Barry Keoghan Is Officially Returning as the Joker in ‘The Batman: Part 2,’ And the Gotham Fandom Is Losing It

The question that has been hanging over ‘The Batman: Part 2‘ since Robert Pattinson’s Bruce Wayne first locked eyes with that scarred, unsettling figure in Arkham has finally been answered. Barry Keoghan is officially set to return as the Joker in Matt Reeves’ sequel.

Keoghan’s original appearance in ‘The Batman’ was brief but unforgettable. He appeared as an unnamed Arkham State Hospital prisoner whose grotesquely scarred face and menacing rapport with Robert Pattinson’s Batman left audiences absolutely certain they were watching the early formation of something genuinely dangerous. Matt Reeves at the time described the character as a “pre-Joker Joker,” a deliberately incomplete figure not yet the fully-formed villain audiences know, which made the sequel’s potential all the more loaded.

The actor himself had been masterfully evasive about his return ever since. When asked point-blank about reprising the role, Keoghan previously told Variety that he “can’t say much,” adding “we’ll see where that goes,” while describing the original experience as incredible. That noncommittal two-step is now resolved, and the announcement has detonated across social media exactly the way that kind of confirmation tends to.

Keoghan will not be the only formidable new addition to the sequel’s villain picture. Sebastian Stan has been reported in a detailed casting that points toward him playing Harvey Dent, the Gotham district attorney who becomes Two-Face, in what would set up a potentially significant arc across this chapter and beyond. Scarlett Johansson, making a notable jump from Marvel to the DC universe, has also been reported as joining the film in a mystery role, with speculation pointing toward a character who functions as both villain and love interest.

The story for ‘The Batman: Part 2’ will dig deeper into Gotham’s corruption, with director Reeves describing in SFX Magazine how the film goes into places Bruce Wayne could not have anticipated in the first entry and explores elements planted throughout that original story. Zoë Kravitz, who played Selina Kyle in ‘The Batman,’ is reported to have departed the franchise, leaving the relationship dynamic around Batman more open than audiences might have expected heading into the sequel.

‘The Batman’ was a commercial and critical success when it released in 2022, grossing $770 million globally against a reported $185 million production budget and landing an 85% on Rotten Tomatoes. ‘The Batman: Part 2’ is currently scheduled for release on October 1, 2027.

With Keoghan confirmed, the central question for this Gotham chapter is no longer whether the Joker will appear but how fully the sequel will unleash him, and what that looks like inside Matt Reeves’ grimy, grounded version of the city.

Have something to add? Let us know in the comments!