Timothy Olyphant’s ‘Lucky’ Season 2? Showrunners Finally Reveal What’s Next

Apple TV’s new crime thriller Lucky is expected to remain a one-season story, with the creative team behind the show confirming that they built it as a limited series from the beginning.

Based on Marissa Stapley’s bestselling novel, Lucky follows Anya Taylor-Joy’s character, Lucky Armstrong, a woman who grew up learning the tricks of the con artist world from her father, John Armstrong, played by Timothy Olyphant. After a major crime plan involving her husband and a dangerous criminal goes wrong, Lucky finds herself caught between a powerful mob boss and the FBI while trying to escape the life she was raised in.

Ahead of the show’s release, ScreenRant’s Ash Crossan spoke with executive producer Lauren Neustadter, showrunners Cassie Pappas and Jonathan Tropper, and actress Annette Bening about the future of Lucky. During the interview, Neustadter explained that the series was always created with a clear ending in mind and was not designed to continue for multiple seasons.

“It’s definitely a limited series,” Neustadter said, adding that the team felt fortunate to work with Taylor-Joy after her success with The Queen’s Gambit. She explained that the actress had mainly focused on movies after that series, so bringing her back for another television project was something they valued.

“She has a lot of different things going on, so we felt very lucky — sorry for the pun — to get to make her next television show after The Queen’s Gambit,” Neustadter said. She also shared that the team was proud of every episode and was excited for viewers to experience the story.

Lucky showrunners Pappas and Tropper agreed that the series was created to tell one complete story. However, they did not completely rule out the possibility of returning in the future if the show becomes a major success.

Tropper explained that the team never created plans for another season because they wanted the story to have a proper conclusion. He also pointed out that making a limited series helped attract actors with busy careers.

“We really wanted to make this a closed-ended story,” Tropper said. “Also, you’re not going to get actors of the caliber that we got if you tell them they have to commit to three or five years. If you tell them it’s one and done, you can get Annette Bening, Anya Taylor-Joy and Timothy Olyphant. It’s much harder to sell them on an ongoing series.”

Bening also confirmed that she understood from the start that Lucky would only run for one season. She said she did not focus on where her character could go in future episodes, but she was interested in how the story would finish.

The actress teased that the ending will be surprising and meaningful for her character. She also enjoyed the freedom that came with knowing the series had a planned conclusion.

The decision to keep Lucky as a limited series also makes sense because the show is based on a single novel by Marissa Stapley, which does not currently have a sequel. The original story already provides a complete ending, making another season unnecessary unless the creators decide to expand the world.

The cast and creative team are also involved in many other projects. Taylor-Joy continues to take on major film roles, while Olyphant and Bening have several television projects keeping them busy.

For now, viewers should expect Lucky to be a short, complete thriller rather than a long-running series. The first two episodes are currently available on Apple TV, with new episodes released every Wednesday.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!