‘I Play Rocky’ Just Went the Distance With Moviegoers, and Few Biopics Have Done It Like This as CinemaScore is Revealed

Amazon MGM Studios
Share:

Few movies carry as much affection as ‘Rocky‘, and few behind-the-scenes stories are as tempting to dramatize as the one about how it got made. The audience reaction to ‘I Play Rocky’ is now one of the more notable stories at the movies this month. It’s a film that came with a built-in fan base and a lot to prove.

Directed by Peter Farrelly, it follows a young, unknown Sylvester Stallone as he fights to bring his vision of ‘Rocky’ to the big screen and to star in it himself. Anthony Ippolito, who plays Stallone, walked the red carpet at the Toronto International Film Festival in September. Now the general public has weighed in.

‘I Play Rocky’ earned an A+ CinemaScore from audiences, a grade that almost never goes to a film in this category. The score is being described as a record for the genre, which makes it a major win for Amazon MGM.

The comparison list is striking. ‘Oppenheimer’, ‘The Boys in the Boat’, ‘Air’, ‘King Richard’, ‘Moneyball’, ‘Bohemian Rhapsody’, ‘Bob Marley: One Love’, ‘Whitney Houston: I Wanna Dance With Somebody’ and ‘Respect’ all landed at an A. Even that group falls one step short of what ‘I Play Rocky’ managed.

Further down the ladder, ‘Killers of the Flower Moon’, ‘Michael’, ‘The Iron Claw’, ‘Elvis’ and ‘Rocketman’ each earned an A-. ‘House of Gucci’ got a B+, ‘Prime Time’ and ‘Christy’ got a B, and ‘The Social Reckoning’, ‘Napoleon’, ‘The Smashing Machine’ and ‘The Apprentice’ each landed at a B-.

RELATED:

‘I Play Rocky’ Review: The Bet On Yourself That Still Packs A Punch

The critical response has been warm but far from unanimous. Critics have hailed Ippolito’s performance, and the film has received an 88% Rotten Tomatoes score. Individual reviews tell a more varied story.

Variety called it a cleverly crafted crowd-pleaser about the making of ‘Rocky’. The Boston Globe, by contrast, called it well-acted yet empty. TheWrap went further, labeling it a hollow crowdpleaser. That gap helps explain why audience grades matter so much here, since regular moviegoers seem to be responding to exactly what some critics found lacking.

The path to the screen was an underdog tale of its own. The film was developed without the studio that owns the franchise, as Peter Gamble wrote the script on spec and it landed on the Black List before reaching producers Christian Baha and Toby Emmerich and director Farrelly.

Amazon MGM signed on to distribute the film in 2025, before cameras rolled, which cleared it to borrow from the franchise. It is also the first film from the ‘Rocky’ universe to come together entirely under Amazon’s ownership. The finished movie leans into that heritage by using the original theme and recreating exact shots from the first film.

The release was planned around a milestone. ‘I Play Rocky’ opens in US theaters on Nov. 20, following a limited release, and coincides with the 50th anniversary of the original ‘Rocky’, which debuted on Nov. 21, 1976. That original film earned 10 Academy Award nominations, won 3 including Best Picture, and grossed about $117 million at the domestic box office.

The limited rollout already showed signs of interest. The film collected $345K from just 7 theaters in its limited opening weekend, a per-theater average of $49K. A wider release now gives that early enthusiasm a much bigger test.

An A+ is the kind of grade that tends to fuel word of mouth, and word of mouth is exactly what a wide expansion needs. For a film pitched as a crowd-pleaser, this is the most encouraging signal possible. Stallone himself has praised the film in recent media interviews.

It also adds to the film’s reputation as a feel-good option for the season. Whether that translates into a long theatrical run is still an open question, but the audience verdict gives ‘I Play Rocky’ a real shot at going the distance.

What interests you most about I Play Rocky?

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!

Don't miss:

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted