Jared Padalecki Pitches a ‘Supernatural’ Revival Where Sam and Dean Wake Up Back on Earth
Few fan campaigns have lasted as long as the push for a ‘Supernatural‘ revival. The show wrapped up its run on The CW, yet the demand for more Winchester stories has never really gone away. Now one of the brothers is putting a fresh idea on the table.
‘Supernatural’ launched in 2005 and ran for 15 seasons and 327 episodes before ending in 2020. The finale was emotional and divisive: Dean was killed on what seemed like a routine vampire hunt. Sam went on to live a normal life before dying of old age, and the brothers were reunited on a bridge in the afterlife.
Padalecki now has a concrete format in mind. Speaking with Collider, the actor said he doesn’t think anyone involved wants to repeat the 15-season grind. Instead, he’d like a short run modeled on the ‘Gilmore Girls’ revival, with 4 episodes of 90 minutes each.
He added that the production could shoot it in 2 or 3 months. That timeline matters, since a compact schedule is far easier to coordinate than a full network season. It also suits actors who have moved on to other projects.
The format has a built-in irony. The ‘Gilmore Girls’ revival consisted of 4 90-minute episodes, and Padalecki himself returned as Dean in it. He knows exactly how that model works from the inside.
Padalecki also offered a loose story idea. His pitch has Sam and Dean ending up back on Earth with no explanation for how it happened, then having to figure out why they’re there. It’s a smart way around the finale, since it avoids undoing the ending and lets the mystery drive the story.
He was careful to frame it as spitballing. Nothing is in the works at this time. That caveat is important, because no network or studio has announced a project.
The idea isn’t new for him. On a podcast, Padalecki said he was dying to do a reboot, comparing it to ‘Gilmore Girls’ and describing 4 episodes of 90 minutes each. The 2026 comments suggest the plan has stayed consistent for years.
Other cast members have weighed in as well. In an interview with TV Insider, Padalecki said a limited series would be great, adding that the cast is a lot older than they were 20 years ago. Jensen Ackles has also pitched a short-run limited series or TV movie instead of a full multi-season order.

The fanbase has plenty of reasons to feel hopeful. The prequel ‘The Winchesters’ lasted a single season, which left fans wanting more. Padalecki wasn’t involved in that series.
The stars have since reunited on screen. Padalecki, Ackles and Misha Collins appeared together in the final season of ‘The Boys’, which was created by ‘Supernatural’ creator Eric Kripke. Kripke has said he’d be all in on another season. With the creator open and the leads willing, the main obstacle is a green light.
For any of this to happen, the pieces have to line up. A studio would need to commit to a short, event-style order, and the schedules of 2 busy actors would have to align. The story would also have to respect an ending many fans consider sacred.
Padalecki’s idea checks several of those boxes. It’s small in scope, has a clear hook, and gives the Winchesters a reason to return without undoing what the finale accomplished. For now, though, it remains a pitch from an actor who clearly misses the role.
Would you like to see a four-episode Supernatural revival with Sam and Dean back on Earth?
Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!
