10 Underrated Movies in Sarah Michelle Gellar’s Film Career

Sarah Michelle Gellar is a name that sparks instant recognition for her iconic role as Buffy Summers in ‘Buffy the Vampire Slayer.’ Yet, beyond the vampire-slaying spotlight, she has delivered a range of performances in films that often fly under the radar. From romantic comedies to chilling thrillers, her versatility shines in projects that deserve more love than they get.

We’re diving into ten of her most overlooked movies, each showcasing her ability to bring depth, charm, or intensity to the screen. These films, spanning different genres, highlight her talent in roles that didn’t always get the attention they merited. Let’s explore these hidden treasures, starting from the least recognized to the most underappreciated.

10. Over the Brooklyn Bridge (1984)

Gellar made her film debut at just seven years old in this heartwarming comedy-romance. She plays a small role as the daughter in a story about a Brooklyn deli owner chasing his dream of opening a Manhattan restaurant. The film mixes humor with family drama, but its low profile keeps it off most radars. Gellar’s brief appearance is a sweet hint of her early start in acting.

9. The Air I Breathe (2007)

In this drama, Gellar plays a struggling singer named Sorrow, one of four characters tied to emotions like happiness, pleasure, sorrow, and love. The interconnected stories explore heavy themes, and Gellar’s emotional performance stands out despite the film’s mixed reception. Its complex narrative didn’t click with everyone, but her role adds raw depth.

8. Harvard Man (2001)

This crime comedy-drama features Gellar as a manipulative girlfriend entangled in a wild plot about a Harvard basketball player fixing games for the mob. Her sharp, cunning performance keeps the chaotic story grounded. The film’s trippy vibe and niche appeal make it a lesser-known entry in her career.

7. Possession (2008)

Gellar stars as a woman dealing with the aftermath of a car accident that leaves her husband and brother-in-law in comas. When one wakes up believing he’s the other, the psychological thriller unfolds with twists. Gellar’s dual emotional range carries the film, though its limited release kept it from wider acclaim.

6. Veronika Decides to Die (2009)

In this introspective drama, Gellar plays Veronika, a woman who rediscovers her will to live after a failed suicide attempt. Set in a psychiatric facility, the film explores mental health and resilience. Gellar’s sensitive portrayal is gripping, but the movie’s heavy themes meant it didn’t reach a broad audience.

5. Suburban Girl (2007)

Gellar shines as a young book editor navigating love and career in New York City, opposite Alec Baldwin. This romantic comedy-drama blends wit with heartfelt moments, showing Gellar’s knack for lighter roles. Its quiet release and lack of marketing left it overshadowed by her bigger hits.

4. Southland Tales (2006)

In this ambitious sci-fi thriller, Gellar plays a porn star with big dreams in a dystopian future. The sprawling, star-studded cast and wild plot didn’t win over critics, but Gellar’s bold performance adds spark to the chaos. The film’s cult status is growing, yet it remains underseen.

3. Simply Irresistible (1999)

Gellar stars as a chef whose cooking skills magically improve thanks to a mystical crab in this quirky romantic comedy. Paired with Sean Patrick Flanery, her charm drives the lighthearted story. Despite its whimsical appeal, the film was dismissed by critics and remains a hidden gem.

2. Small Soldiers (1998)

This action-comedy about toys coming to life features Gellar in a supporting role as a teenager caught in the chaos. The blend of humor, special effects, and a stellar cast, including Kirsten Dunst, makes it a fun ride. Its kid-friendly shift dulled its edge, leaving it less celebrated than it deserves.

1. TMNT (2007)

Gellar voices April O’Neil in this animated Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles film, bringing energy to the iconic reporter. The movie, a hit with audiences, revived the franchise with fresh action and nostalgia. Gellar’s voice work is spot-on, but the film’s animated nature keeps it from being tied to her live-action fame.

Which of these Sarah Michelle Gellar films is your favorite, or is there another underrated gem we should check out? Drop your thoughts in the comments!