James Franco Admits One of His Films Was a “Big Mistake”

James Franco once reflected on his career and admitted that one of his films stands out as a major misstep: Tristan & Isolde. The 2006 romantic drama, directed by Kevin Reynolds and produced by Ridley and Tony Scott, starred Franco alongside Sophia Myles and was based on the classic medieval legend. Despite the film’s high-profile backing, Franco now considers it a “big mistake.”

Speaking to The Daily Beast, Franco explained that his youth and ambition influenced his decision. “I was an overzealous young actor and wanted to make great movies. I read the script and wasn’t sure about it, but my acting teacher said it was a role that a young Brando or Olivier would do. I thought, ‘OK…I guess’,” he recalled.

Franco described the intense preparation for the role, including sword-fighting practice in his girlfriend’s backyard and riding Andalusian horses in Griffith Park. Yet, once filming began in Ireland, he discovered that the script had changed significantly.

“All the training I did was useless,” he admitted, after battle scenes were replaced with stealthy confrontations instead of large-scale fights.

The experience taught him an important lesson. “I will never do a movie again that I don’t have a special feeling for. I know now that you feel it somewhere in your gut when you believe in a movie, and that’s why you should do it. Don’t do a movie you wouldn’t see or don’t believe in, because movies can be hell to make.”

Tristan & Isolde struggled at the box office, opening in 1,845 theaters in North America on January 13, 2006, and earning just over $6.5 million in its first weekend. Its total domestic gross was around $28 million.

Critics were mixed, with Rotten Tomatoes giving it a 31% score based on 121 reviews, noting that the film “doesn’t achieve the sweeping romanticism that it aims for.” Metacritic scored it 49 out of 100, reflecting average reviews. Manohla Dargis of The New York Times offered a more tempered opinion, saying the film delivered “exactly what it promises, no less, no more,” with “some fairly bloodless fighting and some very chaste lovemaking.”

Looking back, Franco sees the movie as a learning experience that shaped his approach to choosing roles in the future. He now emphasizes the importance of connecting personally with a project before committing.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!