5 Things About ‘Daredevil’ That Made Zero Sense and 5 Things That Made Perfect Sense

When I first binged Daredevil on Netflix, I was hooked by its gritty take on Marvel’s blind vigilante, Matt Murdock. The show’s dark tone, intense action, and deep character work made it stand out in the superhero world. 

But not everything clicked perfectly, and some moments left me puzzled, while others felt like they nailed the essence of the character. Here’s my take on five things that didn’t quite add up and five that hit the mark. 

Made Zero Sense: Matt’s Financial Survival

How does Matt Murdock afford his life? As a blind lawyer running a small firm with Foggy Nelson, he’s constantly broke, yet he lives alone in a pricey New York apartment and funds his vigilante gear. 

The show never explains where the money comes from. He’s not a billionaire like Tony Stark, and his law practice barely keeps the lights on. This gap in logic makes his lifestyle feel unrealistic for a street-level hero. 

Made Perfect Sense: Grounded Setting in Hell’s Kitchen

The choice to root Daredevil (2015-2018) in the gritty streets of Hell’s Kitchen was spot-on. The neighborhood’s rough vibe matches Matt’s mission to protect the underdog. 

Every alley and rooftop feels alive, with dim lighting and urban decay adding to the noir atmosphere. This setting makes the stakes feel real and personal, unlike the world-saving plots of other Marvel stories. 

Made Zero Sense: Inconsistent Super-Senses

Matt’s heightened senses are a core part of his character, but their rules are all over the place. Sometimes he can hear a heartbeat across the city or smell someone’s lunch from days ago, yet other times he misses obvious threats. 

For example, ninjas masking their heartbeats throw him off, but he can’t track their breathing or footsteps consistently? This pick-and-choose approach to his powers feels driven by plot convenience rather than clear logic. 

Made Perfect Sense: Charlie Cox’s Performance as Matt Murdock

Charlie Cox as Matt Murdock is a casting triumph. He brings depth to a blind lawyer who’s also a fierce vigilante, balancing faith, guilt, and rage with ease. 

His ability to convey Matt’s inner conflict—especially his Catholic-driven moral struggles—makes every fight and courtroom scene compelling. Cox makes you believe in both the man and the mask. 

Made Zero Sense: The Hand’s Vague Motives

The Hand, a mystical ninja syndicate, is a major villain in season two, but their goals are murky at best. Are they after world domination, selling drugs, or just causing chaos? 

Their obsession with the Black Sky and random rituals, like draining blood, lacks clear explanation. This vagueness weakens their threat and makes their arc feel like a confusing side quest. 

Made Perfect Sense: Wilson Fisk’s Complex Villainy

Vincent D’Onofrio’s portrayal of Wilson Fisk, aka Kingpin, in Daredevil (2015-2018) is a masterclass in villainy. He’s not just a crime lord; he’s a man with deep insecurities and a twisted vision to “save” Hell’s Kitchen. 

His backstory and emotional ties to Vanessa make him relatable, even as he commits brutal acts. This layered approach makes every clash with Matt feel personal and intense. 

Made Zero Sense: Claire Temple’s Sudden Exit

Claire Temple, played by Rosario Dawson, is a key figure in season one, patching up Matt’s wounds and grounding his heroics. But in season two, she’s barely around, with no clear reason for her absence. 

Her brief return shows her as fed up, but why? The show drops her arc without exploring her emotional shift, leaving a gap in a character who felt essential early on. 

Made Perfect Sense: Intense Fight Choreography

The fight scenes in Daredevil (2015-2018) are a standout, blending brutal realism with comic-book flair. The famous hallway fight in season one sets the tone, showing Matt’s skill and vulnerability. 

Each punch and kick feels heavy, and Matt’s injuries linger, making every battle tense. The choreography respects his street-level status, avoiding over-the-top CGI for raw, grounded action. 

Made Zero Sense: Matt’s Secret Identity Struggles

Matt’s secret identity as Daredevil is constantly at risk, yet he does little to protect it. Friends like Foggy and Karen figure it out too easily, and he’s sloppy about hiding his double life. 

For a lawyer who’s supposed to be sharp, his carelessness feels out of character. The show leans into this drama but doesn’t justify why Matt can’t be more discreet. 

Made Perfect Sense: Moral Conflict and Catholicism

Matt’s Catholic faith shapes his vigilante life, creating a gripping moral tension. He believes in justice but wrestles with the violence he uses as Daredevil. 

This inner struggle, especially in season three when he questions his faith, adds depth to his character. It makes his choices feel human, grounding the superhero drama in real emotion. 

What’s your take on Daredevil—any plot holes that bugged you or moments that felt perfect? Drop your thoughts in the comments!