Hollywood Actors Who Were Supposed to Be the Next Big Thing

Hollywood history is filled with talented performers who were once heralded as the future icons of the silver screen. These actors received massive promotional pushes and landed coveted roles in major studio blockbusters during the early stages of their careers. While some found consistent work in the industry others saw their initial momentum fade due to shifting audience tastes or personal choices. This list explores the male stars who were expected to dominate the industry but took different paths in their professional journeys.

Josh Hartnett

Josh Hartnett became a global sensation in the late nineties after appearing in the horror hit ‘The Faculty’. He soon landed major leading roles in historical dramas like ‘Pearl Harbor’ and gritty action films such as ‘Black Hawk Down’. Industry insiders frequently compared him to the most established leading men of the era. He eventually made the personal choice to step away from the pressures of mainstream Hollywood stardom to pursue independent projects. Today he is respected for his artistic range and his continued work in both film and television.

Skeet Ulrich

Skeet Ulrich gained significant attention for his striking resemblance to a young Johnny Depp during the mid-nineties. He starred in the massively successful horror film ‘Scream’ and the supernatural thriller ‘The Craft’. These roles established him as a rising star with a dark and brooding screen presence. His career path shifted toward television where he found success in the series ‘Jericho’ and later in ‘Riverdale’. He remains a recognizable figure in the industry even if he did not become the blockbuster film lead many expected.

Taylor Kitsch

Taylor Kitsch was poised for superstardom following his breakout performance in the television drama ‘Friday Night Lights’. Hollywood studios cast him as the lead in three major big budget films including ‘John Carter’ and ‘Battleship’. Despite the heavy marketing campaigns these projects struggled to perform at the box office. He transitioned back to character work in projects like the miniseries ‘Waco’ and the film ‘Lone Survivor’. His career serves as a notable example of the immense pressure placed on young actors to carry expensive franchises.

Alex Pettyfer

Alex Pettyfer was introduced to global audiences as a teenager in the action movie ‘Stormbreaker’. He was later the center of high profile promotional campaigns for films like ‘I Am Number Four’ and ‘Beastly’. Many experts believed he would become the next major romantic lead and action star for the teen demographic. His reputation in the industry faced challenges during his early twenties and his frequency in major studio films began to decline. He continues to act in a variety of independent films and has explored directing and producing.

Sam Worthington

Sam Worthington became an overnight household name after starring in the record breaking blockbuster ‘Avatar’. He was quickly cast in other major franchise films such as ‘Terminator Salvation’ and ‘Clash of the Titans’. While these movies were financially successful he did not quite achieve the consistent A-list status associated with legendary leading men. He has since focused on a mix of high budget sequels and smaller character driven stories. His career remains active with a heavy focus on the ongoing sequels to the ‘Avatar’ franchise.

Garrett Hedlund

Garrett Hedlund entered the industry with a prominent role in the historical epic ‘Troy’. He later received a significant career boost when he was cast as the lead in ‘Tron: Legacy’. Critics often noted his classic good looks and deep voice as qualities that would make him a massive star. He ultimately chose to focus on more nuanced performances in films like ‘Mudbound’ and ‘Inside Llewyn Davis’. This focus on craft over commerciality has earned him respect within the independent film community.

Wes Bentley

Wes Bentley became a breakout star following his haunting performance in the award winning film ‘American Beauty’. His portrayal of a sensitive and artistic teenager led to many offers for major studio productions. He took a brief hiatus from the industry to deal with personal struggles before returning to acting. He found a second wave of success in the blockbuster ‘The Hunger Games’ and the series ‘American Horror Story’. He is now a regular fixture on the popular television drama ‘Yellowstone’.

Armie Hammer

Armie Hammer appeared to have the perfect trajectory for stardom after playing dual roles in ‘The Social Network’. He was cast in several high profile films including ‘The Lone Ranger’ and ‘The Man from U.N.C.L.E.’. His combination of traditional leading man features and athletic build made him a favorite for studio executives. Controversies regarding his personal life led to a significant halt in his professional career and the loss of multiple upcoming projects. He has largely remained out of the public eye and the Hollywood spotlight in recent years.

Jai Courtney

Jai Courtney was introduced as a major action star through roles in ‘A Good Day to Die Hard’ and ‘Jack Reacher’. He was frequently cast in significant franchises including ‘Divergent’ and ‘Terminator Genisys’. Despite appearing in these massive productions he often received criticism for lacking the distinct charisma of established action icons. He found more critical acclaim for his supporting role as Captain Boomerang in ‘Suicide Squad’. He continues to work steadily in both the Australian and American film industries.

Chris Klein

Chris Klein rose to fame as the charming athlete Oz in the comedy hit ‘American Pie’. He was quickly positioned as a new romantic lead in films like ‘Here on Earth’ and the action movie ‘Rollerball’. The commercial failure of some of his early leading roles slowed his momentum in the film industry. He later embraced his comedic roots and found a new generation of fans through the ‘American Pie’ sequels. He also appeared as a primary antagonist in the television series ‘The Flash’.

Freddie Prinze Jr.

Freddie Prinze Jr. was the quintessential teen heartthrob of the late nineties following his success in ‘I Know What You Did Last Summer’. He solidified his status with the romantic comedy ‘She’s All That’ and the ‘Scooby-Doo’ live action films. While he was one of the most recognizable faces of his era he eventually moved away from traditional acting roles. He transitioned into voice acting for major franchises and worked as a writer for professional wrestling. He now balances selective acting roles with his passion for cooking and gaming.

Hayden Christensen

Hayden Christensen achieved worldwide fame when George Lucas cast him as Anakin Skywalker in the ‘Star Wars’ prequel trilogy. The intense scrutiny and critical response to the films made his transition to other leading roles difficult. He starred in the science fiction film ‘Jumper’ but it did not launch a long running franchise as expected. He chose to spend more time on his farm in Canada and took a step back from the Hollywood machine. He has recently returned to the ‘Star Wars’ universe to reprise his iconic role in new television series.

Jonathan Taylor Thomas

Jonathan Taylor Thomas was arguably the biggest child star of the nineties due to his role on ‘Home Improvement’. He also provided the voice for young Simba in the animated classic ‘The Lion King’. Many predicted he would transition into a major adult leading man similar to other child stars of the past. He chose to prioritize his education and attended prestigious universities like Harvard and Columbia. He has mostly stayed away from the entertainment industry except for a few brief guest appearances.

Brandon Routh

Brandon Routh was selected from thousands of hopefuls to play the Man of Steel in ‘Superman Returns’. He was praised for his physical resemblance to Christopher Reeve and his earnest performance. The film did not generate the level of success required to launch a direct sequel and his time as Superman ended. He managed to reinvent his career by taking on comedic and supporting roles in ‘Scott Pilgrim vs. the World’. He eventually found a consistent home in the television superhero community as the character Ray Palmer.

Casper Van Dien

Casper Van Dien became a household name after starring as Johnny Rico in the science fiction film ‘Starship Troopers’. His classic features led to him being cast as Tarzan and in other high profile projects like ‘Sleepy Hollow’. He was often viewed as the next great action hero during the late nineties. The sequels to his major films often went directly to video which impacted his status as a theatrical leading man. He continues to work frequently in the independent and genre film circuits.

Billy Zane

Billy Zane reached a career peak as the antagonist in the record breaking film ‘Titanic’. He was already well known for his roles in ‘The Phantom’ and ‘Dead Calm’. Following the success of ‘Titanic’ many expected him to transition into a series of top tier leading man roles. He instead found a niche in supporting roles and independent cinema where he has remained prolific. He is often celebrated for his charismatic screen presence and his ability to play complex villains.

Josh Lucas

Josh Lucas gained significant attention for his role as the romantic lead in ‘Sweet Home Alabama’. He followed this success with parts in ‘A Beautiful Mind’ and the action film ‘Stealth’. Studios viewed him as a versatile actor who could handle both drama and high budget spectacles. While ‘Stealth’ did not perform well at the box office he continued to find success in character roles. He has maintained a steady career in films like ‘Ford v Ferrari’ and the television series ‘Yellowstone’.

Shane West

Shane West became a prominent young star after lead roles in the drama ‘A Walk to Remember’ and the series ‘Once and Again’. He was cast as Tom Sawyer in the big budget adaptation ‘The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen’. That film was intended to launch a major franchise but failed to meet commercial expectations. He transitioned into more television work and gained a following for his roles in ‘Nikita’ and ‘Salem’. He is also known for his musical career as a member of the punk band the Germs.

Ryan Phillippe

Ryan Phillippe became a star in the late nineties through films like ‘I Know What You Did Last Summer’ and ‘Cruel Intentions’. He was frequently featured on magazine covers and was considered one of the most promising actors of his generation. He pursued more serious roles in acclaimed movies such as ‘Gosford Park’ and ‘Crash’. While he remained a steady worker he did not reach the level of superstardom predicted during his early career. He later found success as the lead in the television thriller series ‘Shooter’.

Jim Sturgess

Jim Sturgess was positioned for a massive career after starring in the musical ‘Across the Universe’. He went on to lead the gambling drama ’21’ and the ambitious epic ‘Cloud Atlas’. His ability to transform for various roles made him a favorite among prestigious directors. Despite these high profile opportunities he did not become a consistent box office draw in the United States. He has since focused on television projects and independent films in both America and the United Kingdom.

Emile Hirsch

Emile Hirsch earned critical acclaim for his performances in ‘Lords of Dogtown’ and ‘Into the Wild’. He was chosen to lead the big budget adaptation of ‘Speed Racer’ which was expected to be a massive hit. The film underperformed and his career momentum in major studio projects slowed down. He has since focused on character roles in films like ‘Once Upon a Time in Hollywood’. His talent remains recognized by critics even if his commercial standing changed.

James Marsden

James Marsden was widely recognized for his role as Cyclops in the ‘X-Men’ franchise during the early thousands. He possessed the looks and talent of a traditional Hollywood leading man and appeared in hits like ‘The Notebook’ and ‘Enchanted’. He often found himself cast in supporting roles rather than the primary lead in major blockbusters. He eventually found great success in television series like ‘Westworld’ and ‘Dead to Me’. He continues to be a highly respected and versatile actor in the industry today.

Stephen Dorff

Stephen Dorff was a prominent young actor in the nineties with roles in ‘Blade’ and ‘Backbeat’. He was often considered for the same major roles as other top tier stars of the decade. He developed a reputation for choosing gritty and unconventional projects over safe commercial hits. His performance in Sofia Coppola’s ‘Somewhere’ reminded audiences of his depth and skill as a performer. He has recently found success in the third season of ‘True Detective’ and the series ‘Deputy’.

Thomas Jane

Thomas Jane was poised for a major career breakthrough when he was cast as the lead in ‘The Punisher’. He had already appeared in high profile films like ‘Deep Blue Sea’ and ‘Boogie Nights’. While his portrayal of Frank Castle was popular with fans the film did not launch a long running franchise for him. He moved into television and received critical praise for his role in the series ‘Hung’. He remains active in the industry and is known for his work in the science fiction series ‘The Expanse’.

Eric Bana

Eric Bana transitioned from Australian television to Hollywood with a powerful performance in ‘Chopper’. He was quickly cast as the lead in ‘Hulk’ and the historical epic ‘Troy’. While he worked with legendary directors like Steven Spielberg in ‘Munich’ he did not maintain a consistent presence as a blockbuster lead. He eventually chose to take fewer roles in Hollywood to spend more time in his native Australia. He continues to deliver strong performances in films like ‘The Dry’.

Scott Speedman

Scott Speedman became a fan favorite through the television series ‘Felicity’ and the ‘Underworld’ film franchise. He was often looked at as a potential leading man for romantic dramas and action thrillers alike. He chose to focus on more understated roles in independent films for several years. He returned to the mainstream spotlight with roles in ‘Animal Kingdom’ and ‘Grey’s Anatomy’. His career has been defined by a preference for character depth over celebrity status.

Cam Gigandet

Cam Gigandet gained notoriety as the villain in ‘Twilight’ and the action movie ‘Never Back Down’. He was frequently cast in films that highlighted his athletic physique and intense screen presence. Many expected him to transition into a major action hero during the late two thousands. He has appeared in several smaller action films and thrillers since his initial rise to fame. He continues to work steadily in the genre film industry.

Kellan Lutz

Kellan Lutz became a recognizable face worldwide through his role as Emmett Cullen in the ‘Twilight’ saga. He was given a chance at leading man status in ‘The Legend of Hercules’ and ‘The Expendables 3’. These projects did not achieve the level of commercial success needed to solidify him as a top tier star. He has found a consistent place in television as a lead in the series ‘FBI: Most Wanted’. He remains active in the industry while focusing on his family and personal ventures.

Topher Grace

Topher Grace was the breakout star of the hit sitcom ‘That ’70s Show’ and was expected to have a major film career. He landed the role of Eddie Brock in ‘Spider-Man 3’ which was one of the biggest films of the decade. He later chose to take a hiatus from acting to focus on film editing and more selective character roles. He earned critical praise for his performance in ‘BlacKkKlansman’ which signaled a new phase in his career. He is currently starring in the television comedy ‘Home Economics’.

Joel Kinnaman

Joel Kinnaman gained international attention with the Swedish film ‘Easy Money’ and the series ‘The Killing’. He was cast as the lead in the high profile remake of ‘RoboCop’ which was meant to launch him as a Hollywood star. The film received mixed reviews and he moved into more ensemble and television work. He achieved success as Rick Flag in the ‘Suicide Squad’ films and as the lead in ‘Altered Carbon’. He continues to be a prominent actor in both action and dramatic roles.

Jason Patric

Jason Patric was hailed as one of the most talented actors of his generation following his role in ‘The Lost Boys’. He was cast as the lead in ‘Speed 2: Cruise Control’ which was expected to be a massive summer blockbuster. The film was a critical and commercial disappointment which affected his trajectory in major studio films. He preferred working in theater and smaller independent films like ‘Narc’ where he received critical acclaim. He maintains a respected reputation for his intense and thoughtful performances.

Matthew Fox

Matthew Fox was a major television star due to his lead roles in ‘Party of Five’ and the phenomenon ‘Lost’. He attempted to transition to the big screen with roles in ‘Speed Racer’ and ‘Alex Cross’. His film career did not reach the same heights as his television success during that period. He took a significant break from the entertainment industry for several years to focus on his personal life. He recently returned to acting in the television miniseries ‘Last Light’.

Benjamin Bratt

Benjamin Bratt became a household name during his time on the long running series ‘Law & Order’. He was cast as the leading man opposite major stars in films like ‘Miss Congeniality’ and ‘The Next Best Thing’. While he had the charisma and looks of a top tier star he often found more success in supporting roles. He has provided voice work for several animated hits including ‘Coco’ and ‘Despicable Me 2’. He remains a consistent presence on television in shows like ‘Star’ and ‘Poker Face’.

Robert Patrick

Robert Patrick became an icon after playing the T-1000 in ‘Terminator 2: Judgment Day’. He was often considered for other major villainous and leading roles in big budget action films. He found that he was frequently typecast as intense or antagonistic characters due to his breakthrough performance. He transitioned into a highly successful character actor with significant roles in ‘The X-Files’ and ‘Sons of Anarchy’. He continues to be one of the most hardworking and recognizable actors in Hollywood.

Clive Owen

Clive Owen was predicted to be the next big action icon after his roles in ‘The Hire’ short films and ‘King Arthur’. He received an Academy Award nomination for his performance in ‘Closer’ and starred in the acclaimed ‘Children of Men’. While he was a favorite for many prestigious roles he did not become a consistent blockbuster draw. He has since focused on compelling television projects like ‘The Knick’ and various character roles. He is still regarded as one of the most talented and suave actors in the industry.

Orlando Bloom

Orlando Bloom became one of the biggest stars in the world by appearing in the ‘Lord of the Rings’ and ‘Pirates of the Caribbean’ franchises. He was the primary romantic and action lead for a generation of moviegoers. As these franchises concluded he struggled to find new leading roles that matched their commercial impact. He took time to focus on theater and personal projects before returning to television in ‘Carnival Row’. He remains a significant celebrity but no longer dominates the box office as he once did.

Edward Furlong

Edward Furlong became a star as a child after his iconic performance in ‘Terminator 2: Judgment Day’. He followed this with a critically acclaimed role in ‘American History X’ which suggested a long career ahead. Personal struggles and health issues during his young adulthood impacted his ability to secure major studio roles. He worked primarily in independent and direct to video films for many years. His story is often cited as a cautionary tale about the difficulties of early fame.

Shia LaBeouf

Shia LaBeouf was groomed to be the next major leading man with roles in the ‘Transformers’ series and ‘Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull’. He worked with legendary directors like Steven Spielberg and was a constant presence in summer blockbusters. He eventually rejected the Hollywood system to focus on performance art and gritty independent films like ‘Honey Boy’. His personal behavior and legal issues also complicated his standing with major studios. He continues to act in selective roles while maintaining a controversial public image.

Adrien Brody

Adrien Brody became the youngest person to win the Academy Award for Best Actor for his role in ‘The Pianist’. This achievement led to leading roles in big budget films like ‘King Kong’ and ‘Predators’. He did not quite fit the traditional mold of a Hollywood action hero which led to a diverse and sometimes erratic career path. He has since appeared in many Wes Anderson films and successful television series like ‘Peaky Blinders’. He remains a highly respected actor known for his unique choices and intense dedication.

Jerry O’Connell

Jerry O’Connell was a famous child actor in ‘Stand by Me’ and later starred in the popular series ‘Sliders’. He had the physical presence and comedic timing of a leading man and appeared in hits like ‘Jerry Maguire’. While he worked steadily he never quite made the leap to the top tier of film superstardom. He eventually embraced a variety of roles in television comedies and reality programming. He is now a well known television personality and a frequent guest on various talk shows.

Ralph Macchio

Ralph Macchio became a global icon as the star of ‘The Karate Kid’ trilogy during the eighties. He was one of the most recognizable young actors of the decade and also starred in ‘The Outsiders’. As he grew older he found it difficult to shed his association with the Daniel LaRusso character. He worked primarily in theater and smaller film roles for several decades. He achieved a massive career comeback by reprising his most famous role in the hit series ‘Cobra Kai’.

C. Thomas Howell

C. Thomas Howell was a member of the famous Brat Pack after starring in ‘The Outsiders’ and ‘Red Dawn’. He was positioned as a major teen idol and leading man throughout the eighties. Some of his career choices in the late eighties led to a decline in his mainstream appeal. He transitioned into a prolific career in independent films and television guest appearances. He has recently found success in recurring roles on shows like ‘The Walking Dead’ and ‘Animal Kingdom’.

Andrew Keegan

Andrew Keegan was a prominent heartthrob in the late nineties with roles in ’10 Things I Hate About You’ and ‘7th Heaven’. He was a regular fixture in teen magazines and was expected to transition into adult leading roles. He eventually moved away from the traditional Hollywood path to focus on spiritual ventures and community activism. He founded a community center in California which became his primary focus for several years. He still occasionally takes acting roles but remains largely outside the mainstream industry.

Devon Sawa

Devon Sawa gained fame as a young actor in films like ‘Casper’ and ‘Now and Then’. He successfully transitioned to more mature roles in the cult classic ‘Idle Hands’ and the blockbuster ‘Final Destination’. He took a break from acting in the mid-two thousands to step away from the public eye. He returned to the industry and has found success in television series like ‘Nikita’ and ‘Chucky’. He is now appreciated as a veteran actor with a dedicated following in the horror genre.

Breckin Meyer

Breckin Meyer became well known through his roles in ‘Clueless’ and the comedy ‘Road Trip’. He was often cast as the funny best friend or the relatable lead in mid-budget comedies. While he remained a consistent worker he did not become a major leading man in high profile dramas or action films. He found a niche as a voice actor and a writer for the animated series ‘Robot Chicken’. He also starred in the long running legal drama ‘Franklin & Bash’.

Seann William Scott

Seann William Scott became a comedy legend through his role as Stifler in the ‘American Pie’ franchise. This success led to starring roles in other comedies like ‘Dude, Where’s My Car?’ and ‘Role Models’. He found it challenging to break out of the raunchy comedy genre and into more serious dramatic roles. He voiced a character in the ‘Ice Age’ sequels and starred in the ‘Goon’ films. He recently took over a lead role in the television version of ‘Lethal Weapon’.

Jamie Kennedy

Jamie Kennedy rose to fame through his role as Randy Meeks in the ‘Scream’ franchise. He was given his own sketch show ‘The Jamie Kennedy Experiment’ and starred in the comedy ‘Malibu’s Most Wanted’. His attempts to lead larger studio films like ‘Son of the Mask’ were not met with commercial or critical success. He has continued to work in stand up comedy and independent film projects. He remains a recognizable figure in the comedy world and the horror community.

Pauly Shore

Pauly Shore was a massive star on MTV and led a string of successful comedies including ‘Encino Man’ and ‘Bio-Dome’. His unique comedic persona made him a household name in the early nineties. As audience tastes shifted his specific brand of humor became less popular with major film studios. He moved into producing and directing his own projects like the mockumentary ‘Pauly Shore Is Dead’. He continues to perform stand up comedy and maintains a loyal fan base.

Rodrigo Santoro

Rodrigo Santoro was a major star in Brazil before being touted as the next big international lead in Hollywood. He appeared in ‘Charlie’s Angels: Full Throttle’ and played Xerxes in the blockbuster ‘300’. Despite his talent and leading man looks he was often cast in supporting or villainous roles in American films. He found significant success on television in the series ‘Lost’ and ‘Westworld’. He continues to balance a successful career in both the Brazilian and international film markets.

Gael García Bernal

Gael García Bernal became an international sensation through his work in ‘Amores Perros’ and ‘Y tu mamá también’. Hollywood studios were eager to cast him in major English language projects like ‘The King’ and ‘Babel’. While he became a highly respected global star he often preferred artistic international projects over standard Hollywood fare. He won a Golden Globe for his role in the series ‘Mozart in the Jungle’ and provided a voice in ‘Coco’. He remains one of the most acclaimed actors in the world today.

Share your thoughts on which of these actors you were most excited about in the comments.