‘I Play Rocky’ Review: The Bet On Yourself That Still Packs A Punch
Fifty years after ‘Rocky‘ stormed theaters, Peter Farrelly has turned the story behind the film into a movie of its own. ‘I Play Rocky’ arrives from Amazon MGM Studios, opening in limited release on November 6 before going wide on November 20. The title is also the line that drives the whole picture, the stubborn sentence a young Sylvester Stallone refused to take back.
Written by Peter Gamble, the film begins in a grimy New York where Stallone is bouncing between failed auditions and odd jobs, still going by Mike. He meets Sasha, played by AnnaSophia Robb, who nudges him to write the part nobody will hand him. A few years later, a screenplay about an underestimated club fighter lands with producers Irwin Winkler and Robert Chartoff, and the only sticking point is that its author insists on starring in it.
I walked in expecting a hollow nostalgia exercise, and I was wrong. The film treats a famous Hollywood negotiation like a boxing match, with every rejected paycheck landing like a jab. It really shouldn’t be this gripping when everyone in the audience knows how the story ends, and yet it is.
The reason is Anthony Ippolito, who gives the best performance in the film and one of the more convincing biopic turns I’ve seen in a while. The voice and the look are startlingly close, but what impressed me more is the stubborn warmth underneath, the sense of a man who is hurt, funny and unbending all at once. Whenever the movie leans on him, it works.
The supporting cast is generous too. Matt Dillon makes Stallone’s father a genuine source of pain, Toby Kebbell and P.J. Byrne bring comic friction as the producers, and Stephan James turns up as Carl Weathers with real swagger. Jay Duplass plays director John Avildsen with a prickly energy that keeps the on set scenes lively. Not every smaller part lands, but the leads carry plenty of weight.
The film does stumble. Once production moves to Philadelphia on a shoestring budget, the energy that powered the negotiation flattens out a little, and the movie starts ticking through behind the scenes beats that devoted fans of the original already know. The sentimentality is also laid on thick, and subtlety is clearly not Farrelly’s priority here.
Still, the film earns its big moments. When it finally reaches the museum steps, I found myself pumping a fist for a man whose success I already knew about, which is exactly the trick the original pulled on its audience. That is a high compliment for a movie about a movie, and it shows how much affection Farrelly has for the material.
Overall I walked out smiling and a little more willing to bet on myself, flaws and all. It is a warm, funny and well acted crowd pleaser that sags through the middle stretch of production but finishes on its feet. I give ‘I Play Rocky’ 8 out of 10.
Will you be watching 'I Play Rocky'?
Share in the comments whether you agree that ‘I Play Rocky’ goes the distance.
