Gay Actresses Who Play Straight Characters

The landscape of Hollywood has changed significantly as more performers feel comfortable living authentically while pursuing their craft. Many talented actresses who identify as gay or bisexual have spent decades portraying a diverse array of straight characters on screen. These performers demonstrate immense range by stepping into roles that explore various romantic and domestic lives. This list highlights prominent gay actresses who have successfully played straight roles in major films and television series.

Sarah Paulson

Sarah Paulson has built a legendary career by portraying a wide variety of characters across multiple genres. In the series ‘American Horror Story’ she takes on numerous roles that often depict her in heterosexual relationships. She also portrayed real life prosecutor Marcia Clark in ‘The People v. O. J. Simpson’ which earned her significant critical acclaim. Paulson remains one of the most versatile performers in Hollywood today. Her ability to embody complex personas has made her a staple of modern television.

Cynthia Nixon

Cynthia Nixon is best known for her role as Miranda Hobbes in the hit series ‘Sex and the City’ and its various film sequels. Throughout the show Miranda navigates the dating scene in New York City and eventually marries a man named Steve Brady. Nixon played this straight character for years while the show became a cultural phenomenon. Her performance as a cynical but successful lawyer resonated with millions of viewers. She has since continued to take on diverse roles in both television and theater.

Jodie Foster

Jodie Foster has been a major force in the film industry since she was a young child. She delivered an iconic performance as Clarice Starling in ‘The Silence of the Lambs’ where she pursued a serial killer. Foster has played numerous straight protagonists in films such as ‘Contact’ and ‘Panic Room’ over several decades. Her commanding screen presence and dedication to her craft have earned her multiple Academy Awards. She remains one of the most respected and influential figures in the entertainment world.

Holland Taylor

Holland Taylor has enjoyed a long and successful career playing sophisticated and often humorous characters. She is widely recognized for her role as Evelyn Harper on the sitcom ‘Two and a Half Men’ where she played the mother of the main characters. In the film ‘Legally Blonde’ she portrayed Professor Stromwell who serves as a mentor to Elle Woods. Taylor has consistently played straight women in various television shows and theatrical productions. Her sharp wit and timing have made her a favorite among audiences for generations.

Fiona Shaw

Fiona Shaw is a celebrated actress who has appeared in some of the most successful film franchises in history. She is perhaps best known to international audiences for playing Petunia Dursley in the ‘Harry Potter’ film series. In this role she portrays a suburban wife and mother who is famously hostile toward her nephew. Shaw also delivered a powerful performance in the series ‘Killing Eve’ as a high level intelligence officer. Her ability to play stern and formidable characters has defined much of her recent work.

Jane Lynch

Jane Lynch rose to mainstream fame with her hilarious portrayal of Sue Sylvester in the musical series ‘Glee’. Before her breakout success she appeared in various films like ‘The 40 Year Old Virgin’ playing straight supporting characters. Lynch is known for her impeccable comedic timing and her ability to steal scenes with her dry delivery. She has voiced characters in major animated films and hosted several popular television programs. Her career spans across comedy and drama with equal success.

Lily Tomlin

Lily Tomlin is a pioneer in comedy and acting with a career spanning over half a century. She starred alongside Jane Fonda and Dolly Parton in the classic film ‘9 to 5’ as a working woman seeking revenge on her boss. Tomlin also played a variety of straight characters in films like ‘All of Me’ and ‘The Beverly Hillbillies’. More recently she starred in the series ‘Grace and Frankie’ which explores life after divorce for two older women. Her enduring talent has earned her numerous accolades including Emmy and Grammy awards.

Portia de Rossi

Portia de Rossi gained widespread recognition for her role as Nelle Porter on the legal drama ‘Ally McBeal’. She later starred as Lindsay Bluth Fünke in the acclaimed comedy series ‘Arrested Development’ where she played a shallow and materialistic socialite. In both roles she portrayed straight women navigating complex family and romantic dynamics. De Rossi also appeared in the political thriller series ‘Scandal’ as a high ranking operative. Her work in television has established her as a talented comedic and dramatic performer.

Wanda Sykes

Wanda Sykes is a prominent comedian and actress who has appeared in many successful television shows and movies. She played a recurring role in ‘The New Adventures of Old Christine’ as the best friend of the title character. Sykes also appeared in films like ‘Monster in Law’ and ‘Evan Almighty’ portraying various straight supporting roles. Her distinctive voice and sharp humor have made her a stand out performer in every project she joins. She continues to be a major influence in the world of stand up comedy and acting.

Cherry Jones

Cherry Jones is a highly respected stage and screen actress with multiple Tony Awards to her name. She became well known to television audiences for her role as President Allison Taylor in the action series ’24’. In this role she portrayed a strong and principled leader dealing with international crises and family struggles. Jones has also appeared in ‘The Handmaid’s Tale’ and ‘Succession’ taking on significant dramatic roles. Her presence on screen is often characterized by authority and emotional depth.

Beanie Feldstein

Beanie Feldstein has quickly become one of the most sought after young actresses in Hollywood. She earned critical praise for her role as Julie in the coming of age film ‘Lady Bird’ where she played a straight high school student. Feldstein also starred in the comedy ‘Booksmart’ and portrayed Monica Lewinsky in the series ‘Impeachment American Crime Story’. Her performances are often noted for their warmth and relatability. She has successfully transitioned between broad comedy and serious biographical drama.

Clea DuVall

Clea DuVall has been a consistent presence in film and television since the late nineties. she appeared in the cult classic ‘The Faculty’ and later took on a role in the Academy Award winning film ‘Argo’. DuVall has played many straight characters throughout her career in shows like ‘Heroes’ and ‘The Handmaid’s Tale’. She also moved into directing and writing with the film ‘The Happiest Season’ which explores holiday family dynamics. Her long career reflects her versatility as both a performer and a filmmaker.

Kristen Stewart

Kristen Stewart became a global superstar for her portrayal of Bella Swan in the ‘Twilight’ saga. In this massive film franchise she played a straight teenager who falls in love with a vampire and a werewolf. Stewart has since moved into more independent and experimental cinema with films like ‘Spencer’ and ‘Clouds of Sils Maria’. She remains one of the most recognizable actresses in the world due to her early blockbuster roles. Her career evolution has seen her take on a wide variety of complex and challenging characters.

Amandla Stenberg

Amandla Stenberg first gained international attention for her role as Rue in ‘The Hunger Games’. She went on to star in ‘The Hate U Give’ where she played a straight teenager who becomes a political activist after a tragedy. Stenberg also appeared in the romantic drama ‘Everything Everything’ as a young woman with a rare medical condition. Her work often focuses on social issues and the experiences of young people. She is considered a powerful voice for her generation in the entertainment industry.

Tessa Thompson

Tessa Thompson has starred in several major film franchises and critically acclaimed dramas. She plays Bianca in the ‘Creed’ series where she portrays the romantic partner and eventual wife of the lead character. Thompson also appears as Valkyrie in the Marvel Cinematic Universe and starred in the science fiction series ‘Westworld’. Her ability to command the screen in both action movies and quiet character studies is well documented. She continues to be one of the busiest and most versatile actresses in modern cinema.

Ruby Rose

Ruby Rose rose to international fame after appearing in the third season of ‘Orange Is the New Black’. She transitioned into action films with roles in ‘John Wick Chapter 2’ and ‘The Meg’ where she played straight or action oriented characters. Rose also starred as the title character in the first season of ‘Batwoman’ on television. Her striking look and athletic ability have made her a popular choice for high intensity roles. She has worked across various mediums including modeling and music.

Evan Rachel Wood

Evan Rachel Wood began her career as a child actress and gained fame for her role in the film ‘Thirteen’. She later starred as Dolores Abernathy in the series ‘Westworld’ where her character explores consciousness and humanity. Wood has played numerous straight characters in films like ‘Across the Universe’ and ‘The Wrestler’. Her performances are often marked by intense emotional honesty and physical commitment. She is recognized as one of the most talented performers of her generation.

Anna Paquin

Anna Paquin won an Academy Award at a very young age for her role in ‘The Piano’. She later became a household name as Sookie Stackhouse in the series ‘True Blood’ where she played a straight waitress with telepathic powers. Paquin also appeared as Rogue in the ‘X Men’ film series portraying a young woman dealing with unique abilities. Her career has spanned from prestigious dramas to major blockbuster hits. She continues to take on diverse roles in both film and television.

Sara Ramirez

Sara Ramirez is best known for her long running role as Dr. Callie Torres on the medical drama ‘Grey’s Anatomy’. While her character eventually came out as bisexual on the show Ramirez initially played Callie in a straight relationship with George O’Malley. She also voiced the character Queen Miranda in the animated series ‘Sofia the First’. Ramirez has a strong background in musical theater and won a Tony Award for her performance in ‘Spamalot’. She remains a prominent figure in the entertainment industry.

Kate McKinnon

Kate McKinnon became a standout performer on ‘Saturday Night Live’ known for her wide range of impressions and original characters. She starred in the 2016 ‘Ghostbusters’ reboot and played various straight characters in films like ‘Yesterday’ and ‘The Spy Who Dumped Me’. McKinnon often uses her comedic skills to create memorable and eccentric personas. She has won multiple Emmy Awards for her work in television comedy. Her influence on modern sketch comedy is widely recognized.

Abbi Jacobson

Abbi Jacobson is the co creator and star of the hit series ‘Broad City’ where she played a fictionalized version of herself. In the show her character primarily pursues relationships with men and navigates the challenges of living in New York City. Jacobson has also lent her voice to several animated projects including ‘Disenchantment’ and ‘The Mitchells vs. the Machines’. She recently co created and starred in the series ‘A League of Their Own’. Her work often blends humor with poignant observations about friendship and adulthood.

Alia Shawkat

Alia Shawkat is widely known for her role as Maeby Fünke in the cult comedy series ‘Arrested Development’. She played a straight teenager who often schemes to avoid her family and find success on her own terms. Shawkat also starred in the mystery comedy series ‘Search Party’ where she portrayed a young woman obsessed with a missing person. Her film credits include ‘The Final Girls’ and ‘Green Room’ showing her range across different genres. She is also an accomplished artist and musician outside of her acting career.

Jasika Nicole

Jasika Nicole gained fame for her role as Astrid Farnsworth on the science fiction series ‘Fringe’. In this role she played a straight FBI agent who provides essential support to the lead investigators. Nicole also appeared in ‘The Good Doctor’ as Dr. Carly Lever where she was involved in a straight romantic storyline. Her performances are often noted for their intelligence and quiet strength. She has also worked as an illustrator and creator in the craft community.

Maria Bello

Maria Bello has had a prolific career in both independent films and major studio productions. She delivered a powerful performance in ‘A History of Violence’ as a woman who discovers her husband has a secret past. Bello also starred in the series ‘ER’ and appeared in films like ‘The Mummy Tomb of the Dragon Emperor’. Throughout her career she has played many straight leading and supporting characters. Her work is characterized by its emotional depth and versatility.

Saffron Burrows

Saffron Burrows is a British American actress who has appeared in numerous films and television series. She starred in the action thriller ‘Deep Blue Sea’ and played a straight noblewoman in the epic film ‘Troy’. Burrows also had significant roles in the series ‘Boston Legal’ and the musical drama ‘Mozart in the Jungle’. Her elegant screen presence and range have allowed her to work across many different types of stories. She has been a consistent performer in the industry for several decades.

Sarah Sutherland

Sarah Sutherland is best known for her role as Catherine Meyer in the political comedy series ‘Veep’. She plays the daughter of the protagonist and is often caught in the middle of her mother’s political ambitions. In the series Catherine is depicted in a straight relationship and eventually marries her boyfriend. Sutherland has received praise for her dry comedic timing and her ability to play a grounded character in a chaotic world. She continues to build a diverse resume in television and film.

Michelle Rodriguez

Michelle Rodriguez is a major action star known for her roles in some of the highest grossing film franchises. She plays Letty Ortiz in the ‘Fast and Furious’ series where her character is in a long term straight relationship with Dominic Toretto. Rodriguez also appeared in ‘Avatar’ and ‘Resident Evil’ playing tough and capable characters. Her athletic ability and commanding presence have made her a staple of the action genre. She has been a prominent figure in Hollywood since her breakout role in ‘Girlfight’.

Amber Heard

Amber Heard has appeared in several major films across various genres including action and drama. She played Mera in the superhero film ‘Aquaman’ where her character is the romantic interest of the title hero. Heard also had roles in ‘The Rum Diary’ and ‘Pineapple Express’ portraying straight characters in different settings. Her work has often put her at the center of large scale productions and high profile projects. She has been active in the industry for many years as both an actress and a model.

Kelly McGillis

Kelly McGillis became a major star in the 1980s with iconic roles in several classic films. She played Charlie in ‘Top Gun’ where she was the romantic interest of the lead pilot played by Tom Cruise. McGillis also starred in ‘Witness’ as an Amish woman who falls in love with a police officer. Throughout her peak fame she was one of the most recognizable straight leading ladies in Hollywood. She has continued to work in smaller films and television projects over the years.

Meredith Baxter

Meredith Baxter is a beloved television actress who became a household name in the 1980s. She starred as Elyse Keaton in the popular sitcom ‘Family Ties’ where she played a former hippie raising a family. In this role she portrayed a straight wife and mother for seven successful seasons. Baxter also appeared in numerous made for television movies and other series throughout her long career. Her portrayal of the quintessential American mother made her a favorite among viewers.

Kristy McNichol

Kristy McNichol was a major teen star in the 1970s and 1980s winning two Emmy Awards for her work. She starred in the series ‘Family’ as Buddy Lawrence and later played Barbara Weston in the sitcom ‘Empty Nest’. In both of these roles she portrayed straight characters dealing with family and personal issues. McNichol also appeared in films like ‘Little Darlings’ and ‘The Pirate Movie’. She was one of the most popular and successful young actresses of her era.

Amanda Bearse

Amanda Bearse is best known for her role as Marcy Rhoades D’Arcy on the long running sitcom ‘Married with Children’. In the series she played the straight and often annoyed neighbor of the Bundy family. Bearse also directed many episodes of the show and went on to have a successful career as a television director. Her comedic performance as Marcy made her a recognizable figure in 1990s television. She has since balanced her time between acting and working behind the camera.

Heather Matarazzo

Heather Matarazzo gained critical acclaim for her breakout role in the independent film ‘Welcome to the Dollhouse’. She later appeared in ‘The Princess Diaries’ as Lilly Moscovitz who is the best friend of the main character. Matarazzo has played various straight characters in films like ‘Scream 3’ and ‘Saved’. Her work often focuses on unique and relatable characters in both comedy and drama. She has remained a respected figure in the independent film community for many years.

Kimiko Glenn

Kimiko Glenn rose to fame for her role as Brook Soso in the series ‘Orange Is the New Black’. While her character on the show explored various relationships Glenn has played straight roles in projects like ‘Waitress’ on Broadway. She also voiced characters in ‘Spider Man Into the Spider Verse’ and ‘Centaurworld’. Her energetic performances and singing ability have made her a popular choice for musical and animated roles. She continues to work across theater and television with great success.

Maisie Richardson-Sellers

Maisie Richardson-Sellers has appeared in several popular television series including ‘The Originals’ and ‘Legends of Tomorrow’. In ‘The Originals’ she played a character who was involved in straight romantic storylines within the supernatural world. She also had a role in ‘Star Wars The Force Awakens’ as a member of the Resistance. Her work often involves complex genre storytelling and strong character arcs. She is known for her striking screen presence and versatility as a performer.

Ariana DeBose

Ariana DeBose is an Academy Award winning actress and dancer who gained global fame for her role in ‘West Side Story’. She played Anita a straight character who is a central figure in the classic musical’s tragic love story. DeBose also appeared in the series ‘Schmigadoon’ and ‘Westworld’ taking on diverse roles. Her background in Broadway has made her a formidable talent in both film and stage productions. She is recognized for her incredible energy and performance skills.

Stephanie Beatriz

Stephanie Beatriz is best known for her role as Detective Rosa Diaz on the comedy series ‘Brooklyn Nine-Nine’. While her character eventually came out as bisexual on the show Beatriz played her in straight relationships in early seasons. She also voiced the lead character Mirabel in the hit Disney film ‘Encanto’ who is a straight coded protagonist. Beatriz has appeared in ‘In the Heights’ and several other film and television projects. Her ability to play tough and vulnerable characters has earned her much praise.

Shannon Woodward

Shannon Woodward is a versatile actress who has appeared in several successful television shows. She starred as Sabrina in the sitcom ‘Raising Hope’ where her character was in a long term straight relationship with the lead. Woodward also played Elsie Hughes in the science fiction series ‘Westworld’ as a brilliant programmer. Her film work includes roles in ‘The Veiling’ and ‘Man of the House’. She has consistently delivered strong performances in both comedic and dramatic settings.

Aubrey Plaza

Aubrey Plaza became a household name for her role as April Ludgate on the sitcom ‘Parks and Recreation’. In the show her character marries Andy Dwyer and they become one of the series’ most beloved straight couples. Plaza has also starred in films like ‘Ingrid Goes West’ and ‘Emily the Criminal’ showcasing her range as a dramatic actress. Her unique deadpan delivery and sharp wit have made her a favorite of audiences and critics alike. She continues to take on challenging and unconventional roles in film.

Fortune Feimster

Fortune Feimster is a popular stand up comedian and actress who has appeared in numerous comedy series. She had a recurring role on ‘The Mindy Project’ as a nurse who was involved in straight comedic storylines. Feimster also appeared in the film ‘Office Christmas Party’ and the series ‘FUBAR’ alongside Arnold Schwarzenegger. Her infectious energy and humor have made her a standout in many ensemble casts. She remains a major presence in the world of television comedy and stand up.

Margaret Cho

Margaret Cho is a groundbreaking comedian and actress who has worked in the industry for several decades. She starred in the sitcom ‘All American Girl’ as a young woman navigating her family’s traditional values. Cho also had a long running role in the series ‘Drop Dead Diva’ where she played a straight paralegal and best friend. Her work often addresses social issues and her personal experiences through a comedic lens. She is recognized as a pioneer for Asian American performers in entertainment.

Sandra Bernhard

Sandra Bernhard is a legendary performer known for her provocative stand up comedy and acting roles. She played Nancy Bartlett on the sitcom ‘Roseanne’ which was one of the first openly bisexual characters on television but she also played many straight roles prior. Bernhard has appeared in films like ‘The King of Comedy’ and ‘Hudson Hawk’ portraying various characters. Her bold personality and unique style have made her a cult icon in the entertainment world. She continues to perform on stage and in various television projects.

Carrie Brownstein

Carrie Brownstein is a musician and actress who co created and starred in the sketch comedy series ‘Portlandia’. In the show she played a vast array of characters including many straight men and women in various satirical sketches. Brownstein also appeared in the series ‘Transparent’ and the film ‘Carol’ in supporting roles. Her work in comedy is known for its sharp observation of subcultures and modern life. She is also a founding member of the influential rock band Sleater Kinney.

Kiersey Clemons

Kiersey Clemons first gained major attention for her role in the independent film ‘Dope’. She went on to play Iris West in ‘Zack Snyder’s Justice League’ and ‘The Flash’ portraying the straight romantic interest of Barry Allen. Clemons also appeared in the series ‘Transparent’ and the film ‘Hearts Beat Loud’. Her performances are often noted for their charm and emotional authenticity. She is considered one of the most promising young talents working in film today.

Brianna Hildebrand

Brianna Hildebrand is best known for her role as Negasonic Teenage Warhead in the ‘Deadpool’ film series. While her character in the sequel is openly gay she has played straight roles in other projects like the series ‘Trinkets’. Hildebrand also appeared in the horror film ‘Tragedy Girls’ as a social media obsessed teenager. Her work often involves playing rebellious or unconventional characters with a strong sense of identity. She continues to build a diverse filmography in both film and television.

Linda Hunt

Linda Hunt is an Academy Award winning actress with a career spanning several decades in film and television. She is widely recognized for her long running role as Hetty Lange on the series ‘NCIS Los Angeles’. Hunt also delivered a legendary performance in ‘The Year of Living Dangerously’ where she played a male character. Throughout her career she has portrayed many straight characters in films like ‘Kindergarten Cop’ and ‘Popeye’. Her distinctive voice and presence have made her an iconic figure in the industry.

Rosie O’Donnell

Rosie O’Donnell is a famous comedian and host who has also had a successful career as an actress. She starred in the classic film ‘A League of Their Own’ as Doris Murphy who is a straight baseball player. O’Donnell also appeared in ‘Sleepless in Seattle’ as the best friend of the female lead. Her talk show was a massive success and she has remained a prominent public figure for years. She has continued to take on character roles in various television series and theatrical productions.

Ellen DeGeneres

Ellen DeGeneres is one of the most famous comedians and television hosts in the world. Before her talk show success she starred in the film ‘Mr. Wrong’ where she played a woman desperately searching for a husband. She also starred in the sitcom ‘Ellen’ where her character was initially depicted as straight before the famous coming out episode. DeGeneres voiced the character Dory in ‘Finding Nemo’ and ‘Finding Dory’ which became massive global hits. Her career has had a profound impact on the entertainment industry and popular culture.

Leisha Hailey

Leisha Hailey is an actress and musician who gained fame for her role as Alice Pieszecki in the series ‘The L Word’. Before her breakout role she appeared in various television shows and commercials playing straight characters. Hailey is also a member of the band Uh Huh Her and was previously in the group The Murmurs. She has continued to act in projects like ‘Bosch’ and returned for the revival series ‘The L Word Generation Q’. Her career has successfully bridged the worlds of independent music and mainstream television.

Share your thoughts on these talented actresses and their performances in the comments.