5 Things About ‘The Godfather’ That Made Zero Sense & 5 Things That Made Perfect Sense

‘The Godfather’ is a classic. It changed crime movies and pop culture. Many scenes feel tight and true. Some choices still raise eyebrows.

This list looks at both sides. It switches between what made no sense and what made perfect sense. The aim is clear and simple. No fluff. Just the key points.

Zero Sense: The near-empty hospital during Vito’s recovery

Michael finds the hospital almost empty. There are no guards and few staff. This leaves Vito open to another hit. It feels careless for such a high-profile target.

Yes, police corruption is in play. But a full pullback with no backup looks extreme. Even a small detail like one posted officer would track better. The total vacuum strains logic.

Perfect Sense: Vito refusing the narcotics deal

Vito turns down the drug business. He values his ties with judges and politicians. He knows drugs bring heat and risk. The cost to the family would be too high.

This choice fits his code. He wants steady power, not fast cash. Gambling and unions are safer. His long game stays intact.

Zero Sense: Luca Brasi walking into a trap alone

Luca is the family’s feared enforcer. Yet he meets the Tattaglias without real backup. He shows no sign of testing the room. He gets taken out fast.

A pro like Luca should expect a setup. A simple tail, a weapon check, or a safer venue could help. Going in blind does not match his legend. It feels off.

Perfect Sense: Michael taking out Sollozzo and McCluskey

Michael is the “civilian” son, but he sees the gap. Sollozzo is dangerous. McCluskey shields him. No legal fix will work.

The restaurant hit is cold and planned. Michael hides the gun, keeps his nerve, and acts. It solves two problems at once. It also marks his turn toward power.

Zero Sense: Sonny driving to the toll booth without proper protection

Sonny is hot-headed, but he is also a boss. Racing off alone after a phone call is reckless. He ignores basic security. The ambush is then easy.

A short delay to assemble a convoy could save him. Even one trailing car helps. His rage overrides sense. The setup feels too simple for a seasoned crew.

Perfect Sense: Michael hiding in Sicily after the hit

After the restaurant hit, Michael must disappear. Sicily is the smart choice. The family has allies there. Distance buys time.

This move shields the family in New York. It also lets Michael harden and learn. When he returns, he knows what he wants. The exile serves the arc.

Zero Sense: Captain McCluskey punching Michael in public

A police captain breaks Michael’s jaw in front of people. It is loud and messy. It risks attention and reports. It gives the Corleones public sympathy.

A corrupt cop should act quiet and clean. A street assault creates witnesses. It hands Michael a reason to strike back. The move is needlessly risky.

Perfect Sense: The baptism day hits as an airtight alibi

Michael times the hits with the baptism. He stands as godfather while the strikes roll out. It is a strong public alibi. It also sends a message.

The plan removes leaders across town at once. It stops fast retaliation. It clears the board and seals Michael’s control. The logic is sharp.

Zero Sense: Kay believing Michael’s denial about Carlo

Kay asks if Michael ordered Carlo’s death. Michael lies, and she accepts it. The door closes, and she is shut out. Her quick acceptance feels thin.

She has seen enough to doubt him. The change in Michael is clear. A longer pushback or more questions would fit. The scene works as drama, but the trust beats are hard to buy.

Perfect Sense: “It’s business” logic behind settling all family matters

Michael removes every threat after Vito’s death. He cuts ties with traitors and rivals. It is cold, but it keeps the family safe. Loose ends vanish.

This is the core code of the story. Power needs order. Mercy invites payback. The final sweep fits the world and the stakes.

Share which ‘The Godfather’ moments felt real to you and which ones you still question in the comments.