5 Things About The Wolverine That Made Zero Sense and 5 Things That Made Perfect Sense
The Wolverine gave fans a darker and more personal look at Logan’s journey. It balanced emotional storytelling with intense action in Japan. While some parts worked perfectly, others left viewers scratching their heads.
Some story choices felt grounded and logical, while others broke the movie’s own rules. Here’s a mix of both — moments that made zero sense and moments that fit perfectly in Logan’s story.
Zero Sense – The Depowered Healing
Logan losing his healing factor could have been an interesting twist. But the way it was done felt inconsistent. Sometimes he healed slowly, other times not at all, and the movie never made the rules clear.
The parasite device on his heart was meant to explain this, yet he still survived situations that should have killed him. Without clear limits, the stakes didn’t feel real.
Perfect Sense – Logan’s Trauma
Logan’s nightmares about Jean Grey were a natural part of his character. He was still carrying guilt over killing her. This fit perfectly with his isolated life at the start of the movie.
The visions helped show his mental struggle without needing long dialogue scenes. It gave emotional weight to his actions.
Zero Sense – The Silver Samurai Twist
Revealing that Yashida was alive inside the Silver Samurai suit made little sense. The movie gave no real hint he could survive his illness or build such a machine in secret.
It also felt odd that no one noticed a giant metal warrior being prepared under their noses. The reveal felt forced for shock value.
Perfect Sense – Japan Setting
The Japan setting worked perfectly for Logan’s story. It tied back to his World War II past and gave him a personal connection to the Yashida family.
The cultural elements and locations also made the film visually unique compared to other superhero movies at the time.
Zero Sense – Over-the-Top Bullet Train Fight
The bullet train fight looked cool but broke all logic. Logan and his opponent leapt on and off the train at impossible speeds without being blown away.
It was pure action spectacle with no regard for physics, which clashed with the film’s more grounded tone.
Perfect Sense – Logan Protecting Mariko
Logan’s role as Mariko’s protector made sense for his character. He has always stepped in to help people in danger, especially those being hunted.
Their growing trust and bond added depth to the story and gave Logan a reason to stay in Japan.
Zero Sense – Viper’s Powers
Viper’s abilities were inconsistent. She was immune to toxins, could spit venom, and somehow remove Logan’s claws with her bare hands. The movie never explained the science behind any of it.
Her motives were also thin. She seemed dangerous just for the sake of it, without clear goals beyond helping Yashida.
Perfect Sense – Logan’s Surgery Scene
The heart surgery scene was one of the most intense moments in the film. It showed Logan’s determination and pain tolerance.
It also tied into his desperation to get his healing factor back so he could protect Mariko. This was a grounded, suspenseful sequence that felt earned.
Zero Sense – Adamantium Claw Regrowth
At the end, Logan somehow regrew his adamantium claws after they were cut off. This ignored the fact that adamantium is not naturally occurring in his body.
Unless someone secretly re-coated his claws, it should have been bone claws only. The movie never explained it.
Perfect Sense – Logan’s Final Farewell to Japan
Logan leaving Japan without a dramatic goodbye made sense. He’s a drifter who doesn’t linger once his job is done.
It fit with his lone-wolf nature and left the door open for future stories without forcing a sentimental ending.
What about you — which parts of The Wolverine worked for you, and which ones left you confused? Share your thoughts below.
