‘Ted Lasso’ Star Jason Sudeikis and Olivia Wilde Win Big as Former Nanny’s Legal Fight Ends With Zero Damages

Celebrity breakups tend to leave a long paper trail, and the split between Jason Sudeikis and Olivia Wilde has produced one of the longest. Beyond the tabloid headlines, the former couple spent years in a legal dispute with the nanny who worked in their home. That fight over the nanny’s employment now appears to be reaching its end.

Ericka Genaro worked for the couple from 2018 to 2021, caring for their 2 children during the period when Sudeikis and Wilde split up. Genaro filed a wrongful termination lawsuit against the pair in Los Angeles Superior Court in February 2023. The case was always going to be closely watched, given the high profile of the ‘Ted Lasso’ star and the director.

Her complaint centered on the aftermath of the breakup. She claimed she was wrongfully terminated because the couple’s breakup allegedly increased her childcare responsibilities and caused her stress and anxiety, and she added that Sudeikis fired her after she requested a 3-day medical leave. The couple denied that.

Genaro’s attorney has said the case would continue in arbitration, citing text messages and testimony he said showed she was driven to quit and was then fired anyway. Sudeikis and Wilde pushed back from the start. They argued that she had signed a confidentiality agreement requiring employment disputes to be resolved privately through binding arbitration in New York, not in a California courtroom.

That argument won the first round. A Los Angeles judge ruled in 2023 that the wrongful termination lawsuit be resolved in out-of-court arbitration. A representative for the couple said at the time, in a statement to E! News, “The lawsuit has been fully dismissed.”

The final result is far more lopsided than that early step. According to court documents obtained by TMZ, Sudeikis and Wilde filed a petition asking a New York judge to confirm the ruling, which denied all of Genaro’s requests for damages and dismissed all 8 of her claims. The arbitration itself is over.

The arbitrator also went beyond dismissing her claims. The arbitrator found that Genaro willfully breached her confidentiality agreement and awarded Sudeikis and Wilde more than $1.27 million in damages, legal fees and costs. That is a striking outcome in a case that began as a wrongful termination suit.

There is a catch, though. The former couple aren’t seeking to collect the money because of Genaro’s bankruptcy. So the award is a legal win more than a financial one, and it is unclear whether any money will change hands.

The petition now before a New York judge is the next step. By asking the court to confirm the ruling, the former couple are looking to make the key findings official. If granted, the decision would formalize an outcome that already went overwhelmingly in their favor.

The timeline helps explain why this has dragged on. The case began in February 2023 and moved to arbitration within about 6 months, but the arbitration itself took years to resolve. Reports describe the ruling as arriving more than 3 years after Genaro first sued.

Context matters here, because the case grew out of a very public split. Wilde and Sudeikis announced their split in November 2020. They dated for nearly a decade before calling it quits, and they have 2 children together.

The nanny’s claims touched on the household during that period. Her lawsuit alleged that Wilde’s absence from the home put more strain on her, and that Sudeikis leaned on her for support. Those were allegations, and the arbitration ruling found against all of them.

For now, the arbitration is finished, and the focus has shifted to the New York filing. None of the reports reviewed for this story mention a response from Genaro to the ruling, so it’s unclear whether she will challenge it. Her bankruptcy also leaves the financial side of the award uncertain.

What is clear is that the former couple came out ahead after years of legal back-and-forth. After a long fight that began with a single lawsuit in California, the ruling closes a messy chapter in the actors’ post-split story.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!