8 Things in ‘The Witcher’ that Made Absolutely No Sense

Netflix’s ‘The Witcher’ has captured audiences with its gritty fantasy world, compelling characters, and epic battles. Based on Andrzej Sapkowski’s books and the popular video game series, the show follows Geralt of Rivia, a monster hunter navigating a treacherous world.

However, despite its popularity, certain elements in the series leave viewers scratching their heads. From timeline confusion to character choices, some moments defy logic. Here are eight aspects of ‘The Witcher’ that don’t quite add up.

Inconsistent Use of Magic

Magic in ‘The Witcher’ feels like a plot device that bends to the story’s needs. Mages like Yennefer can teleport across vast distances or unleash devastating power, yet they often resort to mundane travel or struggle in situations where magic could easily solve the problem.

For example, Yennefer’s ability to teleport is used sparingly, with characters often riding horses or walking for days. This inconsistency makes the rules of magic feel arbitrary, leaving me wondering why such powerful abilities are ignored when convenient.

Geralt’s Inconsistent Monster-Slaying Code

Geralt, played by Henry Cavill, is a witcher with a strict moral code, refusing to kill sentient beings unless necessary. Yet, in Season 2, he slays the bruxa Vereena without hesitation, despite her sentience.

This contradicts his earlier reluctance to kill beings capable of reason, like the striga. The show doesn’t explain why he makes an exception, making his principles feel shaky and his actions confusing.

Ciri’s Trust in a Stranger

Ciri’s instant trust in Geralt at the end of Season 1 feels unearned. In the books, they meet earlier in Brokilon Forest, building a bond, but the show skips this, having them meet after the Battle of Sodden.

A young girl, betrayed and on the run, trusting a stranger so quickly stretches belief. Without prior connection, her leap of faith feels rushed and undermines her cautious character.

The Law of Surprise Explained Poorly

The Law of Surprise, a key plot point, is introduced with little clarity. Geralt invokes it to claim a reward, unknowingly binding himself to Ciri, but the show barely explains its rules or importance.

Viewers are left puzzled about why this magical pact holds such weight or how it works. A brief explanation could have grounded this concept, but its vagueness makes pivotal moments feel unconvincing.

Nilfgaard’s Sudden Threat

Nilfgaard’s role as a looming empire is central to the story, but the show does little to establish why they’re such a danger. Their motives and strength are mentioned in passing, yet their invasion feels abrupt.

Without context about their power or goals, their threat feels hollow. A few scenes showing their rise or influence could have made their role more menacing and believable.

Geralt’s Quest for a Djinn

In Season 1, Geralt hunts a djinn to cure his insomnia, a bizarre choice that comes out of nowhere. The show doesn’t hint at his sleeplessness being a major issue, making the quest feel trivial.

This leads to chaotic events, like Yennefer nearly destroying Rinde to save Jaskier. The randomness of this plotline, with no buildup or resolution, leaves it feeling like a strange detour.

Timeline Confusion

The show’s first season jumps between different timelines without clear markers, making it hard to follow. Geralt, Yennefer, and Ciri’s stories unfold decades apart, but the show doesn’t signal these shifts.

Viewers are left piecing together when events happen, like Yennefer’s decades-long service to a king. Clearer cues, like visual indicators or dates, could have made the narrative less disorienting.

Jaskier’s Unclear Relationship with Geralt

Jaskier’s bond with Geralt is a fan favorite, but its timeline and depth are murky. The show doesn’t clarify how long they travel together or why Jaskier sticks around despite Geralt’s gruff demeanor.

Their friendship feels inconsistent, with Jaskier sometimes acting like a loyal companion and other times like a casual acquaintance. This lack of clarity makes their dynamic feel underdeveloped.

What’s the most baffling moment in ‘The Witcher’ for you, or did I miss a confusing plot point? Drop your thoughts in the comments!