New Thriller ‘Is God Is’ Lands Rotten Tomatoes Score — Here’s What Critics Are Saying

Is God Is, the new thriller written, directed, and produced by Aleshea Harris, is getting strong attention from critics after its release in theaters on May 15. The film is based on Harris’ 2018 stage play and marks her first time directing a feature film.

The movie stars Kara Young, Mallori Johnson, Janelle Monáe, Vivica A. Fox, and Sterling K. Brown. It tells the story of twin sisters Racine and Anaia, who go on a violent and emotional journey to confront their past and take revenge on their father, who caused their childhood injuries.

The film currently holds a strong Rotten Tomatoes score, with a 98% critic rating from 83 reviews and an 89% audience score based on more than 250 verified ratings. The early reaction shows that the movie is being widely praised, especially for its style, direction, and emotional depth.

Critics are saying the film stands out because of its bold storytelling and strong visual identity. According to The Hollywood Reporter, reviewer Jourdain Searles described it as more than just a family revenge story. She said, “Is God Is is not just the story of one Black family; it stands as an almost cosmic example of the dysfunction inherent in so many Black American families.”

Other critics have also focused on how the film handles trauma and revenge in a unique way. Alise Chaffins from Loud and Clear Reviews said, “This film is a unique, high-energy revenge tale with a distinct view of trauma that setting it apart from other films with similar themes.” Her review highlights how the film uses emotional pain as a driving force for the story rather than just action.

Some reviewers also praised Aleshea Harris for her direction, especially since this is her first feature film. NPR’s Aisha Harris said, “Harris’ vision as a first-time filmmaker is crystal clear, and Is God Is already feels timeless, like a parable that could have been written decades ago, and will be handily passed down as pointed social critique for decades to come.”

Not all reactions were completely positive. A few critics felt the film’s energy and style sometimes overshadowed its emotional weight. For example, Tom Meek from Cambridge Day said, “Is God Is comes out swinging and fierce, but there’s a hollowness to it that resonates more than the searing anger it postures.” Even so, the film is still being recognized as a strong and memorable debut.

Many reviews also mention the film’s mix of Southern Gothic style, surreal imagery, and intense emotional themes. Critics describe it as bold, strange, and visually striking. Some have compared its tone to a mix of stage drama and cinematic revenge story, which fits since it comes from a stage play originally written by Harris.

According to multiple sources including Rotten Tomatoes and film critics featured in outlets like The Hollywood Reporter and NPR, the film is being seen as a major creative success for a first-time director. Even critics who had mixed feelings agree that Harris has a strong voice and a clear artistic vision.

Overall, Is God Is is being talked about as a powerful and unusual thriller that mixes revenge, family drama, and deeper emotional themes. With its high score and strong reviews, it is quickly becoming one of the standout films of the year.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!