characters. He brings a sharp intelligence and wit to every role he undertakes.

Charlie Carver

Charlie Carver started his career playing a twin in the hit series ‘Desperate Housewives’. He acted alongside his brother in ‘Teen Wolf’ and appeared in the film ‘The Batman’. Carver delivered a layered performance in the 2020 film ‘The Boys in the Band’. He writes and advocates for LGBTQ+ rights while continuing to act in high-profile projects. His transition from teen heartthrob to serious actor has been marked by steady growth.

Noah Galvin

Noah Galvin showcased his comedic timing in the sitcom ‘The Real O’Neals’. He played the title role in the Broadway production of ‘Dear Evan Hansen’. Galvin portrayed a surgical resident in the medical drama ‘The Good Doctor’. He brings a quirky and relatable energy to young adult roles. His performances are often characterized by a quick wit and vulnerability.

Conrad Ricamora

Conrad Ricamora gained widespread recognition as Oliver Hampton in ‘How to Get Away with Murder’. He starred in the romantic comedy film ‘Fire Island’ inspired by Jane Austen. Ricamora is an accomplished singer who has appeared in major Broadway revivals like ‘The King and I’. His work often explores the nuances of modern relationships and identity. He balances dramatic intensity with a charming screen presence.

Brandon Flynn

Brandon Flynn became a breakout star with his role as Justin Foley in ’13 Reasons Why’. He appeared in the revival of the horror franchise ‘Hellraiser’. Flynn brings a brooding intensity to troubled youth characters. His performances often deal with difficult themes like addiction and trauma. He has quickly established himself as a talented young actor to watch.

Scott Evans

Scott Evans had a recurring role on the soap opera ‘One Life to Live’ as a police officer. He played one of the Kens in the massive blockbuster ‘Barbie’. Evans appeared in the comedy ‘Almost Love’ and the series ‘Grace and Frankie’. He often brings a likable and grounded energy to his supporting roles. His comedic timing and charm have made him a reliable ensemble player.

Tuc Watkins

Tuc Watkins is best known for his roles in soap operas and the primetime series ‘Desperate Housewives’. He played a prominent role in the Netflix comedy series ‘Uncoupled’. Watkins starred in the film version of ‘The Boys in the Band’ as a straight-acting gay man. His career has demonstrated longevity in a difficult industry. He excels at playing characters who use sarcasm as a defense mechanism.

Maulik Pancholy

Maulik Pancholy played the devoted assistant Jonathan on the hit comedy ’30 Rock’. He voiced the character Baljeet in the animated series ‘Phineas and Ferb’. Pancholy had a recurring role on the show ‘Weeds’ alongside other talented actors. His comedic delivery is precise and often steals scenes from the main cast. He is also an author and advocate for the AAPI and LGBTQ+ communities.

Peter Paige

Peter Paige is known to many as Emmett Honeycutt from the groundbreaking series ‘Queer as Folk’. He has since transitioned into directing and producing shows like ‘The Fosters’. Paige brings an exuberant and joyful energy to his acting roles. His work on ‘Queer as Folk’ remains a touchstone for gay representation on television. He continues to influence the industry from behind the camera as well.

Van Hansis

Van Hansis made history on the soap opera ‘As the World Turns’ as half of a popular gay supercouple. He starred in the critically acclaimed web series ‘EastSiders’. Hansis has received multiple Daytime Emmy nominations for his work. He brings a naturalistic and subtle approach to relationship dramas. His work in independent media has garnered a loyal following.

Brian J. Smith

Brian J. Smith gained a global fanbase for his role as police officer Will Gorski in ‘Sense8’. He showcased his stage talents in the Broadway revival of ‘The Glass Menagerie’. Smith appeared in the series ‘Treadstone’ based on the Bourne franchise. He combines physical toughness with deep emotional sensitivity in his roles. His performances are often physically demanding and emotionally resonant.

Matt Doyle

Matt Doyle is a Broadway favorite who won a Tony Award for his performance in ‘Company’. He appeared in the original ‘Gossip Girl’ series as a recurring character. Doyle has released solo music albums and performs concerts regularly. His stage charisma translates well to his screen appearances. He represents the crossover talent between New York theater and television.

Jelani Alladin

Jelani Alladin originated the role of Kristoff in the Broadway musical adaptation of ‘Frozen’. He played a lead role in the limited series ‘Fellow Travelers’ set in the 1950s. Alladin appeared in the spin-off series ‘The Walking Dead: World Beyond’. He brings a commanding presence and warmth to his characters. His range allows him to move from family-friendly musicals to serious historical dramas.

Zane Phillips

Zane Phillips gained attention for his role as the “island himbo” in the movie ‘Fire Island’. He played a villainous character in the fantasy series ‘Legacies’. Phillips starred in the workplace comedy ‘Glamorous’ on Netflix. He combines classic good looks with a willingness to play subversively funny roles. His comedic instincts have quickly made him a rising star in the industry.

Rory O’Malley

Rory O’Malley earned a Tony nomination for his hilarious performance in ‘The Book of Mormon’. He voiced a role in the animated series ‘Central Park’. O’Malley played King George III in ‘Hamilton’ during its Broadway run. He excels at playing neurotic or high-energy comedic characters. His background in improv and theater serves him well in character roles.

Harvey Guillén

Harvey Guillén achieved fame as the familiar Guillermo de la Cruz in ‘What We Do in the Shadows’. He voices Nightwing in the animated ‘Harley Quinn’ series. Guillén has appeared in ‘The Magicians’ and ‘Reacher’. He brings a grounded humanity to fantastical settings that audiences love. His character arc from servant to vampire hunter has been a highlight of modern television comedy.

Joel Kim Booster

Joel Kim Booster wrote and starred in the modern romantic comedy ‘Fire Island’. He is a stand-up comedian who acts in series like ‘Loot’ on Apple TV+. Booster often explores themes of identity and class through a humorous lens. His sharp writing is matched by his charismatic on-screen persona. He is a leading voice in the new wave of queer comedy.

Bowen Yang

Bowen Yang made history as a cast member on ‘Saturday Night Live’ with his viral sketches. He played a prominent role in the film ‘Fire Island’ alongside his close friends. Yang appeared in the musical comedy ‘Dicks: The Musical’. His comedic style is distinct, pop-culture obsessed, and highly energetic. He has quickly become one of the most recognizable faces in sketch comedy.

Gideon Glick

Gideon Glick originated a role in the controversial musical ‘Spring Awakening’ as a teenager. He played a magician in ‘The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel’ series. Glick received a Tony nomination for his performance in ‘To Kill a Mockingbird’. He possesses a unique character look and voice that directors utilize for specific roles. His work bridges the gap between alternative theater and mainstream television.

Taylor Trensch

Taylor Trensch played the lead role in the hit Broadway musical ‘Dear Evan Hansen’. He voiced characters in the animated series ‘Archibald’s Next Big Thing’. Trensch brings a nervous and quirky energy to his performances that is endearing. He is a staple of the New York theater community with a growing screen resume. His ability to convey anxiety and vulnerability is a hallmark of his acting.

Mario Cantone

Mario Cantone is best known for his fast-talking role as Anthony Marentino in ‘Sex and the City’. He is an accomplished stand-up comedian with a high-energy style. Cantone has appeared on Broadway in shows like ‘Assassins’. His persona is often loud and abrasive but always fundamentally lovable. He remains a pop culture fixture for his quick wit and distinct voice.

Alec Mapa

Alec Mapa played the gossip reporter Suzuki St. Pierre in ‘Ugly Betty’. He had a recurring role as a caterer in ‘Desperate Housewives’. Mapa calls himself “America’s Gaysian Sweetheart” in his stand-up comedy. He brings a flamboyant and fearless humor to his character roles. His visibility has paved the way for other gay Asian actors in the industry.

Doug Spearman

Doug Spearman is known for his role as Chance Counter in the series ‘Noah’s Arc’. He has directed and written films that focus on the black gay experience. Spearman brings a sophisticated and mature presence to his acting work. His career has been dedicated to telling stories that are often overlooked by the mainstream. He continues to be a vital part of independent queer cinema.

Please share your favorite performances by these actors in the comments.